FAQ
Home / FAQs / Landlord & Tenant / Will I Have to Go to Court?

Will I Have to Go to Court?

It is a common misconception that all legal disputes end up in a courtroom. In reality, the vast majority of civil disputes in England and Wales are resolved without the need for a full trial. This is a deliberate policy of the legal system, which encourages parties to explore all possible avenues for settlement before resorting to litigation. While the possibility of a court hearing always exists, it is the last resort, not the first step. The role of a barrister is to strategically guide you through this process, maximising your chances of a successful resolution at the earliest possible stage.

The Civil Justice System’s Focus on Resolution

The courts in England and Wales are not a battleground for every disagreement. The Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), which govern the entire process of civil litigation, have an “overriding objective” to deal with cases justly and at a proportionate cost. This objective fundamentally prioritises settlement over trial.

The Purpose of Pre-Action Protocols

  • Before a single document is filed with the court, parties are expected to engage in a process known as a pre-action protocol. These are sets of guidelines for specific types of claims—such as those related to personal injury, clinical negligence, or property disputes—that set out the steps parties should take to resolve the dispute without issuing a claim.
  • What is the purpose of a pre-action protocol? The purpose is to encourage the parties to exchange information, understand each other’s positions, and attempt to settle the issues before commencing proceedings. Failure to comply with the relevant protocol can result in penalties from the court, including being ordered to pay the other side’s legal costs, even if you ultimately win your case. This shows how seriously the judiciary takes the avoidance of unnecessary litigation.
  • For instance, in a landlord and tenant dispute over rent arrears, the relevant protocol requires the landlord to send a detailed letter of claim to the tenant, providing all the necessary information and a clear deadline for a response. The tenant, or their legal representative, must then respond, either accepting or denying the claim and explaining their position. This exchange of correspondence and information often leads to a resolution, such as a payment plan, before either party even considers court action.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Your Pathway to a Settlement

Even if a pre-action protocol does not result in a settlement, the courts still expect parties to consider alternative dispute resolution (ADR). ADR refers to a range of methods for resolving disputes outside of the courtroom. The courts actively encourage these methods and may penalise parties who unreasonably refuse to engage in them.

The Benefits of Mediation and Arbitration

  • Mediation is one of the most common forms of ADR. In this process, a neutral third party, the mediator, helps the parties to negotiate a settlement. The mediator does not make a decision but facilitates communication and helps both sides explore potential solutions. Mediation is confidential and can be a highly effective way to resolve even the most contentious disputes, such as those related to will and probate. A well-known example is the Ilott v Mitson case, although this went to the Supreme Court, the judges in that case and in many others have stressed the need for parties to find a way to settle their differences amicably through mediation rather than through costly litigation.
  • Will I have to pay my lawyer if we settle out of court? Yes, you will still have to pay for the legal services provided to you, but the total costs are almost always significantly lower than a full-blown trial. The time and resources required to prepare for and attend a trial, including drafting witness statements, preparing evidentiary bundles, and cross-examining witnesses, are vast. By settling through ADR, you can avoid these costs and achieve a resolution much faster.
  • Another form of ADR is arbitration, where the parties agree to have their dispute decided by a neutral third party (the arbitrator), whose decision is final and legally binding. This is often used in complex corporate and contract disputes as it can be quicker and more private than court proceedings.

The Barristers Inc. Approach: A Strategic Focus on Resolution

At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), our primary goal is to resolve your dispute as efficiently and effectively as possible, and that does not always mean going to court. Our expert barristers are specialist advocates, but they are also skilled negotiators and strategists who will work to secure a favourable outcome for you at the earliest stage.

How TBI Assists Clients

  • Our barristers’ role is to provide you with expert legal advice from the very beginning of your case. This includes advising you on the merits of your claim or defence, the risks involved, and the most effective legal strategy to achieve your objectives. We will draft all necessary pre-action correspondence, including letters of claim, to put your case in the strongest possible position.
  • We can also represent you in all forms of ADR, including mediation. Our experience in civil litigation gives us a unique advantage in these negotiations; we know the strengths and weaknesses of a case, and we can use that knowledge to put pressure on the other side to settle. We can help you navigate the strategic use of Part 36 offers, which are formal settlement offers that carry significant cost consequences if rejected, and can be a powerful tool to force a resolution.
  • For example, in a property and boundary dispute, a TBI barrister would first advise on the legal position and the relevant covenants or easements. They would then draft a detailed pre-action letter, setting out the legal arguments and proposing a resolution. If the other party refuses to engage, the barrister would advise on the possibility of a mediation, using their negotiation skills to achieve a resolution that avoids a costly and time-consuming court hearing.

When a Court Appearance Becomes Necessary

  • While the vast majority of cases settle, some disputes are simply not resolvable through negotiation or ADR. This is when a barrister’s right of audience and courtroom expertise become essential.
  • Will my case definitely go to trial? Even if your case is formally issued in court, it is still highly likely to settle before a full trial. The court process itself provides numerous opportunities for settlement, including further negotiations, court-led mediations, and offers of settlement.
  • When a case does proceed to trial, the barrister’s role is to present your case to the judge. This involves delivering an opening speech, examining your witnesses and cross-examining the other side’s witnesses, and making a closing legal argument. A barrister is trained for this, and their courtroom skills are a significant advantage. The barristers at TBI are not only experts in the legal principles of civil litigation, but also in the art of advocacy, ensuring your case is presented with precision and clarity.

Your Strategic Partner in Dispute Resolution

  • The prospect of going to court can be daunting, but it is important to remember that it is not an inevitability. The modern legal system in England and Wales is structured to facilitate settlement at every turn. Engaging a specialist barrister from the start is the best way to ensure that your legal dispute is handled effectively and efficiently.
  • At The Barristers Inc., we are committed to helping you find the right solution for your legal challenge. Our barristers are equipped with the legal knowledge and strategic acumen to pursue a settlement wherever possible, saving you time, money, and stress. However, if a court appearance becomes unavoidable, you can be confident that our barristers will provide you with the robust and expert advocacy you need to succeed. Do not hesitate to contact us to discuss your case and find out how we can assist you in finding a path to a swift and favourable resolution.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Can I Appeal a Court Decision?
A court decision is not necessarily the final word on a legal dispute. While the initial judgment provides a resolution, parties who feel the court made a mistake have a...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Refuse Pets in My Property?
The question of whether a landlord can refuse pets in their property has become one of the most significant and rapidly evolving areas of landlord and tenant law in England...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Evict a Tenant Without a Court Order?
In England & Wales, the law on evicting a tenant is both clear and strict: you cannot evict a tenant without a court order. This fundamental principle is enshrined in...Read More
Toggle Icon
Do I Need a Barrister for a Landlord and Tenant Dispute?
A landlord and tenant dispute can range from a simple disagreement over a security deposit to a complex legal battle over eviction or property disrepair. While the law in England...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Do I Instruct a Barrister?
A barrister is a specialist legal professional who provides expert advice and advocacy in court. Unlike solicitors, who traditionally handle the day-to-day management of a legal case, a barrister's expertise...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link