The relationship between a franchisor and a franchisee is a unique and often complex legal partnership. It’s built on mutual trust and the shared goal of brand success, but it’s also a commercial relationship with distinct legal obligations. Unfortunately, this can lead to disputes that are both costly and time-consuming. This guide outlines the five most common legal conflicts that arise in the franchising sector in England and Wales. We will explain how they can be avoided and how barristers from The Barristers Inc. (TBI) can provide the expert legal assistance needed to resolve them.
The legal foundation of any franchise is the contract that binds the parties together. Unlike in some other countries, there is no specific “franchise law” in the UK. Instead, the relationship is governed by general principles of English contract law, as well as relevant legislation such as competition law.
The franchise agreement is the core legal document that outlines the rights and obligations of both the franchisor and the franchisee. It is a detailed and often lengthy contract that defines the terms of the relationship, including the use of intellectual property, the fees payable, the territory, and the standards of operation. A clear, well-drafted agreement is the first and most important step in avoiding disputes, as it provides a clear roadmap for the parties to follow.
The concept of a duty of good faith is not a strict rule in English contract law, unlike in some other jurisdictions. However, courts may consider the conduct of the parties when interpreting a contract and exercising their discretion. While a franchisor isn’t explicitly required to act in “good faith,” the courts will scrutinise actions that are considered to be arbitrary, unreasonable, or lacking in commercial justification, and this can influence the outcome of a dispute.
One of the most common causes of a dispute is a claim for misrepresentation. This can arise when a franchisor makes a false statement of fact before the franchise agreement is signed, and the franchisee relies on that statement to enter into the contract.
While there is no general duty in English law for a franchisor to disclose all information to a potential franchisee, any statements they do make must be truthful and accurate. This is particularly important for financial projections or claims about the expected profitability of the franchise.
If a franchisee can prove that they were induced to sign the agreement by a false statement, they may have a claim for misrepresentation under the Misrepresentation Act 1967. The legal remedy for this can be rescission of the contract, which unwinds the agreement and places the parties back in the position they were in before the contract was signed, or an award of damages to compensate for financial losses.
A breach of the franchise agreement is a common source of conflict, with both franchisors and franchisees capable of failing to uphold their end of the bargain.
A franchisor can be in breach of the agreement if they fail to provide the promised support, training, or marketing to the franchisee. For example, if the franchisor doesn’t provide the promised operating manual, or fails to deliver ongoing training and support as required by the agreement, the franchisee may have a claim. Similarly, a franchisor might be in breach if they encroach on a franchisee’s exclusive territory by opening a new competing branch.
Franchisees can also breach the agreement in various ways, often by failing to adhere to the strict standards required by the brand. Examples include a failure to pay royalties or other fees, a refusal to maintain the brand’s operational standards, or operating outside of their designated territory.
The termination of a franchise agreement is a serious matter, as it can result in the loss of a business for the franchisee and can lead to a legal battle over the terms of the exit.
A franchise agreement must be terminated in accordance with its terms. Most agreements will have a clause that allows a party to terminate in the event of a material breach by the other side. This is a serious breach that goes to the root of the contract and cannot be easily remedied.
After a franchise agreement ends, restrictive covenants often apply. These clauses are designed to protect the franchisor’s business by preventing the former franchisee from competing with the brand for a specific period of time or from soliciting the franchisor’s clients or employees. A court will only enforce these clauses if they are reasonable in their scope and are necessary to protect a legitimate business interest of the franchisor.
Financial disagreements are a frequent cause of legal conflict. The franchise agreement will set out the fees payable, but disputes can arise over the calculation or fairness of those fees.
Many franchise agreements give the franchisor the right to audit a franchisee’s books to ensure that the correct royalties and fees are being paid. A dispute can arise when an audit finds discrepancies or when a franchisee refuses to cooperate with the audit.
A franchisee may claim that the fees or other charges, such as marketing contributions, are unfair or disproportionate. While courts are generally reluctant to interfere with commercial agreements freely entered into, a barrister can advise a franchisee on whether a clause is so disproportionate as to be considered an unenforceable penalty.
A franchise is built on a brand’s intellectual property (IP), including its trademarks, logos, and business systems. Misuse of this IP is a serious breach.
A franchisor has a legal duty to protect the integrity of its trademarks and other IP. If a franchisee’s actions damage the brand’s reputation, the franchisor may have a claim against them. Conversely, if a franchisor fails to protect the brand from infringement by third parties, a franchisee could argue that the franchisor has breached their obligations under the agreement.
A franchisee can be sued for intellectual property infringement if they misuse the brand’s IP, such as by selling unauthorised products or continuing to use the brand’s name or logo after the agreement has been terminated. This is a serious legal issue that can result in a claim for damages and an injunction to prevent further use.
At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), we provide expert, direct access legal services to both franchisors and franchisees in England and Wales. Our barristers are specialists in civil litigation and franchise law, offering professional guidance and representation to help you navigate these complex disputes.
The best way to resolve a dispute is to seek legal advice early. Our barristers can provide a thorough assessment of your case, helping you to understand your rights and obligations, and advising you on the best strategic approach to protect your interests. This early intervention can often lead to a swift resolution, saving you time and money.
Our barristers can represent you at every stage of the dispute resolution process, from drafting a formal letter of claim or response, to representing you in negotiations, mediation, and formal court proceedings. Our expertise in advocacy ensures that your case is presented with authority and precision to achieve the best possible outcome.
TBI has a proven track record in successfully handling a wide range of civil litigation matters, including complex franchise disputes. Our in-depth knowledge of UK contract law and the nuances of franchising allows us to provide reliable, effective, and tailored legal advice. If you are facing a franchise dispute, contact The Barristers Inc. today for expert assistance.