A breach of contract is a failure, without legal excuse, to perform any promise that forms the whole or part of a contract. This is a very broad term that can cover a range of failures, from a minor delay in delivery to a complete failure to perform.
The legal consequences of a breach depend on the type of term that has been breached. The law divides contractual terms into three main categories:
These are fundamental terms that go to the very root of the contract. A breach of a condition is a serious matter that allows the innocent party to terminate the contract and claim damages.
These are minor or subsidiary terms of the contract. A breach of a warranty does not give the innocent party the right to terminate the contract. They can only claim damages.
These are terms that are not clearly defined as a condition or a warranty. The court will assess the severity of the breach itself to determine the appropriate remedy. If the breach deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit of the contract, it will be treated as a breach of a condition.
Repudiation, also known as a repudiatory breach, is a fundamental breach of contract that is so serious it goes to the root of the contract and shows that the breaching party no longer intends to be bound by its terms.
A repudiation can be:
This occurs when a party explicitly states that they will not perform their contractual obligations. For example, a supplier sends a letter stating they will not be able to deliver the goods as promised.
This occurs when a party’s conduct shows that they no longer intend to be bound by the contract. For example, a contractor ceases all work on a building project and moves their equipment off-site.
An anticipatory breach is a form of repudiation that occurs before the time for performance of the contract has arrived. It is a clear statement or action by one party that they will not be performing their obligations when the time comes. This gives the innocent party an immediate right to choose their remedy without having to wait for the actual breach.
The legal consequences of a breach of contract and a repudiation are very different, particularly regarding the innocent party’s right to terminate the contract.
For a simple breach of contract, the innocent party’s only remedy is usually a claim for damages. They cannot terminate the contract and must continue to fulfil their own obligations. The purpose of the damages is to put the innocent party in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed.
When a repudiatory breach occurs, the innocent party has a choice:
They can choose to continue with the contract and treat it as still being in force. They can still claim damages for the breach but lose the right to terminate.
They can accept the repudiation, terminate the contract, and claim damages for all the losses suffered as a result of the repudiation. The contract is then discharged, and both parties are released from their future obligations.
Terminating a contract for a breach that is not repudiatory carries a significant risk. If the innocent party wrongly terminates the contract, they may be found to be the one who has committed a repudiatory breach.
If a party terminates a contract for what they mistakenly believe is a fundamental breach, a court may find that their action was, in fact, a wrongful repudiation. This means they would then be liable to pay damages to the other side for terminating the contract without a legal right to do so. This is why it is crucial to seek expert legal advice before terminating a contract.