Home / News / Dispute Resolution / How to Choose the Right Expert Witness for Your Case 

How to Choose the Right Expert Witness for Your Case 

02 Nov, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Suspecting that a loved one’s will is a forgery or a product of deliberate fraud can be devastating. While you may feel helpless, UK law provides clear avenues to challenge a will on these very serious grounds. This guide provides a clear and authoritative overview of the legal process for challenging a will based on forgery or fraudulent calumny, explaining what these concepts mean, the type of evidence required, and the steps you need to take to pursue a claim.

The Principle of Testamentary Freedom

In England and Wales, the legal system is built on the fundamental principle of testamentary freedom. This means that a person has the right to leave their estate to whomever they choose, with very few exceptions. This principle is a cornerstone of English law and is a key reason why challenging a will is so difficult. It means that simply feeling that you were unfairly left out of a will is not enough to challenge it. You must have specific, valid legal grounds to prove that the will is legally invalid. The law assumes a will is valid until proven otherwise, placing the burden of proof squarely on the person making the challenge. This principle is deeply ingrained in the legal system, making it essential to build a strong, evidence-based case before embarking on a challenge.

What Makes a Will Invalid?

A will can be challenged for several reasons. The most common grounds include: a lack of testamentary capacity (the person didn’t have the mental ability to make a will), undue influence (they were coerced into making it), or a failure to meet the formal legal requirements for a valid will. However, forgery and fraud are two of the most serious and complex legal grounds for a challenge, as they imply a deliberate and malicious act of deception. These allegations are so grave that the courts require a higher standard of proof than for other claims, demanding strong, convincing evidence. A person challenging a will on the grounds of fraud or forgery must be prepared for a difficult legal battle that requires expert legal assistance.

Forgery and Fraud in Will Disputes

Proving Forgery: The Role of Forensic Evidence

Forgery is a criminal offence that, in the context of a will, means the document or a signature on it is not genuine. This could be a faked signature of the deceased or a physical alteration to the document itself. Proving forgery is a high legal test that requires robust evidence, and due to the seriousness of the allegation, the standard of proof is higher than the usual “balance of probabilities” for civil cases. A claimant will almost always need to instruct a forensic handwriting expert to examine the disputed document.

The expert will compare the signature on the will with other known examples of the deceased’s handwriting, looking for inconsistencies in pressure, slant, spacing, and the overall formation of letters. The expert’s report, while not always conclusive, can be a critical piece of evidence. However, expert evidence is not always sufficient on its own. It must be supported by other circumstantial evidence, such as the absence of credible witnesses to the signing, or evidence that the will was made under suspicious circumstances.

Understanding Fraudulent Calumny

Fraudulent calumny is a subtle and insidious form of fraud. It occurs when a person deliberately makes false, malicious statements about a potential beneficiary to poison the mind of the deceased, causing them to disinherit that person. To prove this, you must show that the person making the statements knew they were untrue and made them with the specific intention of deceiving the deceased. It is not enough to simply show that a person’s opinion of a beneficiary changed; you must prove that the change was caused by a deliberate and calculated lie. The person making the false statement must be aware that it is untrue or be reckless as to its truth. The legal test for fraudulent calumny is strict and requires the claimant to prove that the lies were the sole reason for the deceased’s decision to disinherit the person.

The Distinction Between Fraudulent Calumny and Undue Influence

While they are related, fraudulent calumny and undue influence are distinct legal grounds. Undue influence involves a person being coerced into making a will against their free will, for example, by threats or physical force. The coercion overpowers the deceased’s ability to make their own decision. The deceased’s mind is not poisoned, but rather their will is overborne. Fraudulent calumny, on the other hand, is a form of deception. The deceased may have freely made their decision, but that decision was based on a fundamental lie told to them by someone with the intention of gaining a benefit. The deceased’s mind is poisoned by the lies, but they make the decision to change their will themselves. This is a subtle but crucial legal distinction that requires expert legal advice to navigate.

The Process of Challenging a Will

Starting the Process: The Caveat

If you suspect a will is invalid, your first formal step is to lodge a caveat with the Probate Registry. A caveat is a legal notice that prevents the Grant of Probate from being issued. This effectively “freezes” the estate and gives you time to investigate the will’s validity before the executor can distribute any assets. A caveat lasts for six months and can be renewed. It is a crucial first step to stop the administration of the estate and prevent assets from being sold or given away, which could make a successful challenge meaningless.

The Importance of Evidence

The success of any will challenge, especially one based on forgery or fraud, hinges on the quality and strength of the evidence you can provide.

The Role of Witness Statements

Statements from people who knew the deceased, such as family, friends, or carers, can provide crucial context. They may be able to provide insight into the deceased’s relationship with the beneficiaries, their state of mind, and any unusual circumstances surrounding the will’s creation. Their testimony can be used to support allegations of undue influence or fraudulent calumny, as they can speak to the deceased’s character and intentions.

Gathering Medical Records and Correspondence

Medical records can be invaluable in a will dispute. If you suspect the deceased lacked the mental capacity to make the will, their medical history can provide evidence of any cognitive decline, dementia, or other illnesses. Correspondence, such as emails, letters, or diaries, can also be crucial in revealing the deceased’s true intentions and feelings, which may contradict what is in the will.

The Outcome of a Successful Challenge

The Effect on the Will

If a court finds a will to be invalid on the grounds of forgery or fraudulent calumny, it will be declared null and void. The court will order the Grant of Probate to be revoked, and the will will be set aside. The estate will then be treated as if that will never existed. The person found to be responsible for the fraud or forgery may also be ordered to pay the legal costs of the challenge and may face criminal charges.

Distribution of the Estate: Intestacy or a Previous Will

After a successful challenge, the court will look to see if there is a previous, valid will in existence. If there is, the estate will be distributed according to the terms of that will. If no previous valid will can be found, the deceased will be deemed to have died intestate, and the estate will be distributed according to the strict rules of intestacy as set out in UK law. These rules provide a fixed hierarchy of beneficiaries, typically starting with the deceased’s spouse and children.

Our Expertise in Probate and Civil Litigation

At TBI, our barristers are seasoned experts in probate and civil litigation. We have extensive experience in handling complex will disputes, particularly those involving allegations of forgery and fraud. We understand the legal and procedural complexities of these cases and are committed to helping our clients navigate them successfully.

How Our Barristers Can Assist You

Our barristers can assist you at every stage of a will challenge. We can provide an initial assessment of the merits of your claim, advise you on the evidence you need to gather, and represent you in court. Our expertise in litigation and our commitment to our clients ensure that you have the best possible chance of securing a successful outcome and upholding your loved one’s true wishes.

Contact TBI for a Consultation

A will challenge is a serious and complex undertaking that should not be attempted without expert legal guidance. Contact The Barristers Inc. today for a confidential consultation. Our barristers are here to provide the clarity and guidance you need to take action.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link