Home / News / Dispute Resolution / When ADR Becomes a Court Requirement to Mediate Before a Trial? 

When ADR Becomes a Court Requirement to Mediate Before a Trial? 

19 Nov, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

The UK civil justice system is undergoing a fundamental transformation. For decades, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), which includes methods like negotiation, mediation, and arbitration, was seen as a voluntary alternative to litigation. Courts consistently encouraged parties to consider ADR, but they largely lacked the power to compel them to do so. This approach, however, has shifted dramatically. Following a landmark Court of Appeal decision and the subsequent evolution of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), UK courts now possess the lawful authority to order parties to engage in mediation. This change marks a seismic shift in civil litigation, repositioning it from a first resort to a last resort, to be used only after all avenues for resolution have been exhausted.

This legal evolution is a direct response to the immense strain on the court system and the spiraling costs of litigation. The traditional view of a litigant’s right to their “day in court” has been moderated by the court’s overarching objective to handle cases justly and at a proportionate cost. For civil litigants in England and Wales, this means that a simple refusal to mediate is no longer a viable option. The new legal landscape requires a new strategic approach. You can no longer simply issue proceedings and expect to proceed directly to trial. Instead, you must now prepare for a future where a court-ordered mediation is an almost inevitable, and mandatory, step in the litigation process. At TBI, our expert barristers are at the forefront of this evolving legal landscape, providing clients with the strategic guidance needed to navigate these new requirements and secure a favourable outcome.

The power of UK courts to lawfully order parties to mediate is not an arbitrary change; it is deeply rooted in the foundational principles of the civil justice system. The legal basis for this is the overriding objective of the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), a guiding principle that has governed civil litigation since its introduction in 1999. The overriding objective requires the courts to deal with cases “justly and at a proportionate cost.” This means that judges have a duty to manage cases actively to ensure they are handled in a way that is fair, efficient, and cost-effective for all parties involved.

The CPR gives courts a wide range of case management powers to achieve this objective. Encouraging Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) has always been one of these powers, but until recently, it was understood that a court could not compel a party to engage in a process that would require their consent. However, the landmark case of Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council (2023) fundamentally changed this. The Court of Appeal held that a court can indeed lawfully stay proceedings and order parties to engage in a mediation process, as long as it does not impair the litigant’s right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The decision affirmed that such a compulsory order is not a breach of human rights, but rather a proportionate means of achieving the overriding objective of the CPR. This judgment provides judges with a clear and powerful tool to ensure that parties make genuine attempts to resolve their disputes before taking up precious court time and incurring further costs. It reinforces the principle that litigation should be a last resort, reserved for cases that truly cannot be resolved through other means. The legal foundation is now unequivocally in place: mandatory mediation is a legitimate exercise of the court’s case management powers to deliver a more efficient and just civil justice system for all.

Specific Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) Provisions

  • The court’s power to enforce mediation and other forms of ADR is embedded within the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), which govern all civil proceedings in England and Wales. The authority is primarily derived from several key provisions that grant the court broad powers of active case management.
  • CPR 1.4: The Court’s Duty of Active Case Management: This rule explicitly states that the court must actively manage cases to achieve the overriding objective. The list of powers under this rule includes “ordering or encouraging the parties to use, and facilitating the use of, alternative dispute resolution.” While the language is “encouraging,” the new legal precedent established by Churchill allows courts to use this power to compel participation.
  • CPR 3.1: The Court’s General Powers of Management: This rule further empowers the court to take proactive steps to manage a case, including the power to “stay the whole or part of any proceedings or judgment either generally or until a specified date or event.” A court can use this power to legally pause a claim, effectively blocking it from proceeding to trial, until the parties have complied with an order to attempt mediation.
  • In addition to these general rules, there are specific provisions that make mediation a formal requirement in certain types of cases. For instance, the Civil Justice Council has implemented a new mandatory Small Claims Mediation Service (SCMS) for all small claims cases (generally, those with a value of up to £10,000) that are started after November 2023. This rule makes mediation a compulsory step in the litigation process for these claims. Parties will now be automatically referred to a free one-hour telephone mediation session. This is a significant development, as it removes any ambiguity and makes mediation a standard, non-negotiable step for the majority of civil cases in the country.

The Consequences of Non-Compliance

Refusing to engage in court-ordered ADR is no longer a matter of simply declining an invitation. It is a serious act of non-compliance with a court order that can have severe and wide-ranging consequences for a litigant. The court has a number of powerful sanctions at its disposal, which are designed to penalise parties for their conduct rather than their legal position. This means that a party who ultimately wins their case at trial can still be penalised financially for their earlier refusal to mediate. This powerful deterrent is a core component of the court’s new approach, ensuring that litigants understand the importance of making a genuine effort to resolve their disputes outside of the courtroom. The message is clear: the court system is not an arena for those who refuse to negotiate in good faith.

Financial Penalties

  • The most common and impactful sanctions for a failure to comply with a court order to mediate are financial penalties. The court has a wide discretion to use its cost-awarding powers to punish a party’s unreasonable behaviour. The following are the most typical financial consequences:
  • Adverse Costs Orders: Even if a party wins their case and is successful in a claim, the court can still deprive them of their legal costs. In some cases, the court may even go further and order the winning party to pay a portion of the opponent’s costs, as a direct penalty for their unreasonable refusal to mediate. A judge may, for example, rule that a winning party should only recover 50% of their costs, or that they must pay the other side’s costs from the date that mediation was refused. The court’s reasoning would be that if the party had mediated, the case would likely have settled, and the subsequent costs of litigation would have been avoided.
  • Adjustments to Interest Rates: The court has the power to adjust the interest rates on damages awarded as a further penalty. A winning party who refused to mediate may have the interest on their damages reduced or even eliminated for the period following their refusal. Conversely, a losing party who unreasonably refused to mediate may be ordered to pay an enhanced interest rate on the amount they owe, significantly increasing the total sum of their liability. These measures are designed to financially incentivise and reward those who genuinely engage in the court’s processes, while punishing those who obstruct them.

Procedural Sanctions

  • In addition to financial penalties, a party who fails to comply with a court order to mediate may face significant procedural consequences that can severely prejudice their case. The court can use its active case management powers to halt the progress of the litigation until the party complies.
  • Staying Proceedings: As mentioned, the court can order a “stay” on the proceedings. This effectively freezes the case, preventing it from progressing towards a trial. A stay can last for a specified period or until a specified event—in this case, the completion of a mediation attempt. This can lead to significant and costly delays, with legal fees continuing to accrue while the case remains in limbo. The non-compliant party will be footing the bill for a case that is going nowhere.
  • Striking Out a Claim or Defence: While this is a rare and extreme measure, in the most severe cases of persistent and contumacious non-compliance, a court has the power to strike out a party’s entire claim or defence. This would effectively mean that their case is thrown out of court, leading to an automatic loss. This sanction is reserved for situations where a party’s behaviour is so unreasonable that it amounts to an abuse of the court’s process.
  • These procedural sanctions serve as a powerful signal that the court will not tolerate a party’s obstruction of the overriding objective. The message is that the court is not a forum for those who are unwilling to cooperate in good faith.

How TBI Can Assist You

Navigating the evolving landscape of civil litigation and mandatory mediation requires a clear understanding of your legal obligations and a strategic approach to Alternative Dispute Resolution. At TBI, our expert barristers specialise in both traditional civil litigation and modern ADR, positioning us to provide comprehensive guidance through this new environment.

We can assist you at every stage of your dispute, ensuring you are fully prepared for the changes and that your interests are protected. Our services include:

  • Strategic Legal Advice: We will provide you with a detailed analysis of your case, helping you understand your rights and the potential risks of litigation versus a mediated settlement.
  • Pre-Action Guidance: We will guide you through the pre-action phase of your dispute, ensuring you are fully compliant with any legal obligations to consider ADR before a claim is even issued.
  • Mediation Representation: Our barristers are highly skilled advocates and negotiators. We can represent you during a mediation session, providing expert advice, helping to manage expectations, and working to secure a favourable settlement without the need for a costly and time-consuming trial.
  • Compliance and Risk Management: We will advise you on the new rules and help you understand the serious financial and procedural consequences of non-compliance. Our strategic counsel will ensure you are well-positioned to meet the court’s requirements and avoid sanctions.
  • By working with TBI, you gain direct access to seasoned legal professionals who are adept at both courtroom advocacy and the nuanced art of negotiation. We are committed to providing the clarity and confidence you need to navigate these new legal requirements, ensuring you have the best possible chance of achieving a positive outcome for your dispute.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link