Home / News / Corporate & Contract / Liquidated Damages vs Penalty Clauses: What’s Enforceable? 

Liquidated Damages vs Penalty Clauses: What’s Enforceable? 

03 Sep, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Many commercial contracts in the UK include a clause that pre-determines a specific sum to be paid if one of the parties breaches the agreement. These clauses are designed to provide certainty and avoid the time and cost of litigation. However, a key legal distinction exists between liquidated damages and penalty clauses, and only the former are legally enforceable. This post will clarify that crucial difference and explain the modern legal test used by UK courts, including the landmark Cavendish v Makdessi case. At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), our barristers specialise in these complex contractual issues, offering expert legal advice on drafting and challenging such clauses.

What Are Liquidated Damages and Penalty Clauses?

Understanding the fundamental difference between these two clauses is essential to ensuring a contract is legally sound. The distinction hinges on the purpose and intention behind the sum stipulated.

Liquidated Damages

A liquidated damages clause is a contractual provision that specifies a fixed, reasonable sum to be paid in the event of a breach. The key requirement is that the sum must be a genuine pre-estimate of the loss that the innocent party would suffer. This estimate should be made at the time the contract is formed, not at the time of the breach. For example, in a construction contract, a clause that requires the contractor to pay £500 for each day a project is delayed would be considered liquidated damages if that sum is a reasonable estimation of the daily costs the client would incur, such as lost revenue or additional rental costs.

Penalty Clauses

In contrast, a penalty clause is a sum intended to punish or deter a party from a breach, rather than to compensate for a genuine loss. English law has long held that penalty clauses are unenforceable. Courts view them as an oppressive form of punishment that violates the principle that contract law should be compensatory, not punitive. Even if a clause is labelled “liquidated damages,” a court will look at its substance. If the sum is disproportionate or extravagant compared to the actual loss, it will be deemed a penalty and struck out from the contract.

For over a century, the test for identifying a penalty clause focused on whether the sum was a “genuine pre-estimate of loss.” However, the UK Supreme Court provided a new, more nuanced approach in the landmark 2015 case of Cavendish Square Holding BV v Makdessi (and the conjoined case of ParkingEye Ltd v Beavis).

The New Approach from “Cavendish Square v Makdessi”

The Supreme Court in Cavendish clarified that the rule against penalties applies only to secondary obligations that are triggered by a breach of a primary obligation. The court established that the correct test is whether the clause imposes a detriment on the contract-breaker that is out of all proportion to any legitimate interest of the innocent party in the enforcement of the primary obligation. This new test is much broader and more commercially-focused than the old one.

Legitimate Commercial Interest

Under the new test, a clause is not a penalty if it protects a legitimate commercial interest of the innocent party, even if it is not a direct pre-estimate of loss. This interest can extend beyond mere financial compensation for the breach. For example, in Cavendish, the court found that the buyer of a company had a legitimate interest in preventing the seller from competing, and the clause that penalised the seller for breaching this was therefore not a penalty.

Proportionality

Even with a legitimate interest, the detriment imposed must be proportionate to that interest. A clause will still be deemed a penalty if the sum or remedy is extravagant, exorbitant, or unconscionable. The court will look at the specific context of the contract and the commercial relationship between the parties to make this assessment.

The Consequences of a Penalty Clause

When a court rules that a clause is an unenforceable penalty, there are significant legal consequences for the parties involved.

A Penalty Clause is Unenforceable

If a court finds that a clause is a penalty, it will simply strike the clause out of the contract. The innocent party cannot rely on that clause to claim the pre-determined sum. Instead, they must then pursue a claim for unliquidated damages and prove their actual losses in the traditional way, which can be a more difficult and expensive process. The burden of proving the actual loss shifts back to the innocent party, eliminating the benefit of the clause.

Your Rights if a Clause is a Penalty

If you are a party being pursued under a clause that you believe is a penalty, you may have a valid defense. You should seek legal advice to argue that the clause is an unenforceable penalty under the new Cavendish test. If successful, you will not have to pay the sum stipulated in the contract, and the other party will be required to prove their actual losses, which may be significantly lower.

How The Barristers Inc. (TBI) Can Assist

At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), we provide expert, direct access legal services to help individuals and businesses with all aspects of commercial contract law in England and Wales. Our barristers have a deep understanding of the intricacies of the Cavendish test and its implications.

Drafting and Reviewing Contracts

We can assist you in drafting contracts with legally sound and enforceable liquidated damages clauses that are designed to withstand a legal challenge. Our barristers can also review your existing contracts to identify any clauses that may be at risk of being deemed unenforceable penalties, helping you to mitigate future risks.

Advising on the Enforceability of a Clause

If you are in a dispute over a contract, we can provide a professional legal opinion on the enforceability of a specific clause. We will analyse the contract’s terms and the commercial context to determine if the clause meets the Cavendish test, advising you on the best legal strategy to pursue.

Our Expertise in Civil Litigation

TBI has a proven track record in all areas of civil litigation, particularly in complex commercial contract disputes. Our in-depth knowledge of UK law allows us to provide reliable and effective legal advice. If you are concerned about a liquidated damages or penalty clause, contact The Barristers Inc. today for professional assistance.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link