Home / News / Property & Boundary Disputes / Commonhold vs. Leasehold: What’s the Best Way to Own a Flat? 

Commonhold vs. Leasehold: What’s the Best Way to Own a Flat? 

21 Oct, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Choosing the right type of ownership for a flat is one of the most significant decisions a person can make. In England and Wales, this choice comes down to two models: leasehold and commonhold. While leasehold has been the traditional and dominant form of ownership for flats, commonhold is a modern alternative designed to address many of its inherent problems. Making an informed decision is vital, as the choice impacts your rights, responsibilities, and the long-term value of your property. At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), we provide expert legal guidance in property and civil litigation, helping you handle this complex landscape with confidence.

Introduction to UK Property Ownership

What Are Leasehold and Commonhold?

In simple terms, leasehold ownership is a long-term rental agreement. A leaseholder does not own the property outright but has the right to occupy it for a fixed period, which can be anywhere from 99 to 999 years. The property’s structure and the land it sits on remain the property of a landlord, known as the freeholder. Commonhold, on the other hand, is a form of outright ownership for flats, where you own the freehold of your individual unit, and all the flat owners collectively own and manage the common parts of the building.

Why This Choice Matters for Flat Owners

The choice between leasehold and commonhold has profound real-world consequences. With leasehold, your ownership is time-limited, which can lead to your property’s value depreciating as the lease shortens. You also have limited control over your building and are often subject to a landlord’s decisions and fees. In contrast, commonhold offers perpetual ownership and the chance to participate directly in the management of your building. This grants a level of control and long-term security that is simply not available under the leasehold system.

Understanding Leasehold Ownership

What a Leasehold Means in Practice

Think of a leasehold as a long-term contract with a landlord, who is known as the freeholder. This contract, or lease, outlines your rights and responsibilities. As a leaseholder, you have the right to live in the flat for the duration of the lease term, but you do not own the land or the building itself. The freeholder retains ownership of the entire building, including the roof, external walls, and common areas. As a result, you are dependent on your freeholder for the maintenance and management of the building’s shared parts.

How Leasehold Works

The Role of the Landlord and Leaseholder

Under a leasehold arrangement, the freeholder is responsible for maintaining the building’s structure and common areas, such as hallways, roofs, and foundations. In return, the leaseholder is obligated to pay ground rent and service charges. Ground rent is a fee for the land the property sits on, for which no service is provided, while service charges cover the cost of maintenance and repairs. The lease also contains specific covenants that the leaseholder must abide by, such as restrictions on pets or alterations to the flat.

Common Issues with Leasehold: Ground Rent and Service Charges

A major pain point for leaseholders is the potential for ground rent to escalate and the lack of control over service charges. In older leases, ground rent can be set to double every 10 or 25 years, making the property difficult to sell. Service charges, which cover everything from cleaning to major roof repairs, can also be a source of frequent disputes. Leaseholders may feel they are being charged for unnecessary or overpriced work, with little recourse to challenge the freeholder’s decisions.

The Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022

In a significant step towards a fairer system, the Leasehold Reform (Ground Rent) Act 2022 came into force for most new residential leases granted after 30 June 2022. The Act effectively caps ground rent on these new leases at a “peppercorn” or zero financial value. While this doesn’t help existing leaseholders, it means that new flat owners will no longer be burdened by the escalating ground rent that has caused so many problems in the past.

Exploring Commonhold Ownership

The Commonhold Alternative

Commonhold was introduced by the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 as a modern and more equitable alternative to leasehold. The core principle is simple: the people who own the flats should also own and manage the building. The system is designed to remove the “landlord and tenant” dynamic and empower homeowners, providing them with greater control and a perpetual interest in their property.

How Commonhold Works

The Commonhold Association: Collective Ownership

A commonhold is managed by a Commonhold Association, which is a private company limited by guarantee. Every flat owner in the building is a member and a director of this company. This structure allows for democratic, collective decision-making on all matters concerning the building’s management, including setting budgets for maintenance, choosing contractors, and enforcing rules. The commonhold association owns the freehold of the common parts of the building, such as the roof, stairs, and gardens.

Key Benefits of Commonhold: No Ground Rent or Lease Expiration

The main advantages of commonhold are the absence of ground rent and the fact that ownership is perpetual. Because the flat owner owns the freehold of their unit, the property’s value does not depreciate over time due to a shortening lease. Furthermore, all costs for the upkeep of the building are transparently managed by the Commonhold Association, which the homeowners themselves control. This eliminates the contentious issues of ground rent and unaccountable service charges found in many leasehold properties.

Financial Implications: Costs and Value

The financial implications of each model are significant. A leasehold property can lose value as the lease term shortens, especially once it drops below 80 years, as extending a lease can be a complex and expensive process. This is a primary concern for owners. In contrast, a commonhold unit, being a perpetual freehold interest, retains its value and does not depreciate. While common holders still pay for maintenance, they have direct control over how that money is spent, which offers greater financial security and transparency.

Leaseholders have certain statutory rights under UK law, such as the right to a lease extension or the right to manage the building, but these are often complex and costly to exercise. They have a landlord-tenant relationship with the freeholder. A common holder, on the other hand, is a co-owner of the common parts and has a legal relationship with the other common holders through the Commonhold Community Statement. Disputes are managed within this collective framework, rather than through a traditional landlord-tenant legal process.

Recent Changes and Future Outlook

The Impact of the Leasehold Reform Act 2022

The 2022 Act has been a game-changer for new leases, effectively ending the practice of charging ground rent. This has made new leasehold properties a more attractive proposition than older ones. While this is a positive step, it does not solve the issues of management and control that remain at the heart of the leasehold system. The ongoing legislative reforms are aimed at making it easier and cheaper for existing leaseholders to extend their leases or buy the freehold of their building.

The Push for Commonhold in the UK

The government is actively promoting commonhold as the preferred model for future flat ownership. The Law Commission has proposed reforms to make it easier to create and manage commonholds, and the government has stated its ambition to make it the default tenure. While commonhold adoption has been slow since its introduction in 2002, the legislative push is designed to make it a more viable and attractive alternative to the often-flawed leasehold system.

Making the Right Choice for Your Situation

Seeking Expert Advice

Deciding whether to buy a leasehold or commonhold flat is a major financial and legal decision. While commonhold offers a more secure and empowering form of ownership, the leasehold system is still dominant. It’s crucial to seek professional legal advice tailored to your specific situation before committing to a purchase. A property barrister can review a lease, explain the legal implications, and advise you on the long-term viability of the investment.

Our Expertise in Property and Civil Litigation

At TBI, our barristers are seasoned experts in property law and civil litigation. We have a deep understanding of both the complexities of the leasehold system and the benefits of the emerging commonhold model. We provide legal advice on all aspects of flat ownership, from advising on the terms of a lease to representing clients in service charge disputes. Our expertise is your assurance that you are making a fully informed decision.

How Our Barristers Can Assist You

Our barristers can provide invaluable assistance whether you are considering a purchase or already own a flat. We can help you with lease extensions, advise on a collective enfranchisement (where leaseholders buy the freehold), and guide you through disputes with a freeholder over service charges. For those considering a commonhold property, we can explain the legal structure and your rights and responsibilities as a member of the Commonhold Association.

Contact TBI for a Consultation

The best way to protect your investment and secure your legal rights as a flat owner is to get expert legal advice. Don’t leave your future to chance. Contact The Barristers Inc. today for a confidential consultation. Our barristers are here to provide the clarity and confidence you need to make the best choice for your property ownership journey.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link