Probate disputes can be highly distressing and are becoming increasingly common in England and Wales. While a will is intended to provide certainty, disputes often arise when a person feels they have been unfairly treated or when the will itself is legally flawed. The common causes can be categorised into two main areas: challenges to the will’s validity and disputes over the administration or contents of the estate.
The most direct way to challenge a will is to argue that it is invalid. The law requires a will to meet certain criteria, and a failure to meet these criteria can be a ground for dispute.
This is one of the most common grounds for a dispute. It concerns the mental capacity of the person who made the will (the testator). To have testamentary capacity, a person must be of sound mind, memory, and understanding when they make the will.
Testamentary capacity is a legal concept that requires a person to understand the nature and effect of a will, the extent of their property, and the people to whom they are giving their property. It is important because if the person lacked this capacity, the will is legally void. A person with a medical condition such as dementia may be found to lack this capacity, but it is not a given; it depends on the individual circumstances at the time the will was made.
A will can be challenged on the grounds of undue influence if a person was coerced or pressured into making a will in a way they did not truly intend.
A claim for undue influence is difficult to prove. It requires evidence that a person’s free will was completely overborne by another. This can involve a person in a position of power, such as a carer or a relative, putting pressure on a vulnerable person to change their will in their favour.
Even if a will is valid, a dispute can arise over how the estate is administered or distributed.
The law in England and Wales does not give an absolute right of inheritance. A person can be disinherited from a will, even if they are a close family member.
Yes. Under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, a person who was a family member or financially dependent on the deceased can make a claim for reasonable financial provision if they were left out of a will or the will did not provide for them adequately.
A dispute can also arise if an executor, the person named to administer the estate, is not acting correctly. The executor owes a fiduciary duty to the beneficiaries to act in their best interests.
An executor de son tort is a person who intermeddles with the deceased’s estate without legal authority, for example, by distributing assets before a grant of probate has been issued. This can lead to a dispute as they can be held personally liable for the estate’s debts.
Probate disputes are legally complex and often emotionally charged. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our expert barristers are on hand to provide specialist legal services. We can advise you on your rights and assist you in protecting your inheritance. Our expertise covers a wide range of legal areas, including: