Home / News / Property & Boundary Disputes / What to Do Over Shared Access Disputes Between Flats or Houses With a Neighbour 

What to Do Over Shared Access Disputes Between Flats or Houses With a Neighbour 

20 Nov, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Shared access disputes are one of the most common and emotionally charged types of property disputes in England and Wales. When a driveway, path, or garden is used by more than one household, disagreements can quickly arise, whether due to a parked car blocking the way, a disagreement over maintenance costs, or simple personality clashes. What can start as a minor annoyance can escalate into a major legal conflict, particularly because these issues often involve daily interactions with a neighbour. Before any meaningful resolution can be found, it is essential to understand the legal foundation of your rights and obligations. The law provides clear answers to these disputes, but navigating the legal framework requires knowledge and strategic guidance. At TBI, we provide clarity and expert legal advice to help you resolve your dispute and restore peace of mind.

The key to resolving these disputes without resorting to litigation is to arm yourself with accurate legal knowledge. Understanding the legal status of the shared access area and the specific rights and responsibilities attached to it is the first and most crucial step. Without this knowledge, you may be relying on assumptions or informal agreements that have no legal standing. This article will serve as a guide to help you understand your legal position, outlining the essential steps to take from informal resolution to formal legal action, should it become necessary.

The legal foundation of shared access is rooted in a concept known as an easement. An easement is a legal right to use another person’s land for a specific purpose, without owning the land itself. In the context of shared access, an easement allows one landowner (the “dominant tenement”) to use a path or driveway that belongs to a neighbouring landowner (the “servient tenement”). This right is a proprietary interest in land, meaning it is a permanent and enforceable right that runs with the land, not just with the people who live there.

Easements are typically created in one of two ways. The most common is an express easement, which is explicitly granted in the title deeds of the properties. These deeds will contain a clause that formally grants a “right of way” over a specific piece of land. The second way is through a prescriptive easement, which can be established by a person using a piece of land continuously for a period of at least 20 years “as of right.” To prove this, the use must be without force, without secrecy, and without permission.

Common shared access disputes often fall into one of three categories:

  • Obstruction: This is the most frequent dispute, where one party obstructs the shared access, whether by parking a vehicle, placing bins, or erecting a fence or gate that impedes the use of the right of way. An obstruction can be a “substantial interference” with the right, which may justify legal action.
  • Maintenance and Repair: Disputes frequently arise over who is responsible for the costs of maintaining or repairing a shared access area. The responsibility for maintenance is usually, but not always, outlined in the title deeds. If not, the responsibility is often shared equally among those who benefit from the access.
  • Excessive Use: This occurs when a person uses their right of way in a way that is far beyond what was originally intended, such as running a business from a private road meant for residential use.

The Importance of Your Title Deeds

Your title deeds are the most important documents you own when it comes to understanding your property rights. For shared access disputes, they are the primary source of information and will almost always be the starting point for any legal professional. The title deeds will confirm whether a right of way exists and, if so, the specific terms and conditions attached to it. They will often contain a Deed of Grant which explicitly sets out the scope of the easement.

Your deeds can be obtained from the Land Registry, the official register of land ownership in England and Wales. By obtaining copies of the title deeds for both your property and your neighbour’s property, you can definitively establish the legal status of the shared access. It is crucial to read these documents carefully, as they often contain specific details that can resolve a dispute immediately. For example, a right of way might be granted for “pedestrian and vehicular access” or it might be restricted to “pedestrian access only.” The deeds may also state that the right of way is “at all times and for all purposes” or that it is limited to specific hours. Furthermore, the deeds will often specify the responsibility for maintenance, stating that the costs are to be “shared equally between those who benefit from the right.” Having this information in hand from the outset can help you avoid making assumptions and provide a solid, factual basis for any future communication or legal action.

First Steps to Resolve the Dispute Informally

While the law provides a clear pathway for resolution, resorting to formal legal action should always be a last resort. The process of litigation is not only expensive and time-consuming but can also cause permanent damage to your relationship with your neighbour. The financial costs, including legal fees, court fees, and the possibility of paying your neighbour’s costs, can quickly run into the tens of thousands of pounds. This can often outweigh the value of the dispute itself. For this reason, the UK’s civil justice system has a strong emphasis on pre-action conduct. Parties are legally required to attempt to resolve the dispute informally before issuing a claim in court. Failure to do so can result in serious legal and financial penalties. The first and most effective solution is often open and calm communication.

Communication and Mediation

Before engaging lawyers, you should try to resolve the issue directly with your neighbour. It is best to approach this with a calm and non-confrontational attitude. A simple, polite conversation can often clear up a misunderstanding. If a direct conversation feels too difficult or has already failed, it is advisable to send a formal, but polite, letter to your neighbour outlining the legal position as you understand it from your deeds. This provides a clear, documented record of your attempts at informal resolution.

If direct communication fails, mediation is an excellent alternative. Mediation is a structured, voluntary, and confidential process where a neutral third party—the mediator—assists the parties in reaching a voluntary agreement. The mediator is not a judge and does not make a decision; instead, they facilitate a discussion to help the parties understand each other’s positions and find a mutually acceptable solution. Mediation is significantly more flexible and cost-effective than litigation. It allows for creative solutions that a court may not be able to order, and it helps to preserve the neighbour relationship, which is vital for long-term peace of mind.

When all attempts at informal resolution, including mediation, have failed, it may become necessary to seek formal legal remedies. This is the stage where a person’s legal rights are being seriously infringed upon, and court intervention is required to provide a definitive and legally binding solution. These actions are typically undertaken with the assistance of a legal professional, as they require a deep understanding of property law and court procedure. It is crucial to have a barrister on your side who can provide powerful legal advice and representation.

Seeking an Injunction and Damages

One of the most powerful legal remedies for a shared access dispute is an injunction. An injunction is a court order compelling a person to do something or to stop doing something. There are two main types of injunctions that can be sought in these disputes:

  • A Prohibitory Injunction: This is a court order preventing a neighbour from doing something that infringes on your rights. For example, a court could grant a prohibitory injunction ordering your neighbour to stop parking their car in a way that obstructs your access.
  • A Mandatory Injunction: This is a court order compelling a neighbour to take a positive action. For example, a court could order your neighbour to remove a fence or a shed that they have built on the shared right of way.
  • In addition to an injunction, a person can also claim damages for any financial losses they have suffered as a direct result of the dispute. The purpose of damages is to put the injured party back in the position they would have been in had the breach not occurred. This can include a variety of costs, such as:
  • Financial losses: This could be the cost of a tow truck to move an obstructing vehicle, the cost of alternative travel arrangements if your access was blocked, or the cost of a temporary gate to secure your property if a neighbour removed a shared gate without permission.
  • Property devaluation: In some cases, a prolonged and serious dispute can have a negative impact on the market value of your property. If it can be proven that the neighbour’s actions caused a measurable decrease in your property’s value, you may be able to claim for this loss.

How TBI Can Assist You

Navigating a shared access dispute can be a complex and emotional process. The combination of legal rights, financial implications, and the sensitive nature of neighbour relationships requires a knowledgeable and experienced legal team. At TBI, our expert barristers specialise in civil litigation and property disputes, providing comprehensive legal guidance to help you resolve your shared access issue.

We can assist you at every stage of your dispute, from initial enquiries to formal court action:

  • Initial Legal Advice: We will provide you with a clear and concise assessment of your case, including a detailed analysis of your title deeds, to help you understand your legal rights and obligations.
  • Pre-Action Correspondence: We will draft and send all formal correspondence, including a formal letter of claim that is compliant with all legal protocols, ensuring your position is clearly and professionally stated.
  • Mediation Representation: Our barristers are skilled negotiators and advocates who can represent you in mediation, working to secure a favourable settlement without the need for a costly and public court battle.
  • Court Representation: If litigation is necessary, we will provide powerful and experienced courtroom advocacy. We can apply for court orders, including injunctions and damages, to enforce your legal rights and protect your property.
  • By choosing TBI, you gain direct access to seasoned legal professionals who are dedicated to protecting your property rights and achieving a successful outcome. We are committed to providing the clarity and confidence you need to resolve your dispute and restore your peace of mind.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link