Discovering the contents of a loved one’s will can be an emotional and difficult experience, especially when the outcome is not what you expected. Questioning a will during a time of bereavement can feel daunting, but sometimes it is a necessary step to ensure a fair and just outcome. If a will seems wrong, unfair, or suspicious, the law in England and Wales provides specific ways to challenge it. This area of law is known as “contentious probate.” This guide is designed to provide a clear and sensitive introduction to the process. It will explain the main grounds for challenging a will’s validity and how to make a claim for financial provision, helping you understand your options during this challenging time.
“Contentious probate” is the legal term for any dispute relating to the administration of a deceased person’s estate. While this can cover many issues, it most commonly refers to a dispute over the validity or fairness of a will. It is the formal process of challenging a will through the court system. This area of law exists to ensure that a deceased person’s final wishes were legally sound and that those they had a responsibility to provide for are not left in hardship.
Disputes typically arise when the contents of a will are surprising or seem unfair to those left behind. For example, a will might unexpectedly exclude a close family member, leave a significant sum to a relative stranger, or divide an estate in a way that seems completely out of character for the deceased. These situations often lead spouses, children, or financial dependants to question whether the will is legally valid or if it makes reasonable financial provision for them. This is the point at which they may need to consider initiating a contentious probate claim.
The first way to challenge a will is to argue that it is legally invalid. It is not enough to feel that the will is unfair or that you deserved more. To have a will completely set aside by a court, a challenger must prove that it fails to meet the strict legal requirements for its creation on one of several specific grounds. The burden of proof rests on the person challenging the will. If the challenge is successful, the will is declared void, and the estate is usually distributed according to the terms of a previous, valid will or the rules of intestacy if there is no other will.
For a will to be valid, the person who made it (the “testator”) must have been of sound mind at the time they signed it. This is known as having “testamentary capacity.”
The Legal Test for Mental Capacity: The courts apply a specific legal test established in the 19th-century case of Banks v Goodfellow. To have capacity, the testator must have understood three key things:
It is a fundamental requirement that the testator knew and approved of the contents of the will they were signing. Usually, if the testator had capacity and signed the will, the court will presume they knew and approved of its contents. However, this presumption can be challenged if there are suspicious circumstances. For example, if the person who benefits most from the will was also the one who prepared it, a court will require positive proof that the testator fully understood and consented to its terms, particularly if they were vulnerable or frail.
A will can be challenged as invalid if it is a forgery. This means proving that the signature on the will is not the testator’s. This often requires the expert evidence of a handwriting specialist. A will can also be invalid on the grounds of fraud, for example, if the testator was deliberately misled about the nature of the document they were signing or if deceitful statements were made to them to poison their mind against a natural beneficiary of their estate.
A will is a formal legal document that must be created in a very specific way to be legally valid. If these formalities are not followed correctly, the will fails.
The Requirements of the Wills Act 1837: This Act of Parliament sets out the core rules for creating a valid will. The key requirements are:
The second main type of will challenge is fundamentally different from a validity claim. This route is available when the will itself is legally valid, but it fails to make “reasonable financial provision” for a person the deceased had a responsibility to support. This claim does not seek to invalidate the entire will; instead, it asks the court to vary the terms of the will to provide for the claimant from the estate. This is a powerful legal tool for those who have been unfairly left out or inadequately provided for.
The law recognises that a person has a moral and social duty to provide for certain family members and dependants. If a valid will fails to do this, the court can intervene. The key legislation is the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. This Act gives the court the power to re-distribute a portion of the estate to make an award for a person’s maintenance. The court will consider a range of factors, including the claimant’s financial needs and resources, the size of the estate, and the needs of the other beneficiaries.
The 1975 Act sets out specific categories of people who are eligible to bring a claim. You cannot make a claim simply because you feel you deserve something; you must fall into one of the following groups:
If you believe you have grounds to challenge a will, either by questioning its validity or by making a claim under the Inheritance Act 1975, there is a formal process to follow. It is a complex legal journey that requires careful navigation from the outset. Acting quickly and seeking expert advice is essential, as there are strict time limits and procedural rules that must be followed. The process is designed to encourage investigation and settlement before a full court hearing becomes necessary, but you must be prepared to take formal steps to protect your position.
This is the single most important practical point. A claim under the Inheritance Act 1975 must be issued at court within six months from the date the Grant of Probate is issued. The Grant of Probate is the legal document that confirms the executors’ authority to administer the estate. This is a very strict deadline, and it is difficult to get permission to bring a claim out of time. It is therefore vital that you seek legal advice as soon as you become aware of a potential issue.
If you have concerns about the validity of a will, you can lodge a “caveat” with the Probate Registry. This is a simple notice that serves to temporarily stop a Grant of Probate from being issued. This freezes the administration of the estate for six months, giving you a crucial window of time to investigate your concerns, gather evidence, and decide whether to proceed with a formal claim without the assets being distributed first.
The courts strongly encourage—and in many cases, expect—the parties involved in a will dispute to try and resolve their differences without going to a final trial. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods are often used. The most common and effective of these is mediation, a confidential meeting where a neutral facilitator helps all parties negotiate a settlement. This can be a far less stressful and more cost-effective way to resolve sensitive family disputes.
If investigations confirm you have a strong case but a settlement cannot be reached through negotiation or mediation, the final step is to issue a formal claim in court. This begins the formal litigation process that will ultimately lead to a judge hearing the case and making a binding decision on the matter. This should always be considered the last resort after all other avenues have been explored.
Handling a will dispute requires not only robust legal knowledge but also a sensitive and pragmatic approach. At TBI (The Barristers Inc), our specialist contentious probate barristers understand the emotional and financial pressures our clients face. We provide clear, strategic, and supportive guidance through every stage of the process. Our aim is to help you understand your legal position clearly, protect your interests, and find the most effective and sensible path to resolving the dispute, allowing you to move forward.
The first step is often the most important. A TBI barrister will conduct a thorough review of your situation and provide a clear, honest, and realistic assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of your potential claim. We will explain the legal principles in plain English, manage your expectations, and help you make a fully informed decision about whether to proceed, ensuring you understand the risks and potential rewards from the outset.
Our barristers are first and foremost expert advocates. This skill is invaluable whether we are representing you in a private mediation, engaging in settlement negotiations with the other side’s lawyers, or presenting your case powerfully before a judge at court. We will fight your corner, ensuring your case is put forward in the most persuasive and effective way possible to achieve the best available outcome for you.
If you are concerned about the contents of a will or feel you have been unfairly provided for, please do not hesitate to act. Contact the specialist contentious probate team at TBI (The Barristers Inc) for a confidential discussion about your case. We are here to provide the sensitive support and expert legal advice you need to handle this difficult time with confidence and clarity.