Home / News / Will & Probate / Can You Challenge a Will Due to Dementia or a Medical Condition? 

Can You Challenge a Will Due to Dementia or a Medical Condition? 

14 Nov, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

When a loved one passes away, discovering that their will appears to be inconsistent with their long-held intentions or seems to make an irrational distribution of assets can be both emotionally distressing and legally confusing. These concerns often arise when the deceased had been suffering from a medical condition like dementia. In England and Wales, a will can be challenged on the grounds that the person making it lacked the necessary “testamentary capacity.” This is a complex area of law, but it provides a clear legal avenue for those who believe a will is invalid. It is a sensitive issue, but with the right legal guidance, it is possible to contest such a will.

What is “Testamentary Capacity”?

“Testamentary capacity” is the legal and mental ability required for a person to make a valid will. It’s not a general test of mental capacity but a very specific one that applies only to the act of writing a will. The test for testamentary capacity is established in the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870), and it remains the cornerstone of this area of law.

For a will to be legally valid in England and Wales, it must meet several requirements. In addition to being in writing, signed by the person making it (the “testator”), and witnessed by two people, the testator must have the mental capacity to make the will at the time of its execution. This means they must fully understand the document they are signing. Without this, the will is invalid, and the estate will be distributed according to a previous valid will or the rules of intestacy.

The Key Elements of Testamentary Capacity (The Banks v Goodfellow Test)

The legal test from Banks v Goodfellow requires the person making the will to satisfy four key elements:

  • Understand the nature of the act: The testator must be aware that they are making a will and understand its effect, which is to dispose of their property after their death.
  • Know the extent of their property: They must have a general understanding of the property they own, even if they can’t recall every single asset or bank account balance.
  • Comprehend the claims on their estate: The testator must be able to remember and appreciate the moral claims of potential beneficiaries. This includes close family members who would normally expect to inherit, even if the testator chooses to exclude them from the will.
  • Not suffer from a “disorder of the mind”: They must not be suffering from any delusion or other medical condition that would influence their decisions about their property and lead them to dispose of it in a way they would not have done if they had been of sound mind. A person may have delusions, but if those delusions do not affect the will, the will can still be valid.

How Dementia and Medical Conditions Affect a Will

A diagnosis of dementia or another cognitive impairment does not automatically mean a person lacks testamentary capacity. However, it can raise a “real doubt” about their capacity, shifting the burden of proof to those who wish to uphold the will. In these cases, medical evidence becomes a critical component of any challenge.

Medical Evidence and its Role

An expert medical opinion on the deceased’s mental state at the time the will was made is often the most important piece of evidence. This opinion, usually provided by a geriatric psychiatrist or another specialist, is based on a review of the deceased’s medical records, including notes from their GP and any hospital admissions. It will also consider statements from witnesses and family members who can describe the deceased’s behaviour and mental state at the relevant time.

Proving a Lack of Capacity

The law operates on a presumption of capacity. This means the court will assume that the person who made the will had the capacity to do so, especially if the will was professionally drafted and appears rational. However, if you can present sufficient evidence to raise a “real doubt” about the deceased’s capacity, the burden of proof shifts. It is then up to the person seeking to validate the will to prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the deceased did have the required mental capacity when they made the will. This is where comprehensive medical records, witness statements, and legal expertise are essential.

Challenging a will is a formal legal process that must be approached with care and precision. The process begins with an investigation and can lead to a formal claim in the High Court.

Initial Steps: Investigation and Evidence

The very first step you should take is to place a caveat with the Probate Registry. A caveat is a legal notice that prevents the grant of probate from being issued, effectively putting the administration of the estate on hold. This gives you time to investigate your concerns without the estate being distributed. During this time, you should gather all relevant evidence, including the deceased’s medical records, notes from the solicitor who drafted the will, and witness statements from family and friends who can speak to the deceased’s mental state at the time the will was made.

Making a Formal Claim

If, after your investigation, you believe you have a strong case, you will begin the formal legal procedure. This involves sending a “Letter of Claim” to the executors of the will, outlining your grounds for the challenge and requesting any documents you need to see. The parties are then encouraged to use Alternative Dispute Resolution methods, such as mediation, to try and reach a settlement outside of court. It is a fact that most will disputes are resolved at this stage. If a settlement cannot be reached, the case will proceed to the High Court. A judge will hear evidence from both sides and make a final determination on the will’s validity.

The Role of Barristers in Contested Wills

Contesting a will is a complex area of civil litigation. A single misstep can be costly and could jeopardise your entire case. Given the specialist nature of these disputes, it is crucial to seek legal counsel from a professional who is an expert in this field.

The legal test for testamentary capacity is not straightforward and requires a nuanced understanding of case law and legal precedent. A barrister specialises in advocacy and litigation, which means they are uniquely equipped to analyse complex evidence and present a compelling case in court. They can provide an objective assessment of the merits of your case, helping you understand the legal risks and the likelihood of success.

How a Barrister Can Help

TBI’s barristers provide essential services to guide you through a contested will dispute:

  • Case Assessment: We will thoroughly review your evidence and provide a clear and candid opinion on the strength of your case and your legal options.
  • Strategic Advice: We will advise you on the best course of action, whether that is to seek a settlement or to pursue a claim in court.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: We are skilled negotiators who can represent you in mediation, working to achieve a favourable settlement without the need for a costly trial.
  • Court Representation: If the case proceeds to a hearing, we will represent you with expertise and authority, presenting your arguments and evidence persuasively to the court.

TBI’s Barristers are on Hand to Assist You

At TBI (The Barristers Inc), we understand that contesting a will can be one of the most difficult experiences you may face. Our barristers are not only legal experts but are also compassionate and understanding. We have a wealth of experience in contentious probate, and our team is committed to providing you with the highest level of legal care and support.

Our Expertise in Contested Probate

Our barristers have a deep and practical understanding of the legal principles surrounding testamentary capacity. We are well-versed in the latest case law and the strategies required to successfully challenge a will. Our specialisation in this field allows us to offer you a level of insight and expertise that can make all the difference in the outcome of your case.

Our Approach to Capacity Disputes

We take a client-centric approach to every case. We provide clear, strategic advice that is tailored to your specific situation and work diligently to achieve a fair outcome. We are committed to making the legal process as transparent and straightforward as possible, empowering you to make informed decisions at every stage.

Contact TBI Today

If you are concerned that a loved one’s will is invalid due to a lack of mental capacity, do not hesitate to seek professional legal advice. Contact TBI today for a confidential consultation. Our expert barristers are here to help you understand your options and provide the robust representation you need to achieve a just and fair resolution.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link