A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when an individual or organisation, known as a fiduciary, fails to act with complete loyalty and in the best interests of another party, the principal, to whom they owe a special legal duty of trust and confidence. This duty is considered a higher standard than a typical contractual or tortious duty of care and is rooted in the principle of equity. It arises in relationships where one party places trust in another to act on their behalf in a matter, particularly concerning financial or legal matters.
A fiduciary relationship is not one of arm’s-length commerce. Instead, it is a relationship of trust and confidence, where the fiduciary has a legal obligation to put the interests of their principal before their own.
The law recognises several established categories of fiduciary relationships. These are not exhaustive, and a court can determine that a fiduciary relationship exists in other circumstances. Common examples include:
The duties of a fiduciary are distinct from a mere contractual duty. While a contract requires parties to act in a certain way, a fiduciary duty requires a higher standard of loyalty and good faith, often extending beyond the express terms of a contract. A breach of fiduciary duty can occur even if the fiduciary has not breached a contractual term.
A fiduciary is bound by strict duties that are often referred to as the “no-conflict” and “no-profit” rules. These duties are designed to prevent the fiduciary from abusing their position for personal gain.
This is the most fundamental duty of a fiduciary. It requires the fiduciary to act in good faith and with undivided loyalty to their principal. They must not allow their personal interests to conflict with their duty to the principal. This duty is so strict that even if the fiduciary acts in good faith and the principal suffers no loss, a breach can still be found.
A fiduciary must not place themselves in a position where their personal interests, or their duty to a third party, could potentially conflict with their duty to their principal. Even the appearance of a conflict is a serious matter. This duty is often violated by directors who approve transactions that benefit themselves or a related company.
A fiduciary must not profit from their position without the full and informed consent of the principal. This is a strict rule; even if the principal would not have been able to make the profit themselves, the fiduciary is still not entitled to it. A classic example is a director who diverts a business opportunity away from the company to their own personal benefit.
A breach of fiduciary duty can take many forms, from active dishonesty to passive neglect.
A fiduciary using the principal’s funds or property for their own personal benefit.
A fiduciary taking advantage of a business opportunity that arose from their position and should have been offered to the principal.
A fiduciary entering into a transaction with the principal without disclosing a personal interest in the deal.
A fiduciary using confidential information obtained through their position for their own gain or for the benefit of a third party.
The remedies available for a breach of fiduciary duty are particularly powerful, as they are based on the principles of equity, which aim to be fair and just.
This remedy requires the fiduciary to surrender any profits they made from the breach, regardless of whether the principal suffered a loss. This is a powerful deterrent and is based on the principle that a fiduciary should not benefit from their wrongdoing.
The principal can claim compensation for any loss they suffered as a direct result of the breach. The goal is to put the principal back in the financial position they would have been in had the breach not occurred.
If the fiduciary has acquired property or assets from the breach, the court can impose a constructive trust, which means the property is held on trust for the principal, who can then claim ownership of it.
A court can grant an injunction to prevent the fiduciary from committing further breaches of their duty.
Allegations of a breach of fiduciary duty are serious and can lead to significant financial and personal consequences. At TBI – The Barristers Inc., our expert barristers and solicitors specialise in civil litigation and corporate and contract law. We have a proven track record in handling complex disputes and can provide you with a comprehensive legal service. Our barristers can assess your case, advise you on the available remedies, and provide expert representation in court. We can assist by:
Our firm’s expertise also extends to immigration, will and probate, landlord and tenant, and property and boundary disputes, ensuring we can provide a holistic approach to your legal needs.