Partnership disputes are a common feature of the business landscape in England and Wales. A partnership is often founded on trust and a shared vision, but when disagreements arise, they can threaten the very existence of the business. The legal framework governing partnerships is the Partnership Act 1890, but in practice, most disputes stem from a lack of clarity in a formal partnership agreement
In England and Wales, a partnership can be formed without any formal written agreement. The Partnership Act 1890 governs the default position, which dictates that partners share equally in the profits and losses and have an equal say in the management of the business. However, relying on this statutory framework leaves a business vulnerable to disputes, as it does not account for the complexities of a modern business or the specific contributions of each partner. A well-drafted partnership agreement is the single most important tool for preventing and resolving disputes.
Answer: While a partnership can exist without a formal agreement, it is strongly advised to have one. A partnership agreement defines the rights and obligations of each partner, sets out how decisions will be made, and establishes a clear process for resolving disputes. Without one, any disagreement is governed by the rigid rules of the Partnership Act 1890, which can lead to protracted and costly litigation.
One of the most frequent causes of disputes is a disagreement over finances. This can include the division of profits, the amount of money each partner is entitled to draw from the business, or a disagreement over how capital is invested. If there is no clear agreement, a partner may feel they are being unfairly compensated for their efforts or that their funds are being used inappropriately.
A fiduciary duty is a legal obligation to act in the best interests of the partnership, not for personal gain. A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when a partner acts in a way that is contrary to this obligation. This could include secretly competing with the partnership, diverting business opportunities, or failing to disclose a conflict of interest. Such a breach can completely erode trust and is a common cause for seeking the dissolution of the partnership.
Answer: A breach of fiduciary duty is when a partner or person in a position of trust fails to act in the best interests of the company or partnership. For example, in the landmark case of Pathirana v Pathirana [1967], a partner in a business secretly set up a new company to compete with the original partnership. The court ruled that this was a clear breach of fiduciary duty, as he was acting in his own self-interest rather than the interests of the partnership.
Partners may have different visions for the future of the business. One partner may want to expand, while another may prefer to maintain the status quo. These disagreements over management, strategy, or the direction of the business can become major issues if there is no clear decision-making process outlined in a partnership agreement.
Answer: Generally, a partner cannot be forced out of a partnership against their will unless there is a specific provision for it in a partnership agreement. The Partnership Act 1890 does not provide a mechanism for this. However, if a partner has committed a serious breach of contract or a fundamental breach of fiduciary duty, the other partners can seek a court order for the dissolution of the partnership.
The best way to deal with a partnership dispute is to prevent it from happening in the first place. This begins with drafting a comprehensive partnership agreement that addresses all potential points of conflict. It should cover:
If a dispute does arise, resorting to formal litigation should be a last resort. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods, such as Mediation and arbitration, are often a more cost-effective and time-efficient way to resolve disputes. In Mediation, a neutral third party helps the partners reach a mutually agreeable solution. In arbitration, an independent third party makes a binding decision.
Answer: At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our expert barristers specialise in corporate and contract disputes and have a wealth of experience in resolving complex partnership issues. We can assist you by: