FAQ
Home / FAQs / Will & Probate / What Is The Role of a Barrister in a Probate Dispute?

What Is The Role of a Barrister in a Probate Dispute?

The Barrister’s Role in a Probate Dispute: A Guide to Contested Wills and Estates
A barrister’s role in a probate dispute is to provide specialised legal advice and high-level advocacy for individuals embroiled in conflicts over a deceased person’s will or estate. Probate is the legal process of administering a deceased person’s estate, which includes settling their debts and distributing their assets in accordance with their will or the rules of intestacy. When this process is challenged, the matter becomes a probate dispute or a contentious probate case. Barristers, as specialist advocates, are called upon to handle the intricate legal and procedural complexities of these disputes. They are not merely advocates in a courtroom; they are strategic advisors who can navigate the complex legal landscape, from the initial pre-action correspondence through to a full trial in the High Court. Their expertise is crucial in deciphering the legal nuances of testamentary capacity, undue influence, and the validity of a will.

Understanding the Grounds for a Probate Dispute

Probate disputes are not simply about disagreements over who gets what. They are legal challenges that must be founded on specific, legally recognised grounds. The burden of proof rests on the claimant to demonstrate that the will or the administration of the estate is invalid for a particular reason. A barrister’s first role is to assess the merits of a potential claim, providing a candid and realistic assessment of the chances of success.

Challenges to the Validity of a Will

The most common form of probate dispute is a challenge to the validity of a will. A barrister will scrutinise a will on several grounds:

  • Lack of Testamentary Capacity: The person making the will, known as the testator, must have had the mental capacity to understand and approve the contents of the will at the time it was made. This is a highly technical area of law, often requiring expert medical evidence. What does it mean to have ‘testamentary capacity’? It means the testator must understand the nature and effect of a will, the extent of their property, and the people who have a moral claim on their estate. A barrister will review the testator’s medical records and instruct a medical expert to provide an opinion on their mental state at the time the will was executed.
  • Undue Influence: This occurs when a person is coerced into making a will in a certain way, so that it no longer reflects their true intentions. Proving undue influence is notoriously difficult, as it often happens behind closed doors, without witnesses. A barrister’s role is to build a case from circumstantial evidence, looking at the testator’s relationship with the influencer, their vulnerability, and the sudden changes in the will’s provisions.
  • Lack of Due Execution: For a will to be valid, it must be signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses, who must also sign the will in the presence of the testator. Any failure to adhere to these strict formalities can render the will invalid. A barrister will review the original will and gather evidence from the witnesses to ensure the formalities were correctly observed.
  • Lack of Knowledge and Approval: Even if a will is properly executed and the testator had capacity, the court must be satisfied that the testator knew and approved of the contents of the will. This ground is often used when a testator is frail or illiterate, and the will contains a complex clause that they may not have fully understood.

Claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975

Even if a will is valid, it may not make reasonable financial provision for certain family members or dependants. The Inheritance Act allows eligible applicants, such as a spouse, child, or someone who was financially dependent on the deceased, to apply to the court for a share of the estate. Barristers advise clients on their eligibility and the merits of their claim. Can a child disinherited from a will bring a claim? Yes, a child who has been disinherited can bring a claim under the Inheritance Act. The barrister will argue their case based on factors such as their financial needs, the size of the estate, and any disability or special circumstances. The case of Ilott v Mitson [2017] UKSC 17 is a landmark example of this, where the Supreme Court had to balance a testator’s freedom to dispose of their property with their moral duty to a child with whom they had had a long estrangement. This case highlights the complexity and discretionary nature of such claims.

The Barrister’s Role in Litigation and Dispute Resolution

The barrister’s role extends far beyond simply advising on the law. They are integral to the entire litigation process, from pre-action negotiations to the final judgment.

From Pre-Action to Trial

  • When a dispute arises, a barrister will first draft a detailed letter of claim outlining the legal basis of the challenge and inviting the other side to a negotiated settlement. These letters are crucial as they can set the tone for the entire dispute and often lead to a resolution without the need for court proceedings. Barristers are skilled in strategic negotiation and can represent clients in mediation, which is a form of alternative dispute resolution where an impartial third party helps the parties reach an agreement.
  • If an agreement cannot be reached, the barrister will draft a statement of case, which sets out the client’s position and the legal arguments in detail. This document is the foundation of the case in court. A barrister then acts as the client’s advocate in court, presenting the evidence, cross-examining witnesses, and making persuasive legal arguments before a judge. A barrister’s right of audience in all courts means they can represent clients from the County Court to the High Court and beyond.

Why The Barristers Inc. is the Right Choice for Your Probate Dispute

Probate disputes are often highly personal and emotionally charged. They require not only an expert legal mind but also a sensitive and strategic approach. The barristers at The Barristers Inc. (TBI) are experts in civil litigation and dispute resolution, making them ideally suited to handle these contentious matters.

A Cohesive and Comprehensive Legal Service

At TBI, our barristers are not confined to a single specialism. While we have deep expertise in will and probate disputes, our barristers also specialise in related areas such as civil litigation, property and boundary disputes, and landlord and tenant matters. This multi-faceted expertise is invaluable in a probate case, as the dispute may involve other legal issues, such as a claim over a piece of land owned by the deceased, or a debt owed to the estate. Our barristers can handle all of these legal aspects simultaneously, providing a seamless and cohesive strategy.

By instructing a TBI barrister directly, you gain a single point of contact who can guide you through every stage of the process. We can advise you on the merits of your case, negotiate with the other parties, draft all necessary court documents, and represent you at a mediation or a full trial. This direct access model ensures that you receive expert legal advice and representation without the need for a separate solicitor, providing a more efficient and often more cost-effective service.

The TBI Advantage: Unrestricted Advocacy and Expertise

Our barristers have an unrestricted right of audience in all courts, ensuring that whatever the complexity of your case, you have an expert advocate on your side. We can handle everything from an initial application to the Probate Registry to a full-blown trial in the High Court. We are adept at managing highly sensitive and complex family disputes, providing objective and strategic advice to help you navigate a challenging time. Our goal is to achieve the best possible outcome for you, whether that is through a negotiated settlement or a robust and successful court action.

Seeking Expert Counsel for Your Estate Dispute

A probate dispute can be a distressing and complex experience. The legal issues involved are often highly technical, and the emotional toll can be immense. Seeking legal advice from a specialist barrister is the most prudent step you can take. They can clarify your legal position, advise you on your options, and provide the expert advocacy you need to protect your rights. The Barristers Inc. stands ready to provide you with the expert, compassionate, and effective legal representation you require. If you believe you have grounds to challenge a will or the administration of an estate, contact us today to discuss your case and find out how we can help you find a resolution.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Can a Will be Rectified If it Contains a Mistake?  
Yes, a will can be rectified if it contains a mistake, but only under very specific and limited circumstances. Rectification of a will is the process by which the High...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Represent Myself in a Will Dispute?
A will dispute can be an emotionally charged and legally complex matter. It’s understandable to consider representing yourself to save on legal fees, particularly when the value of the estate...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Settle a Will Dispute Out of Court?
A dispute over a will can be one of the most emotionally charged and legally complex situations a family can face. The grief of losing a loved one, coupled with...Read More
Toggle Icon
How do I Find a Good will Dispute Barrister in London?
A will dispute can be a deeply personal and emotionally taxing ordeal. Unlike other legal matters, it often involves family members, and the outcome can have a profound impact on...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Much Does a Will Dispute Barrister Cost?
The cost of engaging a barrister for a will dispute is a significant consideration for anyone involved in a contentious probate matter. There is no single answer to this question,...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link