Home / News / Landlord & Tenant / What Are Restrictive Covenants and How Can a Barrister Help You Modify or Remove Them? 

What Are Restrictive Covenants and How Can a Barrister Help You Modify or Remove Them? 

07 Aug, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

This blog post will explain exactly what restrictive covenants are, how to determine if they are still enforceable, and the legal pathways available to modify or remove them in England and Wales. At TBI (The Barristers Inc), our specialist property barristers are experts in this complex area, and this guide provides the clarity you need to challenge outdated restrictions on your home.

What is a Restrictive Covenant?

In simple terms, a restrictive covenant is a legal obligation written into the title deeds of a property that limits what the owner can do with it. Unlike a personal promise, it is tied to the land itself, meaning it automatically passes from one owner to the next, potentially binding you to a promise made decades or even centuries ago.

A Binding Promise on Your Property

Think of a restrictive covenant as a permanent “rulebook” for the property that “runs with the land.” When you buy the property, you also inherit the obligation to follow the rules in that book. Covenants are often created when a landowner sells off a plot of land and wants to ensure the new owner doesn’t do something that could negatively affect the land they have retained. Their original purpose is typically to preserve the character, value, and amenity of a neighbourhood.

Common Examples of Restrictive Covenants

Restrictive covenants can cover a wide range of activities and uses of a property. While some may seem archaic, many are still highly relevant and can have a significant impact on how you are able to use your home and land.

Restrictions You Might Encounter

Some of the most common examples of restrictive covenants that property owners in the UK may encounter include:

  • Prohibiting further building: Preventing the construction of new buildings or extensions on the land.
  • Restricting business use: Forbidding any trade or business from being operated from the property.
  • Limiting the number of properties: Allowing only one dwelling to be built on the plot of land.
  • Controlling aesthetic changes: Preventing alterations to the external appearance of a property without consent.
  • Prohibiting certain animals: Forbidding the keeping of livestock or a specific type of pet.

Determining if a Covenant is Enforceable

The mere existence of a covenant in your deeds does not automatically mean it is legally enforceable today. Over time, or due to technical defects in how they were created, some covenants lose their legal power. Therefore, a thorough legal assessment of the covenant’s validity is a crucial first step before you attempt to challenge it.

For a covenant to be enforceable, several legal conditions must be met. Firstly, the covenant must “touch and concern” the land, meaning it must relate directly to the use and value of the property, not just be a personal benefit to the original landowner. Secondly, the land that was originally intended to benefit from the covenant must be clearly identifiable. If it’s impossible to determine which neighbouring properties hold the benefit of the covenant, it may be impossible to enforce. An expert legal review is needed to confirm these points.

The Process for Modifying or Removing a Covenant

If you are burdened by an enforceable covenant, you are not without options. The law provides two main pathways for seeking to have it modified or removed, allowing you to move forward with your plans. The best route for you will depend on your specific circumstances and the nature of the covenant itself.

Negotiation and Agreement

The most direct and often most cost-effective route is to negotiate directly with the person or entity who currently benefits from the covenant (the “beneficiary”). If they agree to your proposal, they can formally release you from the obligation by signing a legal document called a “Deed of Release or Variation.” The first step is to identify the benefiting land and its current owners. This approach relies on mutual agreement and often involves paying a sum of compensation.

Application to the Upper Tribunal

When negotiation is not possible perhaps because the beneficiary cannot be identified or refuses to agree the formal route is to make an application to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber). This is a specialist court that has the power to modify or discharge restrictive covenants. The application must be made under specific legal grounds set out in Section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925, and you will need to present a strong, evidence-based case.

You cannot simply ask the Tribunal to remove a covenant because it is inconvenient. You must prove that your case meets one or more of the specific legal grounds laid out in the 1925 Act. The burden of proof is on you, the applicant, to convince the Tribunal that the covenant should be changed or discharged.

Meeting the Requirements of the Law

The Covenant is Obsolete

You can argue that the covenant is now obsolete due to changes in the character of the property or the neighbourhood. For example, a covenant preventing business use in an area that has since become overwhelmingly commercial may be considered obsolete.

The Covenant Impedes Reasonable Use

This ground can be used if the covenant prevents a reasonable use of your land and does not provide any practical benefits of substantial value to the beneficiaries. You must also show that money would be adequate compensation for any loss they might suffer.

The Beneficiaries Have Agreed

If you have sought agreement from all the beneficiaries and they have expressly or implicitly consented to your application to the Tribunal, the covenant can be discharged. This is often used when most, but not all, beneficiaries have agreed.

No Injury to the Beneficiaries

You can argue that the proposed modification or discharge of the covenant will not injure the people who benefit from it. This means you must prove that your plans will not negatively impact the value or amenity of their properties.

How TBI’s Barristers Provide Essential Support

Challenging a restrictive covenant is a complex legal process that requires specialist knowledge of property law and procedure. Whether you are negotiating with a neighbour or preparing a case for the Tribunal, the expertise of a specialist barrister is invaluable. TBI (The Barristers Inc) provides the expert advocacy and advice needed to navigate this challenge successfully.

Initial Assessment and Strategy

The first step is a robust assessment of your position. Our specialist property barristers will conduct a detailed analysis of your title deeds, assess the technical validity and enforceability of the covenant, and advise you on the risks and potential merits of a challenge. Based on this, we will work with you to form a clear strategy, recommending whether negotiation or a formal Tribunal application is the best approach for your specific circumstances and goals.

Expert Negotiation and Representation

Our barristers are skilled in both negotiation and courtroom advocacy. We can act on your behalf to negotiate a Deed of Release with beneficiaries, ensuring your interests are protected throughout the process. If litigation is necessary, we will prepare and present a compelling case to the Upper Tribunal, leveraging our deep knowledge of property law and expert advocacy skills to fight for the modification or discharge of the covenant. If a restrictive covenant is holding you back, contact TBI for a consultation today.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link