It’s a common and frustrating situation for a tenant to find that their landlord is neglecting their legal duty to make repairs. Fortunately, tenants in England and Wales have several legal avenues to compel their landlord to act, and in some cases, to seek compensation. The initial steps involve clear communication and documentation, followed by escalating the matter to local authorities and, if necessary, pursuing a civil claim for disrepair.
A landlord’s duty to carry out repairs is not just a matter of good practice; it’s a legal obligation that is either explicitly stated in the tenancy agreement or implied by law.
A key piece of legislation governing a landlord’s obligations is the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Section 11 of this Act sets out the landlord’s statutory duty to repair the structure and exterior of the property, including drains, gutters, and external pipes. It also covers the upkeep of installations for the supply of water, gas, electricity, sanitation, and for space and water heating. The Homes (Fitness for Human Habitation) Act 2018 further strengthened this obligation by requiring landlords to ensure that a property is fit for human habitation at the start of the tenancy and throughout.
Disrepair is a legal term that refers to a state of being broken, damaged, or in a condition that is no longer fit for purpose. It is distinct from issues that might be deemed minor or aesthetic. For example, a leak in the roof, a broken boiler, or a severe damp problem would all be considered disrepair.
Before taking any formal legal action, a tenant should follow a clear and documented process to inform the landlord of the issue.
The first step is to formally notify the landlord in writing. This is crucial as a landlord is only legally liable for disrepair from the point they are made aware of it. The letter should detail the problems, reference the relevant sections of the tenancy agreement, include clear photographs or videos as evidence, and give a reasonable deadline for the repairs to be completed. This letter serves as a formal “letter before action,” which is a mandatory pre-action step in any subsequent legal claim.
Keep copies of all correspondence, including emails, letters, and text messages. Maintain a detailed log of all communication, noting the date, time, and content of each conversation. This creates a strong evidential trail that will be essential in any legal proceedings.
If the landlord fails to respond or take action, a tenant can escalate the issue to their local council’s Environmental Health department.
An Environmental Health Officer (EHO) can inspect the property and assess the severity of the disrepair. If they find that the issues pose a risk to the tenant’s health and safety, they have the power to serve an enforcement notice on the landlord. A landlord who fails to comply with this notice could face a fine and may also be prevented from serving a Section 21 notice to evict the tenant.
No, you can’t. Withholding rent is a dangerous step that can put you in breach of contract and give your landlord grounds to evict you. The legal process for withholding rent is complex and requires you to have a solicitor’s support and a separate client account. The correct procedure is to pay the rent into this account until the repairs are completed, but this should never be done without professional legal advice.
If all other avenues fail, a tenant may have grounds for a formal civil claim against their landlord.
A tenant can sue their landlord for breach of contract. The court can award damages to the tenant to compensate for the discomfort, inconvenience, or personal injury caused by the disrepair. The court can also issue an injunction, which is a legally binding order compelling the landlord to carry out the repairs.
For claims for damages under £10,000, the claim can be made through the County Court’s Small Claims Track, a more streamlined process than a full trial.
The law provides protection against this. If a tenant complains to their landlord in writing about disrepair and the landlord then serves a Section 21 notice (a “no-fault” eviction notice), the tenant can challenge it. The tenant may have a defence against eviction if the local authority has served an improvement or emergency works notice on the landlord. This is known as “retaliatory eviction.”
Handling a disrepair claim against a landlord can be a daunting process. At TBI – The Barristers Inc., our expert barristers and solicitors specialise in landlord and tenant law and can provide comprehensive guidance and representation. We can assist by: