For many charities in the UK, a legacy left in a will is a vital source of income, often funding crucial projects and services. However, this revenue stream is increasingly at risk due to a rise in will disputes. When a will is challenged, the charity’s legacy is under threat, and it can be difficult to know how to respond. This guide provides charities with actionable advice on how to safeguard legacies, from identifying potential issues early to defending the deceased’s wishes when a dispute arises.
Charitable legacies are an essential part of the UK’s philanthropic landscape. They represent a significant portion of the voluntary income received by many non-profit organizations. This type of fundraising is a cost-effective way for charities to raise funds, and it plays a vital role in their long-term financial stability. As a result, charities must be proactive in protecting this income stream from legal challenges.
Despite the importance of legacies, charities often face a difficult position in a will dispute. Unlike a family member, the charity is typically a secondary or residuary beneficiary. This means they often have limited knowledge of the deceased’s personal circumstances, family dynamics, or the events surrounding the will’s creation. This lack of information can put the charity at a disadvantage when a disappointed family member or a former beneficiary decides to challenge the will.
Understanding the legal grounds for a will dispute is the first step in defending a legacy. In England and Wales, a will can be challenged on a number of key grounds.
For a will to be legally valid, it must meet the strict formal requirements of the Wills Act 1837. The requirements are:
One of the most common grounds for challenging a will is lack of testamentary capacity. The legal test for this, established in the case of Banks v Goodfellow, requires the testator to have had a “sound mind” at the time the will was made. The test involves a number of key criteria:
Undue influence is a serious allegation that suggests the testator was coerced into making a will or changing an existing one. This goes beyond mere persuasion and involves a lack of free will on the part of the testator. It is very difficult to prove in court, as the burden of proof lies with the person making the allegation. The court must be convinced that the coercion was so severe that the testator was forced to make a will that did not reflect their true wishes.
Fraudulent calumny, a more subtle form of fraud, involves a person making false, defamatory statements about a potential beneficiary to poison the testator’s mind and cause them to disinherit that person. For a charity, this can arise if a family member makes untrue allegations about another family member to secure a larger inheritance for themselves.
When a charity is notified of a legacy, it should take proactive steps to protect that gift from a potential dispute.
A charity’s legacy team should be trained to spot red flags that may indicate a dispute is brewing. These include:
If a charity identifies any of these red flags, it should act quickly to gather and preserve evidence that may be used to defend the will. This is a crucial step that can make or break a case.
The Larke v Nugus protocol is a vital tool for charities. It is a formal request, typically sent to the solicitor who drafted the will, for a statement about the circumstances of the will’s creation and execution. A solicitor is expected to comply with this request. The response can provide crucial information on the testator’s mental capacity at the time the will was made and whether they acted under any influence. It can also help the charity assess the merits of any potential challenge and decide on a strategy.
Statements from staff and volunteers who knew the deceased can provide crucial evidence. These individuals may be able to provide context on the deceased’s personality, their relationship with their family, and their intentions for their estate. Such statements can provide valuable insight into the deceased’s state of mind and confirm their charitable intentions.
Charities can reduce the risk of future disputes by implementing best practices when accepting legacies. This includes encouraging potential legators to use a qualified solicitor to draft their will, ensuring the charity’s name is correctly spelled in the will, and maintaining a record of the relationship with the deceased where possible.
Once a formal challenge is made, the charity’s response must be swift, strategic, and legally sound.
The charity’s primary legal position is to remain neutral in the dispute. The charity’s role is not to take sides with any of the family members but to uphold the deceased’s wishes as expressed in the will. If a charity is seen to be taking sides or acting with improper motives, a court may make a personal costs order against them, which can be financially devastating.
Litigation can be costly, time-consuming, and can expose the charity to negative publicity. The courts actively encourage parties to use mediation to resolve disputes. Mediation is a confidential and voluntary process where a neutral third party helps the parties reach a mutually agreeable settlement. For a charity, mediation can be an effective way to protect a portion of the legacy, avoid the high costs of litigation, and maintain a positive public image.
At TBI, our barristers are seasoned experts in probate and civil litigation. We have extensive experience in handling will disputes, representing a wide range of clients from individuals to charities. We understand the unique challenges charities face in these matters and provide clear, authoritative advice to protect their legal and financial interests.
Our barristers can assist you in all stages of a will dispute. We can provide an early assessment of the merits of a challenge, assist with a Larke v Nugus request, and help you prepare a robust defense. We can also represent you in mediation, working to secure a favourable settlement, and, if necessary, provide powerful representation in court to ensure the deceased’s wishes are honoured.
A charitable legacy is a precious gift that must be protected. If you are a charity facing a will dispute, do not hesitate to seek expert legal advice. Contact The Barristers Inc. today for a confidential consultation. Our barristers are here to provide the clarity, guidance, and representation you need to safeguard your legacies and your mission.