For individuals coping with the grief of a loved one, finding a will that appears to be made when they were suffering from dementia can be devastating and confusing. It can leave you with the difficult question of whether the will truly reflects your loved one’s final wishes. Fortunately, UK law provides clear legal grounds for challenging a will on the basis of a person’s mental capacity. This guide provides a legal overview and a clear path forward for those concerned that a loved one with dementia lacked the capacity to make a valid will.
Testamentary capacity is the legal term for a person’s mental ability to make a valid will. It is a fundamental requirement in will drafting. If a person does not have the capacity to make a will, the document they sign will be legally invalid, and it can be challenged in court. While many people assume a diagnosis of dementia automatically means a person lacks capacity, this isn’t always the case. The key is their mental state at the time the will was made.
The legal test for testamentary capacity is established in the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870). It requires the person making the will to understand four key elements at the time of signing:
A will made by someone with dementia can be challenged if their illness meant they were unable to pass the Banks v Goodfellow test at the time the will was made. For example, if the dementia was so advanced that the person no longer recognised their children or did not understand they owned a property, their capacity would be called into question. Similarly, if they were suffering from delusions or hallucinations related to their illness, and these delusions influenced them to leave a person out of the will, the will could be declared invalid.
Medical evidence is central to proving or disproving a lack of capacity. It is the single most important type of evidence in a will dispute involving dementia.
For solicitors, a key best practice for a client with a potential mental health issue is to follow the “Golden Rule”. This is a legal guideline that advises a solicitor to have a medical practitioner examine a testator and provide a written opinion on their capacity and understanding before they sign the will. While this is not a legal requirement, a solicitor who follows this rule creates powerful evidence to defend the will against a future challenge.
If a solicitor did not follow the Golden Rule, a person challenging the will will need to obtain their own expert medical opinion. This involves a medical expert reviewing the deceased’s medical history, including their GP and hospital records, and providing a retrospective report on their likely mental state at the time the will was made. This report will be a critical piece of evidence in court.
Undue influence is a separate but often related legal ground for a challenge. This occurs when a person with dementia, who may be vulnerable due to their condition, is coerced or pressured into making a will they would not have made otherwise. The coercion can be subtle, such as emotional blackmail or isolation, and it is a difficult claim to prove. However, a person’s mental frailty due to dementia can make them more susceptible to this type of manipulation, and it is common for both lack of capacity and undue influence to be argued together.
If you suspect a will is invalid, your first and most crucial step is to lodge a caveat with the Probate Registry. A caveat is a legal notice that prevents the Grant of Probate from being issued, effectively “freezing” the estate and giving you time to investigate the will’s validity. It is a quick and inexpensive way to prevent the executor from distributing assets before you have had a chance to build your case.
Building a strong case requires a diligent effort to gather all available evidence.
Statements from people who knew the deceased well—such as family, friends, or carers—can provide valuable insight into their behavior and mental state around the time the will was made. Their testimony can help establish the deceased’s normal cognitive function, their relationships with their beneficiaries, and any signs of confusion or undue influence.
The “Larke v Nugus” protocol is a vital legal tool. It is a formal request sent to the solicitor who drafted the will for a statement explaining the circumstances of the will’s creation. The solicitor’s response can provide crucial information on the testator’s mental capacity, who was present at the signing, and any unusual instructions, which can help you decide whether to proceed with your claim.
A will dispute is a complex legal proceeding. The court will consider all the evidence, including medical reports, witness statements, and the solicitor’s file, to determine whether the will is valid. The process can be stressful, time-consuming, and costly, and the outcome is never guaranteed.
Given the emotional and financial cost of litigation, mediation is often the preferred route for resolving a will dispute. It is a confidential and voluntary process where a neutral third party helps the parties reach a private settlement. This can be a faster and less stressful way to resolve the dispute and protect a portion of the estate, rather than risking everything on a costly court battle.
At TBI, our barristers are seasoned experts in probate and civil litigation. We have extensive experience in handling complex will disputes, particularly those involving allegations of a lack of testamentary capacity due to dementia. We are committed to providing our clients with the legal clarity, guidance, and representation they need to navigate these sensitive cases.
Our barristers can assist you at every stage of the process. We can provide an initial assessment of the merits of your challenge, advise you on the evidence you need to gather, and handle all legal correspondence on your behalf. We can also represent you in mediation to negotiate a settlement or, if necessary, provide robust representation in court to fight for your rights.
A will dispute involving a loved one with dementia is a deeply personal and difficult journey. You don’t have to navigate it alone. Contact The Barristers Inc. today for a confidential consultation. Our barristers are here to provide the expert legal guidance you need to take action.