Breaching director’s duties can lead to severe consequences for a company director in England and Wales. These consequences can be both civil and, in some cases, criminal, leading to personal liability, fines, and even imprisonment. The duties, primarily set out in the Companies Act 2006, are owed to the company itself, and a breach can result in legal action being brought against the director.
A director who breaches their duties can face personal liability for losses suffered by the company. This is a crucial distinction, as the principle of limited liability that protects shareholders and the company does not extend to a director’s personal conduct.
The company can seek various remedies against a director who has breached their duties. These often involve recovering losses or ill-gotten gains. For instance, the court may order a director to pay damages to the company for a loss caused by their negligence or to compensate the company for a poor decision. In cases where a director has profited from a breach of their fiduciary duty, the company can claim for disgorgement of profits, forcing the director to return any financial gain.
Generally, a director is not personally liable for a company’s debts due to the principle of limited liability. However, this protection is lost if a director is found to have engaged in wrongful trading or fraudulent trading, which are both breaches of duty. In such cases, the court can order the director to contribute to the company’s debts.
While most breaches of director’s duties are civil matters, some are considered serious enough to be criminal offences under the Companies Act 2006 or other legislation.
A director can face criminal charges for certain breaches, such as falsifying company records, failing to file accounts, or engaging in fraudulent trading with the intention to defraud creditors. The consequences for these offences can include substantial fines or even a prison sentence.
A civil breach typically results in a claim for compensation or a remedy for the company’s loss, whereas a criminal breach is a more serious offence against the state, often involving an element of dishonesty or fraud. A civil breach is brought by the company (or by shareholders on its behalf), while a criminal prosecution is brought by a public body, such as the police or the Insolvency Service.
One of the most significant consequences of a serious breach of duty is disqualification from acting as a director in the future.
Under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986, the court can make a disqualification order against a director who is deemed “unfit” to hold a leadership position in a company. This can happen in cases of misconduct, such as negligence, failure to file accounts, or breaching fiduciary duties.
Yes. While many disqualifications occur when a company becomes insolvent, a director can be disqualified even if the company is still trading. The focus is on the director’s conduct and whether it falls below the standard of care expected under the Companies Act 2006.
Facing allegations of a breach of director’s duties can be a daunting and complex experience. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our expert barristers are on hand to provide specialist legal services. We offer comprehensive advice and robust representation in all aspects of company and contract law, including cases involving allegations of breaches of director’s duties. We can assist you by: