The duration of a legal appeal in England and Wales is highly variable and depends on a range of factors, from the specific court to the complexity of the case. Unlike a first-instance trial, which has a more predictable structure, the appeals process is subject to court backlogs, the nature of the legal points at issue, and the diligence of the parties involved. A simple appeal might conclude in under a year, while complex cases can take several years to reach a final decision.
The length of an appeal is heavily influenced by the court handling it. An appeal from a Magistrates’ Court to the Crown Court, for example, is generally much faster than an appeal from the High Court to the Court of Appeal, or ultimately, to the Supreme Court. The more complex the legal issues—for instance, in a large-scale civil litigation or a complex corporate and contract dispute—the more time the courts will need to consider the arguments and write a judgment.
An appeal is not a retrial. It is a review of the original court’s decision. An appeal can generally only be made on a point of law, not on a point of fact, unless the original judge made a clear and obvious mistake. The most common grounds for appeal are that the original judge made a mistake of law, or that the decision was unjust because of a serious procedural or other irregularity. This narrow scope means the process is more focused, but it also means the arguments must be carefully constructed, which takes time.
Answer: Generally, no. The appellate courts in England and Wales are reluctant to interfere with a trial judge’s findings of fact, as they had the benefit of hearing the evidence and observing the witnesses. An appeal is usually limited to points of law. However, an exception might be made if the judge’s factual finding was irrational or perverse, meaning no reasonable judge could have reached that conclusion. This is a high threshold to meet and makes appeals on factual grounds very challenging.
The first and often most challenging hurdle is obtaining permission to appeal. In most cases, you cannot simply file a notice of appeal; you must first convince either the original court or the appellate court that your case has a real prospect of success or that there is some other compelling reason for the appeal to be heard.
Answer: Permission to appeal, also known as “leave,” is the court’s approval for an appeal to proceed. It is a vital filtering mechanism that prevents the appellate courts from being overwhelmed with unmeritorious cases. The time it takes to get permission varies. A written application can take several weeks or months to be decided. If the application is refused on paper, the appellant can request an oral hearing to argue their case for leave, which will add further time to the process.
Once permission is granted, the parties will prepare for the appeal hearing. This involves the appellant and the respondent filing detailed skeleton arguments, bundles of evidence, and legal authorities. The time it takes for the hearing to be listed can vary significantly depending on court backlogs. In the Court of Appeal, it can take several months or even over a year for a hearing date to be secured. The hearing itself may last from a few hours to several days.
Answer: The time it takes to get a decision after the appeal hearing can vary. In straightforward cases, the judges may provide a decision on the same day. However, in more complex cases, the judges will “reserve judgment,” meaning they will take time to deliberate and write a full, reasoned judgment. This process can take several weeks or months, and in very complex or significant cases, it could take over a year.
A landmark case that illustrates the lengthy nature of the appeal process is the long-running Berezovsky v Abramovich civil litigation. The case went through multiple appeals and tribunals, highlighting how a complex commercial dispute can be a protracted, multi-year process that tests the limits of the legal system and the patience of the parties involved.
At TBI, our expert barristers are experienced in the intricacies of the appeals process, having represented clients in appeals stemming from will and probate, corporate and contract, and immigration disputes. We understand that the appeal is often the last opportunity to reverse a negative outcome, and we treat it with the seriousness and diligence it deserves.
We work proactively to ensure all deadlines are met and that the legal arguments are as robust and compelling as possible. This includes: