FAQ
Home / FAQs / Dispute Resolution / How Can I Protect Myself From Aggressive or Unfair Tactics Employed by the Opposing Party?

How Can I Protect Myself From Aggressive or Unfair Tactics Employed by the Opposing Party?

Litigation is, by its very nature, an adversarial process. While the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) of England & Wales are designed to ensure that cases are managed fairly and justly, some parties may choose to employ aggressive or unfair tactics to gain an advantage. These tactics can be intimidating, costly, and designed to put undue pressure on an opponent. However, the legal system provides a robust set of protections and remedies to ensure that such behaviour is not only penalised but also actively prevented from derailing a case. Navigating a hostile litigation environment requires an understanding of these protections and the proactive use of legal tools to restore balance and fairness to the process.

Recognising Unfair Tactics

Before you can defend yourself, you must first be able to identify the aggressive or unfair tactics being used against you. These tactics often fall into a few common categories, all of which are designed to waste time, increase costs, and wear down the opposing party.

Delaying Tactics

A common form of aggressive behaviour is to deliberately slow down the progress of a case. This can be achieved by:

  • Making unnecessary applications: The opposing party may file numerous applications to the court for minor matters or for extensions of time that are not justified.
  • Failing to meet deadlines: They may consistently miss deadlines for filing documents or providing information, forcing you to chase them and apply for court orders.
  • Refusing to cooperate: They may refuse to engage in pre-action correspondence or settlement discussions in good faith, forcing the matter into formal court proceedings.

Excessive Demands and “Fishing Expeditions”

Another tactic is to make unreasonable or disproportionate demands. This can include:

  • Excessive requests for information: A party might ask for a vast quantity of documents or answers to a long list of questions, often with the primary aim of overwhelming you with work and driving up your legal costs. This is often referred to as a “fishing expedition,” where a party is hoping to uncover a new claim rather than seeking information relevant to the existing dispute.
  • Disproportionate use of expert witnesses: They may insist on multiple expert reports or unnecessary site visits, again with the aim of increasing the financial burden on you.

Intimidation and Harassment

  • In some cases, the tactics go beyond procedural misconduct and stray into direct intimidation. This can take the form of:
  • Threatening communications: Sending overly aggressive or threatening letters that go beyond the bounds of professional legal correspondence.
  • Making spurious allegations: Raising baseless accusations against you or your legal team in an attempt to discredit you or distract from the core issues of the case.

Legal Protections and Remedies at Your Disposal

The Civil Procedure Rules are the core framework for legal proceedings in England & Wales, and they are built to prevent and penalise such improper conduct.

Case Management and Court Control

The court has an overriding objective to deal with cases justly and at a proportionate cost. To this end, judges actively manage cases through Case Management Conferences (CMCs). At a CMC, the judge will set a clear timetable for the case, including deadlines for filing evidence and a date for trial. If a party fails to comply with the court’s orders, the judge has the power to impose penalties, including striking out their claim or defence. This proactive management by the court is one of the most effective ways to counter delaying tactics.

Wasted Costs Orders

One of the most potent tools against aggressive and improper conduct is a wasted costs order. This is a court order that requires a solicitor or barrister to personally pay the legal costs of the other party if their conduct has been deemed improper, unreasonable, or negligent. It is a direct sanction against the legal representative, not their client, and it is reserved for serious misconduct. For example, if a solicitor makes a baseless application to the court or fails to prepare for a hearing, a judge can order them to personally pay the wasted costs incurred by the other side. This power serves as a strong deterrent against aggressive and unprofessional behaviour.

What is a ‘wasted costs order’ and when can it be used?

A: A wasted costs order is an order for a legal representative to pay the costs that a party has incurred as a result of their improper, unreasonable, or negligent conduct. It is a powerful sanction used by the court to penalise lawyers for their own misconduct. For the court to grant such an order, the applicant must demonstrate a clear causal link between the solicitor’s conduct and the wasted costs. It is not used for minor errors but for serious failings that have caused a party to incur unnecessary expense.

Interim Injunctions

In situations where an opposing party is actively engaging in harmful or harassing behaviour, an interim injunction may be necessary. This is a court order that compels a party to either do something or, more commonly, to refrain from doing something. In the context of aggressive tactics, a claimant might seek an injunction to prevent the defendant from harassing them or from publishing defamatory material. These orders are powerful, as a breach can lead to a finding of contempt of court and, in serious cases, imprisonment.

Part 36 Offers: A Tactical Weapon

A Part 36 offer is a powerful tactical tool under the Civil Procedure Rules designed to encourage parties to settle out of court. If you make a formal offer to settle under Part 36 and the other party refuses it, there are significant cost consequences if they later fail to beat your offer at trial. For example, if you offer to settle for £10,000 and the other side rejects it, but is only awarded £8,000 at trial, they will not only be responsible for their own legal costs but may also have to pay a portion of your costs from the date the offer was made. This can put immense pressure on an aggressive opponent to settle, as it exposes them to significant financial risk.

Q: How does a ‘without prejudice’ offer protect me?

A: The without prejudice rule is a legal principle that allows parties to negotiate a settlement without the risk of their concessions or admissions being used against them in court. Any communication made on a “without prejudice” basis cannot be shown to the judge as evidence of an admission. This encourages open and frank settlement discussions. A Part 36 offer, however, is an exception; it is made on a “without prejudice save as to costs” basis, meaning it cannot be used during the trial but can be brought to the judge’s attention on the issue of costs after a judgment has been reached.

How The Barristers Inc. Can Assist

  • Facing an aggressive opponent in a legal dispute can be daunting, but you are not without protection. At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), our expert barristers have extensive experience in civil litigation and dispute resolution. We are not just reactive; we are proactive in protecting our clients from unfair and improper tactics.
  • Our approach begins with a thorough analysis of the opposing party’s conduct. We will advise you on the most effective legal strategies to counter their behaviour, whether that involves making a specific application to the court for case management directions or seeking an interim injunction to stop a harmful act. Our team is skilled at using the tools of the Civil Procedure Rules, such as Part 36 offers and applications for wasted costs orders, to put pressure on the opposing party and their legal representatives, holding them accountable for their actions.
  • We handle complex matters across our core practice areas, including civil litigation, corporate disputes, and landlord and tenant disagreements. Our expertise ensures that we can anticipate and respond to aggressive tactics with the full force of the law, ensuring that your case proceeds on its merits, not on the basis of intimidation or procedural gamesmanship.

Q: Can I report a solicitor for aggressive behaviour?

A: Yes. In England & Wales, you can report a solicitor to the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA), which regulates the professional conduct of solicitors. The SRA’s Code of Conduct requires solicitors to act with integrity and uphold the rule of law. A pattern of aggressive, harassing, or dishonest behaviour could be a breach of these rules. While the SRA does not provide a remedy for your personal case, it can investigate the solicitor’s conduct and take disciplinary action if a serious breach is found.

Strategic Approach to Litigation

Aggressive litigation tactics are a reality in some disputes, but they are not insurmountable. The legal system of England & Wales provides numerous powerful tools to counteract such behaviour. The key to protecting yourself is to have experienced legal counsel who can not only identify these tactics but also deploy the correct legal and procedural remedies to neutralise them. At The Barristers Inc., we ensure that your legal journey is conducted fairly and justly, providing you with the peace of mind that comes from knowing you are represented by professionals who will fight tirelessly to protect your interests.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
What is the Typical Timeline for Resolving a Dispute?  
The timeline for resolving a dispute in England and Wales is not fixed and can vary dramatically depending on a multitude of factors. While some disputes can be settled in...Read More
Toggle Icon
What is the Difference Between Mediation and Arbitration?  
In the legal landscape of England and Wales, both mediation and arbitration are prominent forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). They serve as alternatives to traditional court litigation, offering a...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Are Settlements and Court Orders Enforced If the Other Party Does Not Comply?  
In the legal landscape of England and Wales, both mediation and arbitration are prominent forms of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). They serve as alternatives to traditional court litigation, offering a...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can a Direct Access Barrister Represent Me in Court for a Dispute Resolution Hearing?  
A direct access barrister is a barrister who can be instructed directly by a member of the public without the need for a solicitor. The Direct Public Access scheme, authorised...Read More
Toggle Icon
Are There any Alternative Fee Arrangements Available?
In the traditional legal landscape, clients have long been accustomed to the 'billable hour' model, a system where fees are calculated based on the time a solicitor or barrister spends...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link