Unexpected events from natural disasters and pandemics to government actions and civil unrest can make it difficult, or even impossible, to perform contractual obligations. When this happens, businesses and individuals must look to their contracts to determine their rights and liabilities. This post will clarify the legal principles of force majeure and the doctrine of frustration, two distinct concepts for dealing with unforeseen events. We will also outline the requirements for a legally sound force majeure clause and how The Barristers Inc. (TBI) can assist in drafting, enforcing, and disputing these clauses.
In English law, there is no inherent legal doctrine of force majeure. This means that a party cannot simply claim “force majeure” to excuse their non-performance unless the contract explicitly contains a clause to that effect. This is the fundamental difference between a force majeure clause and the doctrine of frustration.
The doctrine of frustration is a common law principle that automatically terminates a contract when an unforeseen event occurs, through no fault of either party, that makes performance of the contract impossible or so radically different from what was originally agreed that it would be unjust to hold the parties to it. For instance, if a venue for an event burns down, the contract for its use would be frustrated. However, the legal bar for proving frustration is very high. An event that simply makes a contract more expensive or difficult to perform will not be sufficient. The event must fundamentally change the nature of the obligation.
A force majeure clause is a contractual provision that allows parties to define their own terms for handling unforeseen events. It provides far greater flexibility than the doctrine of frustration, which only applies in very limited circumstances and automatically terminates the contract. A force majeure clause can specify that a contract’s obligations are merely suspended, that deadlines are extended, or that a party has the right to terminate if the event persists for a long period. This allows the parties to manage risk in a way that best suits their commercial interests.
Because force majeure is a creation of contract, its enforceability depends entirely on the specific wording of the clause. A court will interpret the clause using the usual rules of contractual interpretation, but will apply a strict and literal approach, particularly to clauses that excuse a party from performance.
For a force majeure clause to be enforceable, it must clearly define the events that will trigger it. Vagueness can render the clause void for uncertainty. The events listed must be beyond the parties’ reasonable control.
A well-drafted clause will either provide an exhaustive list of specific events (e.g., “fire, flood, war, civil unrest, or a pandemic”) or a general catch-all phrase (e.g., “any event beyond the reasonable control of the parties”). The most robust clauses use a combination of both. For example, a clause might list specific events and then add a general phrase like, “or any other similar event beyond the reasonable control of the affected party.”
Even if a qualifying event occurs, the party relying on the clause must prove a causal link between the event and their inability to perform their obligations. It is not enough that the event has happened; it must be the sole or substantial cause of the non-performance. If the party was unable to perform for another reason (e.g., pre-existing financial issues), the force majeure clause will likely be invalid.
Most force majeure clauses, either expressly or implicitly, require the affected party to have taken all reasonable steps to mitigate the impact of the event. This means they must have done everything they reasonably could to avoid the non-performance. For instance, if a supplier’s factory is destroyed by a fire, they may have a duty to try to find an alternative supplier or another method of fulfilling their obligations. Failure to mitigate can render the force majeure claim unsuccessful.
If you believe a force majeure event has occurred, you must follow the correct procedure to successfully rely on the clause.
Most force majeure clauses contain a notice requirement. This is a crucial procedural step that must be followed precisely. The contract will likely specify:
The consequences of a successful force majeure claim depend entirely on the wording of the clause. Unlike the doctrine of frustration, which terminates the contract, a force majeure clause can have a number of outcomes, including:
At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), we provide expert, direct access legal services to help individuals and businesses in England and Wales with contract-related issues. Our barristers are specialists in civil litigation and contract law.
Whether you are seeking to invoke a force majeure clause or are challenging one, our barristers can provide a professional legal opinion on its enforceability. We will analyse the specific wording of the clause, assess the facts of your case, and advise you on the strength of your position under English law.
If a dispute arises, our barristers can represent you at every stage, from drafting formal correspondence to representing you in negotiations, mediation, and court proceedings. We will ensure that your case is presented with authority and precision to achieve the best possible outcome.
TBI has a proven track record in successfully handling complex civil litigation matters, including a wide range of contract disputes. Our in-depth knowledge of UK law allows us to provide reliable, effective, and tailored legal advice. If you have questions about a force majeure clause, contact The Barristers Inc. today for professional assistance.