A formal witness statement is a formal, written document that contains a person’s evidence of fact relating to a dispute. It’s the primary way the court learns about your side of the story. A powerful and persuasive witness statement is not just a chronological account of events; it is a carefully crafted document that adheres to strict legal rules, presents facts clearly, and demonstrates your credibility. As barristers, we know that proper preparation is the single most important factor in a witness’s success. A well-prepared statement will not only serve as your evidence in chief but will also set a strong foundation for any cross-examination you may face.
A witness statement is a written statement signed by a person which contains the evidence which that person would be allowed to give orally in court. It is a crucial piece of evidence that will be referred to and relied upon at trial. The purpose of a witness statement is to provide the court with your truthful and factual account of events within your personal knowledge. It is essential for informing the judge and the other party about the evidence you intend to rely on to support your case.
The primary purpose of a witness statement is to present factual evidence to the court. It sets out the witness’s understanding of the events and facts that are relevant to the case, and it serves as the witness’s evidence in chief (the evidence they give to support their own party’s case). At trial, the witness statement will stand as their main evidence, and they will be subject to cross-examination from the opposing party. A witness statement must not contain legal arguments, personal opinions, or speculation. Its sole purpose is to present a truthful and factual account of events.
A witness statement must state only matters of fact of which the witness has personal knowledge. This is a fundamental rule. You can only write about what you personally saw, heard, or did. The statement should be in your own words, and if any information is based on something you were told by a third party (hearsay), you must clearly state the source of that information. The judge relies on witness statements to build a picture of the events that led to the dispute, and any information that is not from personal knowledge must be identified as such.
A witness statement must be limited to factual evidence and should not contain legal arguments, opinions, or a narrative that simply takes the court through documents. It should not make a case for you or argue that the other party is at fault. Your barrister’s role is to make the legal arguments based on the facts you provide. The statement is not the place for lengthy quotations from documents; instead, you should reference them in an exhibit.
Drafting a witness statement is not a creative writing exercise. It is a formal legal process with strict rules that must be followed. Failing to comply with these rules can result in your statement being deemed inadmissible, and it could even lead to legal sanctions.
Every witness statement must be verified by a ‘Statement of Truth.’ This is a formal declaration at the end of the document, which must be signed and dated by the witness. By signing the Statement of Truth, you confirm that you honestly believe the facts stated in the entire witness statement are true. This is a very serious declaration.
The Statement of Truth is the witness’s assurance to the court that the evidence is truthful. It makes the maker of the statement personally accountable for its contents. Its purpose is to deter a witness from making a false or exaggerated claim, as the consequences of doing so are severe. The court relies on this declaration to have confidence in the evidence provided.
Signing a Statement of Truth when you know or believe the facts to be false is a serious offence that can lead to contempt of court. Contempt of court is a crime punishable by a fine or a prison sentence. Under the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), the court can also strike out a claim or defence that is based on a false statement. This is why it is absolutely critical that you do not include anything in your statement that you cannot honestly and truly stand by.
When drafting your formal witness statement, the text used for the Statement of Truth must follow the precise wording stipulated by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), specifically Practice Direction 32.
“I believe that the facts stated in this witness statement are true. I understand that proceedings for contempt of court may be brought against anyone who makes, or causes to be made, a false statement in a document verified by a Statement of Truth without an honest belief in its truth.”
This declaration is what elevates the document beyond a simple narrative.
The CPR also has strict rules on how the witness statement should be written and formatted. These rules are in place to ensure that the statement is clear, professional, and easy for the court and the other party to understand.
The witness statement must be written in the witness’s own words and in the first person (“I did this,” “I saw that”). It should reflect your genuine recollection of events and not be a version of events written by your lawyer. While your barrister can help you structure the statement and ensure it is legally compliant, the content must be yours. If you use an interpreter, that must be clearly stated on the document.
As stated earlier, a witness statement must stick to facts and personal knowledge. It should be presented in a chronological order to provide a clear and logical narrative of events. Each paragraph should be numbered and should deal with a single point. You must also clearly state which of your statements are from your own personal knowledge and which are based on information or belief, giving the source of that information. For example, “I was told by my colleague, Jane Smith, on 1 June 2025, that…”
A properly drafted witness statement must begin with a clear introduction that immediately establishes the witness’s identity and their connection to the case. This answers the question of how to start a witness statement professionally:
Preparing a witness statement is a process that requires a careful and methodical approach. Here is a step-by-step guide to help you prepare your statement effectively.
Before you put a single word on paper, you must prepare. This is the most crucial stage of the process and will make drafting the statement much easier.
Once you have gathered your documents and created a chronology, you are ready to begin drafting your statement.
The process of preparing a witness statement is complex, but you don’t have to do it alone. The barristers at TBI are experts in civil litigation and can provide the crucial support you need.
Our barristers have a strategic approach to witness statements. We provide an objective case assessment, advising you on the strengths and weaknesses of your position. We also provide legal strategy, advising you on what evidence is most important for your case and how to write a witness statement that maximises its impact.
A barrister’s job is to provide an objective opinion on the merits of your case. We can advise you on what a court would find persuasive and what it would consider irrelevant. This early advice helps you focus your efforts on the facts that matter and avoid wasting time on details that will not strengthen your case.
We assist you with the entire preparation process, from reviewing your documents to helping you create a chronology of events. We can help you identify any inconsistencies in your account and advise you on how to deal with them honestly and effectively. This is vital to learning how to draft a witness statement that stands up in court.
A point of frequent confusion for lay clients is the distinction between a ‘witness statement’ and a ‘proof of evidence’.
The final witness statement is a curated and legally compliant version of the raw evidence; therefore, when asking, is a witness proof, the answer is that the formal statement is the legal proof of the evidence, whereas the draft is the proof-gathering document.
Our barristers can assist you in several ways:
By understanding the legal requirements, preparing carefully, and seeking expert legal advice, you can ensure that your evidence counts. For the peace of mind that your statement is legally sound and a powerful asset in your case, a specialist barrister is an invaluable partner.
In civil litigation governed by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) in England and Wales, every document presented to the court serves a distinct, regulated purpose. Two documents often confused by lay clients—the witness statement and the legal argument (or submissions)—are fundamentally different in their purpose, content, and provenance.
The fundamental difference lies in their role within the legal process: a witness statement is a vehicle for presenting factual evidence from a witness’s direct personal knowledge, establishing what happened. A legal argument is the vehicle for applying the law to those established facts, explaining why those facts lead to a specific legal conclusion and remedy. The former provides the raw material; the latter provides the legal interpretation.
A witness statement is a written statement signed by a person which contains the evidence in chief that the witness would be allowed to give orally at Trial. Its purpose is strictly limited by the CPR Part 32 and related Practice Directions.
A witness statement must be strictly limited to factual evidence based on the witness’s personal knowledge and experience. This includes describing events, quoting conversations, confirming dates and times, and identifying documents. It must not contain argument, speculation, rhetorical flourish, or legal commentary. The core principle of admissibility of evidence demands this focus on verifiable facts.
The statement must be verified by a Statement of Truth, a formal legal declaration signed by the witness. By signing, the witness confirms their genuine belief that the facts stated in the document are true. Making a false statement without honest belief can lead to prosecution for Contempt of Court, highlighting the gravity of the commitment.
Only in rare circumstances can a non-expert witness include opinion evidence—specifically, opinions based on fact and rationally based on what the witness perceived (e.g., “The vehicle was travelling fast”). All other opinion evidence must be given by a qualified expert whose duty is owed to the court, not the client, and is subject to specific CPR rules.
Legal arguments (or submissions) are the province of the instructed Barrister or Solicitor Advocate. They are the means by which the lawyer links the established factual evidence to the relevant legal principles and case law.
Legal arguments are the lawyer’s oral or written advocacy directed to the judge. They involve selecting the strongest facts from the witness statements and expert reports, interpreting relevant statutes and judicial precedents, and persuading the court to rule in the client’s favour. Unlike a statement, an argument is inherently partisan and persuasive.
A legal argument contains conclusions about the law (e.g., “The defendant breached their duty of care”) and explains why the law applies in a certain way to the facts proven in the witness statements. A statement can never contain this application or analysis.
Breaching the distinction between fact and argument carries significant risks in the English courts.
If a party includes excessive legal submissions or irrelevant opinion evidence in a witness statement, the court may use its powers under the CPR to strike out the inadmissible portions. Critically, the court may impose adverse costs orders against the offending party, forcing them to pay the opponent’s costs incurred in dealing with the defective statement. This is a common form of sanction for procedural unfairness.
TBI ensures that all evidence prepared for litigation in England and Wales is procedurally flawless and legally effective, maximising its persuasive impact at Trial.
Our Civil Litigation experts draft witness statements that are strictly limited to admissible factual evidence. We ensure every fact is presented clearly and logically, providing the best possible basis for subsequent legal submissions without incurring penalties for non-compliance.
We work directly with clients to extract and verify the crucial facts while deliberately separating them from any premature legal interpretation. This strategic separation ensures the integrity of the evidence in chief while preserving the power of the legal argument for the appropriate stage of advocacy.
TBI’s rigorous adherence to CPR Part 32 rules and practice directions including the proper format, exhibits, and the Statement of Truth mitigates the risk of procedural sanctions. We protect our clients from adverse costs orders that often result from careless drafting or the inclusion of inadmissible material.
The success of any case hinges on the admissibility of evidence and the effective presentation of that evidence. TBI’s integrated expertise is paramount. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure that all witness statements are compliant, robust, and persuasive. Our experience in Family Law and Criminal Litigation (which have stringent rules on evidence and procedure) informs our approach to fact-gathering and verification. By rigorously separating factual evidence from legal arguments, we ensure that clients’ cases are built on an unassailable foundation of admissible facts, significantly strengthening their position at Trial and securing the best possible outcome under UK law.
In civil litigation governed by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), the Statement of Truth is one of the most crucial elements in ensuring the integrity of the evidence presented to the court. Unlike historical procedures where oral evidence was given under oath, modern written statements are verified by this declaration, giving them the same formal weight and legal consequence.
The Statement of Truth is a mandatory, formal legal declaration by which a party or witness confirms their genuine belief that the facts stated in the document are true. This declaration applies to all key documents relied upon in litigation, including witness statements, statements of case (such as Particulars of Claim and Defence), and applications for interim relief. By verifying the document, the signatory attests to its honesty, establishing the evidentiary basis for their claim or defence.
The requirement for the Statement of Truth is enshrined in CPR Part 22. Its purpose is to uphold the overriding objective of the CPR—to deal with cases justly—by ensuring that the court can rely on the honesty of the parties and witnesses. The specific wording required is usually: “I believe that the facts stated in this [document] are true.”
The statement must verify the facts contained in the document itself. For a witness statement, this confirms that the facts the witness is relying on are true. For a statement of case, this confirms the truth of the pleaded facts and the honest belief in the merit of the case being advanced. It imposes a professional and ethical duty on the signatory to exercise care and diligence in checking the accuracy of the document.
If a party or witness signs a Statement of Truth knowing the contents to be false, or without an honest belief in their truthfulness, the consequences are immediate for the case and severe for the individual.
The most severe consequence is that a person who makes a false statement in a document verified by a Statement of Truth may be liable for Contempt of Court. This is a serious legal offence designed to punish interference with the administration of justice. The penalties are substantial: the court may impose an unlimited fine, order the sequestration of assets, or, most gravely, impose a sentence of committal to prison for up to two years. This liability arises directly from the CPR provisions, establishing the declaration as functionally equivalent to giving false evidence under oath (perjury).
In addition to the punitive sanction of Contempt of Court, the case itself will suffer immediate and devastating consequences:
The severity of the penalty for Contempt of Court is reserved for deliberate or reckless falsehoods.
If a document contains a factual inaccuracy that resulted from an honest mistake or error, the court’s usual response is to permit an amendment to the document. The key distinction is the mental element: the statement must be made without an honest belief in its truthfulness to constitute Contempt of Court.
TBI ensures absolute honesty and procedural compliance in all client documentation, protecting clients from the serious risks associated with the Statement of Truth in England and Wales.
Our Civil Litigation experts conduct rigorous verification and evidentiary basis audits on all documents before they are signed. We cross-reference every factual assertion in a witness statement or statement of case against supporting documentation to eliminate errors and ensure compliance with the Statement of Truth requirement.
We provide clear, unambiguous advice to every client regarding the gravity of the Statement of Truth, detailing the risk of committal to prison or a severe fine for dishonesty. This proactive approach safeguards our clients from inadvertently or intentionally misleading the court and incurring Contempt of Court proceedings.
In the event of an alleged inaccuracy, TBI defends the client by clearly establishing the factual basis and demonstrating that any error was an honest mistake, thereby protecting the client from a punitive sanction while accepting procedural responsibility for the necessary correction.
Credibility is currency in court. TBI’s integrated expertise guarantees the highest level of ethical and procedural compliance. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure expert compliance with CPR Part 22, protecting clients from the devastating consequences of a false declaration. Our experience in Family Law and Criminal Litigation (where issues of honesty and disclosure are paramount) informs our verification processes. By rigorously upholding the Statement of Truth, we safeguard our clients’ liberty, finances, and credibility, preventing the striking out of their case and securing their best chance of achieving justice under UK law.
A witness statement is the essential document used in civil litigation in England and Wales to convey the factual evidence that a witness would provide orally as evidence in chief at Trial. Because this document is relied upon by the court to establish the facts of the case, it must adhere strictly to the formal requirements laid out in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), specifically CPR Practice Direction 32 (PD 32).
These procedural requirements are not mere bureaucratic hurdles; they are fundamental to establishing the document’s authenticity, context, and legal admissibility. Three specific pieces of information must be provided at the very beginning of the statement to formalise the evidence and define the witness’s role.
The three mandatory requirements are concerned with identifying the proceedings and the identity of the person giving evidence, ensuring the evidence can be linked correctly to the specific case.
The heading of the witness statement must state the full case title of the proceedings (e.g., Claimant Name v Defendant Name) and the official litigation reference (or claim number). This is essential for procedural clarity. The court and the opponent must be able to immediately verify that the document relates to the correct legal action. Errors in this section can lead to the document being rejected by the court registry or cause confusion during the evidence exchange process, impacting admissibility.
The statement must clearly identify which party to the litigation the Claimant, the Defendant, a Part 20 Defendant, etc is relying on the evidence. In complex litigation involving multiple parties, this information is vital for understanding the context and alignment of the factual evidence. This confirms the witness’s role as a witness for a specific litigant, a necessary piece of information for the judge and the opposing advocate during Trial preparation.
The body of the statement must begin with the witness’s full name, address, and occupation. This information serves several critical purposes:
These three requirements are not optional; they are mandatory under the CPR Practice Direction 32 because they uphold the foundational principles of litigation.
Failure to include these mandatory procedural formalities can render the witness statement formally defective, jeopardising its admissibility as evidence in chief at Trial. The court may refuse to allow the defective statement to be relied upon, which could be catastrophic to the party relying on that evidence.
Even if the court eventually accepts the defective statement, the opponent is entitled to draw the court’s attention to the procedural irregularity. The judge has the discretion to impose adverse costs orders on the party who filed the defective statement, penalising them for non-compliance with the CPR. The court seeks to maintain a professional standard of drafting.
TBI ensures every piece of evidence presented to the court in England and Wales is procedurally sound, effective, and fully compliant with the CPR.
Our Civil Litigation experts ensure absolute adherence to the CPR and associated Practice Directions. We check that every witness statement meets all formal criteria, guaranteeing admissibility of the crucial evidence in chief at Trial and preventing substantive evidence from being rejected on a technicality.
We implement robust internal checks to ensure the case title, litigation reference, party name, and the witness’s full name, address, and occupation are correct and accurately transcribed, eliminating errors right from the drafting stage.
By prioritising procedural compliance, TBI protects clients from the risk of adverse costs orders associated with technical drafting errors. We view compliance as a foundational element of effective advocacy, ensuring the court’s focus remains on the merits of the case, not the flaws in the documentation.
Procedural compliance forms the essential framework for successful litigation. TBI’s integrated expertise is paramount. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure that the evidence we rely on is watertight, admissible, and professional. Our experience across Family Law and Criminal Litigation (fields with extremely strict evidential rules) informs our attention to detail in every witness statement. By guaranteeing the initial formalities are flawless, we strengthen the client’s case from the outset, providing clarity, credibility, and protection from procedural sanctions, ensuring a strong path to Trial and a favourable outcome under UK law.
In civil litigation governed by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), the witness statement is the primary vehicle for presenting factual evidence to the court. While the statement itself must be formally presented, the quality of its content hinges on preparation. The drafting of a comprehensive Chronology of Events is not merely a helpful preliminary step; it is a critical, almost mandatory exercise that underpins the accuracy, credibility, and ultimate admissibility of the evidence.
A Chronology of Events is a preparatory document used by the legal team and the witness to list, in strict sequential order, all the material facts relevant to the case, cross-referenced with the corresponding documentary evidence (emails, letters, invoices, etc.) and specific dates.
The rigorous preparation of a Chronology of Events before drafting the formal witness statement is essential for safeguarding the client’s case from attack and ensuring compliance with the principles of good litigation practice under the CPR.
The CPR Practice Direction 32 implicitly requires witness statements to be organised in a clear, logical, and chronological sequence. Compiling a Chronology of Events forces the witness and the legal team to methodically map out the entire factual history of the dispute. This process helps to identify critical events, dates, and interactions that might otherwise be forgotten, ensuring that no essential material facts are inadvertently omitted from the formal evidence in chief.
A key vulnerability of any witness statement is inconsistency with the available documentary evidence (the disclosed documents). The chronology acts as a crucial audit tool, allowing the legal team to check every assertion of the witness against the firm dates and details contained in the documents. By resolving these discrepancies before the statement is finalised, the team significantly strengthens the statement and prevents potential embarrassment or damage to the witness’s credibility during cross-examination at Trial.
A witness statement that flows logically and is supported by precise dates and document references is inherently more credible and persuasive to the judge. The chronology ensures the statement adheres to the required standard of objectivity and clarity, which is a procedural safeguard against the court imposing adverse costs orders for disorganised or poor-quality evidence.
The ultimate test for any witness statement is its ability to withstand hostile cross-examination at Trial. The Chronology of Events is the best defense against this challenge.
Opposing counsel will search for any inconsistency or factual gaps in the witness’s testimony. By mapping the facts chronologically against the disclosure documents, the legal team can anticipate the points of attack. Any weaknesses identified in the chronology can be addressed (e.g., by finding additional documents or clarifying the witness’s recollection) before the formal statement is signed.
The process helps to filter out irrelevant or non-essential details, ensuring the resulting witness statement focuses only on the material facts directly relevant to the pleaded issues. This adherence to relevance is critical under the CPR and ensures the statement is an effective piece of advocacy.
TBI treats the Chronology of Events as a mandatory step in its litigation preparation process, ensuring that all factual evidence is reliable and compelling in the courts of England and Wales.
Our Civil Litigation experts enforce a strict process of auditing every chronological event provided by the witness against the full set of disclosure documents. This forensic approach proactively eliminates inconsistencies that would otherwise be exploited during cross-examination.
By utilising the chronology, we strategically craft the witness statement to be robust and precise. This strengthens the evidence in chief to the point where it is highly resilient, reducing the likelihood that the witness’s credibility can be successfully challenged at Trial.
TBI ensures the final witness statement flows in a clear, logical, sequential order, adhering to the best practices required under CPR Practice Direction 32. This attention to structure maximises the persuasive impact of the evidence and guarantees its admissibility.
Effective litigation is built on the rigorous verification of facts. TBI’s integrated expertise is paramount for securing successful outcomes. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure expert procedural compliance and the creation of highly credible witness statements. Our experience in Family Law and Criminal Litigation informs our chronology preparation. By front-loading the evidence preparation process with a mandatory Chronology of Events, we mitigate litigation risk, prevent the imposition of adverse costs orders, and ensure our client’s narrative is coherent, complete, and unassailable at Trial under UK law.
In civil litigation governed by the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), the process of documenting a witness’s memory evolves through several stages. A critical distinction must be drawn between the internal Proof of Evidence and the final, formal Witness Statement. Confusing the two can lead to significant procedural and strategic errors, potentially waiving valuable legal protections.
The fundamental distinction lies in their legal status and intended audience: the Proof of Evidence is a preliminary, internal, and often privileged record of a witness’s account, designed for the legal team’s analysis. The Witness Statement is a final, verified, and disclosable document intended for the court and the opposing parties to be used as the witness’s evidence in chief at Trial.
The Proof of Evidence serves as the initial documentation stage where the legal team captures the witness’s narrative, often during an interview.
The primary purpose of the Proof of Evidence is investigative and preparatory. It is the initial, raw account of factual evidence as recalled by the witness. Critically, because it is created for the dominant purpose of litigation (to obtain evidence and receive legal advice on that evidence), the Proof of Evidence is typically protected by legal professional privilege (specifically, litigation privilege). This means the document is confidential and generally does not have to be disclosed to the opposing side.
The Proof of Evidence is an internal document that does not need to comply with the rigid formatting requirements of the CPR. It is often written in narrative form, may contain the solicitor’s provisional thoughts or questions, and does not need to be signed by the witness or verified by a Statement of Truth. It is a working document.
The Witness Statement represents the culmination of the evidence preparation process and is the formal document used in court proceedings.
The Witness Statement is created specifically for compulsory disclosure to the other parties and for presentation as evidence in chief at Trial. Its legal status is that of formal evidence under CPR Part 32. It is a statement of fact that the court will rely upon when making its findings. Unlike the Proof of Evidence, the final Witness Statement is not privileged.
The Witness Statement must strictly adhere to the technical requirements of the CPR (including specific headers, paragraphs numbered sequentially, and a chronological flow). Most importantly, it must be signed by the witness and include a Statement of Truth, verifying that the witness believes the factual evidence is true. Signing a document with a false Statement of Truth can lead to Contempt of Court.
Failing to maintain the distinction between the Proof of Evidence and the Witness Statement can have severe consequences for a client’s case.
If the privileged Proof of Evidence is accidentally served on the opponent, or if the final Witness Statement too closely resembles the raw, unedited Proof (e.g., by containing extraneous information or legal arguments), the court may rule that the legal professional privilege has been waived. This would compel the legal team to disclose internal, strategic communications to the opponent, severely damaging the case.
If the final statement is not properly converted from the raw Proof into a CPR-compliant document missing the Statement of Truth or essential formalities, it may be deemed inadmissible as evidence in chief at Trial, leaving the client without key evidence to support their claim.
TBI manages the evidence lifecycle with precision, ensuring the transition from a protected, initial account to a formal, compelling piece of evidence in England and Wales.
Our Civil Litigation team handles and stores the Proof of Evidence separately, ensuring it remains confidential and protected by legal professional privilege. We enforce strict protocols to prevent accidental waiver through improper referencing or disclosure.
We manage the complex process of converting the witness’s narrative Proof of Evidence into a structured, chronologically accurate Witness Statement. This involves rigorous editing to remove legal commentary and ensure full compliance with CPR formalities, maximising its admissibility.
We use the original Proof of Evidence and the final Statement to conduct a detailed evidential audit. This ensures that the two documents are not subject to any significant or explainable inconsistency, preventing vulnerabilities that could be exploited during cross-examination at Trial.
The integrity of evidence management is paramount to litigation success. TBI’s integrated expertise is essential for navigating the complex rules of privilege and evidence. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure maximum strategic protection of internal documentation by expertly managing legal professional privilege.
Our experience across Family Law and Criminal Litigation (fields where factual accounts and disclosure rules are intensely scrutinised) informs our handling of the Proof of Evidence. By ensuring the transition to a final Witness Statement is procedurally flawless, we safeguard the client’s narrative, prevent harmful inconsistencies, and ensure their factual evidence is presented flawlessly at Trial under UK law.
In the context of preparing a witness statement for use in civil litigation in England and Wales, the general rule remains that a witness must limit their testimony to factual evidence based on their own personal knowledge—what they directly saw, heard, or did. Evidence based on what someone else told the witness, intended to prove the truth of the matter stated, is technically known as hearsay evidence.
Crucially, however, the landscape of hearsay evidence in civil proceedings was fundamentally reformed by the Civil Evidence Act 1995. Unlike in criminal law, where the exclusion of hearsay is strict, hearsay evidence is now generally admissible in civil proceedings in England and Wales, provided certain strict procedural rules are observed. The primary circumstances under which a witness statement can include hearsay relate entirely to the mandatory steps required to give notice of the intention to adduce such evidence.
The Civil Evidence Act 1995 provides that evidence shall not be excluded on the ground that it is hearsay. However, the party seeking to rely on it must comply with the accompanying rules set out in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), specifically Practice Direction 33 (PD 33).
The most important procedural requirement is the obligation on the party intending to rely on hearsay evidence to give proper notice to all other parties. This notice requirement exists to allow the opposing side fair warning and sufficient time to prepare a challenge to the evidence, particularly if they intend to challenge the credibility of the original source of information. The hearsay must be identified either in the witness statement itself or in a separate formal notice.
When including hearsay evidence in a witness statement, the witness must clarify that the information is not from their personal knowledge and is instead a statement made by another person (the source of information). The statement must also clearly specify the following:
While hearsay evidence is technically admissible, the consequences of failing to adhere to the statutory notice requirement are significant, and the court retains the power to assess its weight.
If the party relying on the hearsay evidence fails to give proper notice under CPR Practice Direction 33 to the other parties, the court retains the discretion to refuse to admit the evidence. Alternatively, even if admitted, the court may impose severe adverse costs orders on the defaulting party as a penalty for procedural non-compliance, demonstrating that the obligation to give notice is not optional.
The Civil Evidence Act 1995 provides that the court, when assessing the weight (or credibility) of hearsay evidence, must consider several factors. The court will naturally attach less weight to hearsay than to direct evidence, particularly if the source of information is not called to give evidence. The opponent also has the right to compel the original source of information to attend Trial for cross-examination on the contents of their statement.
TBI strategically handles the inclusion of all types of evidence, ensuring that necessary hearsay is admitted legally while minimising risks to the overall case credibility in England and Wales.
Our Civil Litigation barristers possess in-depth knowledge of the Civil Evidence Act 1995. We ensure that any reliance on hearsay evidence is strategically justified and that all mandatory disclosure requirements are met, safeguarding the client from procedural challenges and adverse costs orders.
We draft the witness statement to clearly delineate which parts are hearsay and precisely identify the source of information and basis of belief for that evidence. This transparency is crucial for technical compliance and for maximising the small amount of credibility the court can afford to hearsay evidence.
TBI manages the entire Hearsay Notice procedure, ensuring timely service under CPR Practice Direction 33. This proactive step guarantees the admissibility of the evidence and provides a strategic framework to deal with any request from the opponent to compel the original source for cross-examination.
Dealing with complex evidence, such as hearsay, requires expert legal dexterity to ensure it is both admissible and effective. TBI’s integrated expertise is paramount. Our core Civil Litigation capabilities ensure expert compliance with the Civil Evidence Act 1995 and associated CPR rules. Our experience across Family Law and Criminal Litigation (where the rules on hearsay and credibility are intensely debated) informs our strategic approach to evidence management. By expertly navigating the hearsay notice requirement and ensuring the proper disclosure of the source of information, we maximise the chance that necessary evidence is admitted and secure the best possible evidentiary position for our clients at Trial under UK law.