The ability to force someone to honour their contractual obligations is a powerful and exceptional legal remedy. While most contract disputes are settled with an award of monetary damages, this financial compensation is not always a sufficient solution. Specific performance is a court order that compels a party to perform their duties under a contract exactly as they were agreed upon. It is a serious legal step that is not granted lightly. A barrister, as a specialist in contract law and advocacy, is essential for demonstrating to the court that specific performance is the only adequate remedy for your loss.
Specific performance is an equitable remedy available for a breach of contract in England and Wales. It is a court decree that compels a party to perform their contractual obligations. It is a powerful remedy that is granted at the court’s discretion, not as a right. A court will only grant an order for specific performance when a monetary award of damages would be an inadequate remedy for the claimant’s loss.
Specific performance is a remedy of last resort. The court’s default position is that a contract breach can be remedied by an award of damages, which is a common law remedy available as of right. For specific performance to be granted, a claimant must demonstrate that money alone cannot compensate for the harm caused by the breach. This is most often the case when the subject of the contract is unique and cannot be replaced. For example, a contract for the sale of land is almost always considered unique, as is a contract for a unique piece of art or a custom-made item.
The power to order specific performance is discretionary, which means the court must be convinced that it is the most appropriate remedy for the situation. The court applies a two-part test to determine whether to grant the order.
The court’s primary consideration is whether damages would be an adequate remedy. If the subject of the contract is something that can be easily bought or replaced on the open market, an order for specific performance is highly unlikely to be granted. For example, if a contract for the sale of a common model of car is breached, the claimant can simply use the money from a damages award to buy another car. However, if the contract is for a unique item such as an antique, a rare book, or a specific piece of land, money is not an adequate remedy because a substitute is not available. This is why specific performance is most commonly used in disputes over the sale of land, as every parcel of land is considered unique.
Because specific performance is an equitable remedy, the court will refuse to grant an order if it would be unfair or impractical to do so. The court’s discretion is guided by several key principles:
Specific performance is a powerful tool, but it is not applicable in every situation. Its use is most common in a few specific types of contracts where the subject matter is, by its nature, unique.
Specific performance is most suitable for the following types of contracts:
A court will not enforce a contract if its terms are ambiguous or uncertain. To be enforceable, a contract must be clear and precise, leaving no doubt about the obligations of each party. This is particularly important for specific performance, as the court must be able to specify exactly what the defendant is required to do. This is why it is essential to have a clear, well-drafted contract from the outset.
Securing a specific performance order is a complex legal process that requires the skill and expertise of a specialist barrister. At TBI, our barristers are experts in contract law and can provide the strategic advantage needed to secure this remedy.
TBI’s barristers have a strong history of advising on remedies for breach of contract. We provide an objective, client-specific legal strategy, assessing the merits of your case and advising on the most effective course of action. We can determine whether specific performance is a viable remedy and whether your claim meets the court’s strict criteria.
Our barristers can assist you in several ways:
Specific performance is a powerful legal tool for a serious situation. It is the remedy that can secure what you were promised when money alone is not enough. To protect your rights and ensure you get what you were promised, it is essential to seek expert legal advice from a specialist barrister.