Tenancy agreements, whether written or verbal, typically contain a covenant for the tenant to pay rent and for the landlord to maintain the property. These are separate obligations. You cannot simply stop paying rent because your landlord is in breach of contract for not making repairs.
If you unilaterally withhold rent, your landlord has the right to treat this as a breach of your tenancy agreement. They can issue a Section 8 notice to end the tenancy on the grounds of rent arrears. This can lead to a formal possession claim in court, and if the court rules in the landlord’s favour, a possession order will be issued, which can result in your eviction.
No. Even in urgent circumstances, such as a broken boiler or a serious leak, you do not have an automatic right to withhold rent. The correct legal procedure must be followed to avoid a possession claim against you. The law provides for a ‘right to set-off’ in very specific circumstances, but this must be done correctly.
The only legal way to withhold rent is by using the right to set-off. This is a common law remedy that allows a tenant to deduct the cost of repairs from the rent they owe, but it requires a strict procedure to be followed.
To exercise the right to set-off, you must:
The right to set-off is a legal principle that allows you to deduct a sum of money from what you owe if the other party owes you a debt from a related transaction. In this case, your landlord’s failure to make repairs is a breach of their statutory duty under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, which gives rise to a debt in your favour.
You must keep record of all communications, including dates and times, copies of all letters sent to the landlord, and all quotes and receipts for the repair work. This documentation is crucial evidence in court if your landlord tries to pursue a possession claim against you.
Navigating landlord and tenant disputes is legally complex, and making a mistake can have severe consequences, including eviction. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our expert barristers are on hand to provide specialist legal services. We can advise you on your rights and obligations, ensuring all legal requirements are met to protect your tenancy and recover the costs of repairs. We can assist you by: