Shareholder disputes are a frequent and often damaging feature of the corporate landscape in England and Wales. A company, unlike a partnership, is a separate legal entity, but its success still relies heavily on the relationship between its owners and directors. When this relationship breaks down, it can threaten the company’s stability and financial health. While some disputes are a matter of a simple breach of contract, others involve complex legal claims, such as unfair prejudice, that can only be resolved through a formal legal process.
Every company in England and Wales is governed by its articles of association, a public document that sets out the company’s internal rules. However, for a private company, the articles of association are often supplemented by a private shareholders’ agreement. While not legally required, a well-drafted shareholders’ agreement is the single most important tool for preventing and resolving disputes. It can be tailored to the specific needs of the shareholders, defining their rights and obligations in a way that the standard articles of association cannot.
Answer: While a company can function without a shareholders’ agreement, it is highly recommended to have one. An agreement can establish how decisions are made, set out a clear procedure for a director’s removal, and define a process for resolving disputes. Without one, the company is governed by the standard articles of association and the Companies Act 2006, which may not be sufficient to protect a minority shareholder’s interests.
One of the most frequent causes of disputes is a disagreement over finances. This can include the payment of dividends, a disagreement over how profits are reinvested, or allegations of financial mismanagement. Similarly, disputes over the management of the company can arise when a minority shareholder feels they are being excluded from key decisions, or if there is a fundamental difference in the strategic direction of the company.
A key legal ground for a shareholder dispute is a claim of unfair prejudice. This is a powerful remedy for a minority shareholder who believes the company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner that is unfairly prejudicial to their interests. The actions do not have to be illegal, but they must be “unfair.” This is a broad term, and it can include actions such as a director excluding a shareholder from management, improperly diverting company assets, or a failure to pay dividends.
Answer: Unfair prejudice is a legal remedy under the Companies Act 2006 that allows a shareholder to petition the court for an order to remedy the unfair way in which the company’s affairs have been conducted. The most common remedy is for the court to order the majority shareholder to buy the minority shareholder’s shares at a fair value.
A landmark case in this area is O’Neill v Phillips [1999], where the House of Lords clarified the law on unfair prejudice. It held that a company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner that is unfairly prejudicial if a minority shareholder has been treated unfairly, even if the actions were not technically a breach of contract. The court will look at whether the actions were a departure from the “agreed understanding” between the shareholders.
Company directors owe a fiduciary duty to the company to act in its best interests. This is a higher standard than the duty owed by a partner. A breach of fiduciary duty occurs when a director acts in a way that is contrary to this obligation, such as by secretly competing with the company, failing to disclose a conflict of interest, or improperly diverting company assets.
Answer: A minority shareholder cannot be forced out of a company unless a specific provision for it exists in the articles of association or a shareholders’ agreement. Without such a provision, a majority shareholder who tries to force a minority shareholder out may be met with a claim of unfair prejudice. A court, in such a case, may order a “buy-out” of the minority shareholder’s shares at a fair value, effectively forcing the majority shareholder to purchase them.
The best way to deal with a shareholder dispute is to prevent it from happening in the first place. This begins with drafting a comprehensive shareholders’ agreement that addresses all potential points of conflict. It should cover:
If a dispute does arise, resorting to formal litigation should be a last resort. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) methods, such as Mediation and arbitration, are often a more cost-effective and time-efficient way to resolve disputes. In Mediation, a neutral third party helps the shareholders reach a mutually agreeable solution. In arbitration, an independent third party makes a binding decision.
Answer: At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our expert barristers specialise in corporate and contract disputes and have a wealth of experience in resolving complex shareholder issues. We can assist you by: