FAQ
Home / FAQs / Property & Boundary Disputes / What Is a Restrictive Covenant, and How Can it Affect My Property?  

What Is a Restrictive Covenant, and How Can it Affect My Property?  

A restrictive covenant is a legally binding covenant that imposes a negative obligation on a landowner, restricting the way they can use their property for the benefit of another piece of land. Essentially, it’s a promise not to do something on your land, and this promise “runs with the land,” meaning it is enforceable not just against the person who made it, but against all future owners of the burdened property. Unlike an easement, which is a positive right to use another’s land, a restrictive covenant prevents a certain use. Its purpose is to preserve the character and value of a neighbouring property or a wider area, and this is why they are so crucial to understand.

The Creation and Common Forms of Covenants

Restrictive covenants are typically created when a larger piece of land is sold in plots. The original landowner, in the deed of transfer, will impose restrictions on the land being sold to protect the land they are keeping. This creates a relationship between the two parcels: the servient land (the plot being sold) is burdened by the covenant, while the dominant land (the retained land) benefits from it. The legal principles behind this were established in the landmark case of Tulk v Moxhay (1848), which held that a restrictive covenant could be enforced against a subsequent purchaser who had notice of the covenant.

What Covenants Typically Restrict

Covenants can restrict a wide variety of activities, often to preserve a particular aesthetic or residential character. Common examples include:

  • Building Restrictions: “Not to erect more than one dwelling on the land.” This is common in residential areas to prevent overcrowding.
  • Use of Property: “Not to use the property for any purpose other than as a private residence.” This prevents a property from being converted into a business or commercial premises.
  • Alterations: “Not to alter the exterior of the property without the prior consent of the landowner.” This is often seen on estates to maintain a uniform architectural style.
  • Nuisance: “Not to cause a nuisance or annoyance to the owners of the neighbouring property.”

A client might ask:

  • “I want to build an extension on my house. My deeds have a covenant saying I can’t build any more than one house. Does this stop my extension?”
  • No, in this case, the covenant restricts the erection of an additional “house” or “dwelling,” which is distinct from an extension to the existing property. However, if the covenant restricted any “alterations” or “buildings,” the position would be different. This demonstrates the importance of the specific wording of the covenant.

Enforcing, Discharging, and Modifying Covenants

Understanding who can enforce a covenant and how it can be removed is essential for any property owner.

Who Can Enforce a Covenant?

A restrictive covenant can only be enforced by the owner of the benefited land. In most cases, this will be the current owner of the original dominant land. The covenant is noted on the title deeds of the burdened land, which puts all subsequent owners on notice of its existence. If a burdened owner breaches the covenant, the owner of the benefited land can seek legal recourse, most commonly an injunction to stop the breach and, in some cases, a claim for damages.

The Legal Process for Removal

A restrictive covenant can be removed or modified, but it’s a complex legal process that requires more than just a passage of time. The primary route is to apply to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber) under Section 84 of the Law of Property Act 1925. The Tribunal has the power to discharge or modify a covenant on several grounds, including:

  • Obsolescence: If the character of the neighbourhood has changed so drastically that the covenant is no longer relevant. For example, a covenant restricting the land to residential use might be deemed obsolete in an area that has become heavily commercial.
  • Impeding Reasonable Use: If the covenant impedes a reasonable use of the land and provides no practical benefits of substantial value to the person entitled to enforce it.
  • Agreement: If all parties who benefit from the covenant agree to its discharge.

It is a difficult process, as the burden of proof is on the applicant to convince the Tribunal that the covenant should be altered or removed.

How TBI (The Barristers Inc.) Can Assist

Restrictive covenants are often the source of major property disputes, particularly for those looking to develop or alter their land. Interpreting them correctly and understanding their enforceability requires expert legal advice. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our team of expert barristers provides comprehensive legal services to help you navigate these complex issues.

Our Expertise in Property and Boundary Disputes

Our firm specialises in civil litigation, dispute resolution, and property and boundary disputes. Our barristers have extensive experience in advising both landowners who wish to enforce a covenant and those who are seeking to challenge or remove one. We can help you:

  • Assess Enforceability: We can provide a clear legal opinion on whether a covenant is valid and enforceable against your property.
  • Advise on Breach: We can advise on the legal implications of a potential breach and the options available to you, whether as the party in breach or the party seeking to enforce.
  • Representation at the Tribunal: We can prepare and represent you in an application to the Upper Tribunal (Lands Chamber), providing the legal expertise required to present a compelling case for the modification or discharge of a covenant.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Can a Barrister Help with Disputes Involving Tenants or Landlords?  
Yes, a barrister can be of significant help in landlord-tenant disputes in England and Wales. While solicitors often manage the initial case work, barristers are specialist advocates who provide expert...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Do I Handle a Dispute Over a Shared Fence or Wall?  
Disputes over shared fences or walls are a common source of conflict between neighbours. While they may seem minor, these disagreements can escalate quickly and have serious legal and financial...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Is a Restrictive Covenant, and How Can it Affect My Property?  
A restrictive covenant is a legally binding covenant that imposes a negative obligation on a landowner, restricting the way they can use their property for the benefit of another piece...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Is a Surveyor’s Role in a Boundary Dispute?  
A surveyor's role in a boundary dispute is to act as a technical expert, providing an unbiased and evidence-based professional opinion on the location of a property boundary. They are...Read More
Toggle Icon
What Kind of Evidence is Needed to Prove a Boundary Line?  
Defining the exact line where one property ends and another begins can be a source of significant stress and dispute between neighbours. While you might assume your property’s title deeds...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link