FAQ
Home / FAQs / Property & Boundary Disputes / What Is a “Right of Way” and How Can it Cause a Property Dispute?

What Is a “Right of Way” and How Can it Cause a Property Dispute?

What is a “Right of Way”? A Foundational Understanding

A right of way is a legal easement, a right that allows one party to use the land of another for a specific purpose. This is a fundamental concept within English property law, where the law balances the rights of a landowner to enjoy their property with the necessary rights of another to access their own land. This legal right is not a physical part of the land itself but an incorporeal hereditament—an intangible right that can be inherited and transferred with the land.

There are two main types of rights of way: public rights of way and private rights of way. A public right of way, such as a footpath or bridleway, is a right for all members of the public to pass over land, and these are often maintained by the local authority. In contrast, a private right of way is a right held by one specific landowner (the dominant tenement) to use a portion of a neighbour’s land (the servient tenement) for a specific purpose, such as access. This legal relationship creates a direct link between the two properties, and the right is generally tied to the land, not the individual who owns it. The right is not merely a courtesy; it is an enforceable legal interest that can be a source of significant conflict if not properly understood and respected.

The Legal Framework: Dominant and Servient Tenements

At the heart of any private right of way is the legal relationship between the two properties involved. The dominant tenement is the property that benefits from the right of way. For example, if your property is landlocked and you have a right of way over a neighbour’s driveway to access the main road, your property is the dominant tenement. The servient tenement is the property over which the right of way runs—the land that is burdened by the easement. The rights of the dominant tenement owner and the obligations of the servient tenement owner are often the source of disputes. The servient tenement owner, while having to accommodate the right of way, is still entitled to the reasonable use and enjoyment of their land. Conversely, the dominant tenement owner must not exceed the scope of their right.

The Creation of a Private Right of Way: How Legal Rights Arise

A private right of way does not simply exist; it must be created through one of several legally recognised methods. Understanding how a right of way was established is crucial in any dispute, as it defines the scope and limitations of the right.

Express Grant or Reservation

The most straightforward way to create a right of way is through an express grant. This occurs when a landowner formally grants an easement to another, typically documented in a deed of transfer or a separate legal document. For example, when a large piece of land is subdivided and sold off, a right of way may be expressly granted over one plot to allow access to another. Conversely, a right of way can also be reserved when a landowner sells part of their land but wants to retain the right to use the part they have sold. These rights are usually clearly defined in legal documents and registered at the Land Registry, which helps to prevent future misunderstandings.

Acquisition by Prescription

A right of way can also be acquired through long-term use under the principle of prescription. This is a common and often contentious way for rights to arise. To establish a prescriptive right, the use of the way must meet specific legal criteria, which include:

  • Continuous use: The right must have been used consistently over a long period. The Prescription Act 1832 sets a minimum period of 20 years for uninterrupted use.
  • “As of right”: The use must be without force, without secrecy, and without permission (or “nec vi, nec clam, nec precario”). If the use was secret, or if the servient landowner expressly gave permission, a prescriptive right cannot be claimed.
  • Without force: The use must not have involved a physical struggle or overt conflict.
  • Without secrecy: The use must have been open and apparent to the servient landowner, who could have, if they wished, prevented it.
  • Without permission: If the landowner gave permission, the use is considered a licence and cannot ripen into an easement. The user must be acting “as of right,” believing they are legally entitled to use the way.

Implied Grant or Reservation

In some cases, a right of way can be implied. This typically happens when land is sold without explicitly granting or reserving an easement, but the right of way is necessary for the reasonable enjoyment of the property. This could be, for example, a situation where a property is sold with an existing access road that is clearly visible and has been used for a long time. The law will often imply a grant to ensure the property is not rendered unusable.

Why a Right of Way Becomes a Property Dispute

Despite the clear legal principles, right of way issues are a leading cause of neighbour disputes. The vagueness of the legal documentation or the informal nature of their creation often leads to conflict.

Obstruction and Interference

The most common cause of disputes is obstruction of the right of way. This can take many forms, from intentionally building a fence or gate that blocks access to more subtle forms of interference, such as parking vehicles on the right of way, allowing vegetation to grow over it, or storing materials that impede passage. The dominant tenement owner has a right to “the full and unimpeded use of the way,” and any significant obstruction is a breach of the easement.

Disputes Over Scope and Extent

Another frequent issue is a disagreement over the scope of the right of way. What does the easement actually permit? Is it for pedestrian access only, or does it include vehicular access? Is it a right to pass and repass, or does it also include a right to park? The legal documents that created the right often do not foresee all future uses. A common question a client might ask is:

“My neighbour is now driving a lorry over the access way. My property title deeds only say ‘right of way.’ Does this cover large vehicles?”

The answer depends on the original grant and the circumstances at the time it was created. If the grant was made when the dominant tenement was a residential property, a court might rule that it only extends to normal residential use. However, if the property has since been converted to a commercial business, a court may deem the new use to be excessive and an unreasonable burden on the servient tenement.

Maintenance and Repair Obligations

The duty to maintain a right of way is another flashpoint for disputes. Who is responsible for the cost of repairs? The common law position is that the dominant tenement owner (the one who benefits from the right) is responsible for the cost of maintenance, while the servient tenement owner has no general obligation to repair the way. However, disputes arise when the servient owner takes steps that damage the right of way or refuses to cooperate with necessary repairs.

Resolving Right of Way Disputes: The Legal Remedies

When communication breaks down and a dispute escalates, parties must turn to legal remedies. In England and Wales, these include:

  • Seeking a Declaratory Judgment: A party can ask a court to make a formal declaration of the rights and obligations of both parties. This provides a legally binding clarification of the extent and scope of the easement.
  • Applying for an Injunction: If there is a persistent and significant obstruction, the dominant tenement owner can apply to the court for an injunction to prevent further interference. An injunction is a powerful remedy that can compel the servient landowner to remove the obstruction.
  • Claiming Damages: If a party has suffered a loss as a result of the obstruction or interference, they can seek damages to compensate for the harm caused. For example, a business that lost revenue due to being unable to access its premises might claim damages.

TBI (The Barristers Inc.) Can Assist with Your Right of Way Dispute

Navigating the complexities of property law requires expertise and a firm understanding of the legal principles involved. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our team of expert barristers is on hand to provide comprehensive legal services tailored to your specific needs. Right of way disputes can be emotionally and financially draining, and our role is to provide clear, actionable advice to help you resolve the matter efficiently.

Our Expertise in Property and Boundary Disputes

Our firm specialises in civil litigation, dispute resolution, and property and boundary disputes. Our barristers have extensive experience in advising both dominant and servient tenement owners on their legal rights and obligations. We can help you:

  • Analyse your title deeds and other legal documents to determine the nature and scope of the easement.
  • Assess the validity of a claim based on prescriptive rights.
  • Draft and send legal correspondence to your neighbour to open a line of negotiation and seek a resolution.
  • Represent you in court if a legal resolution is necessary, advocating for your position and seeking an appropriate remedy, such as an injunction or damages.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Can a Barrister Help with Disputes Involving Tenants or Landlords?  
Yes, a barrister can be of significant help in landlord-tenant disputes in England and Wales. While solicitors often manage the initial case work, barristers are specialist advocates who provide expert...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Do I Handle a Dispute Over a Shared Fence or Wall?  
Disputes over shared fences or walls are a common source of conflict between neighbours. While they may seem minor, these disagreements can escalate quickly and have serious legal and financial...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Is a Restrictive Covenant, and How Can it Affect My Property?  
A restrictive covenant is a legally binding covenant that imposes a negative obligation on a landowner, restricting the way they can use their property for the benefit of another piece...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Is a Surveyor’s Role in a Boundary Dispute?  
A surveyor's role in a boundary dispute is to act as a technical expert, providing an unbiased and evidence-based professional opinion on the location of a property boundary. They are...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Kind of Evidence is Needed to Prove a Boundary Line?  
Defining the exact line where one property ends and another begins can be a source of significant stress and dispute between neighbours. While you might assume your property’s title deeds...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link