FAQ
Home / FAQs / Will & Probate / What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will?

What Are the Grounds for Contesting a Will?

Contesting a will is a legal challenge to its validity in England and Wales. It’s not about simply disagreeing with the contents, but rather proving that the will is legally flawed on one of a number of specific grounds. The person challenging the will, known as the claimant, carries the burden of proof and must present compelling evidence to the court. The grounds for contesting a will include a lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, and a failure of due execution.

Understanding the Legal Concept of Contesting a Will

The legal process for challenging a will is complex and requires a strong evidential basis. The law presumes that a will is valid if it appears to have been properly signed and witnessed. This initial presumption means the person challenging the will has a significant hurdle to overcome. The evidence must be compelling and, in some cases, must demonstrate a high degree of probability that the will does not reflect the final wishes of the person who made it, known as the testator. The first step in a will dispute is often to issue a caveat with the Probate Registry, which prevents the executor from obtaining probate and distributing the estate while investigations are carried out.

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

This is one of the most common grounds for challenging a will. It concerns the mental state of the testator at the time the will was made. The law requires a person to have sufficient mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of their actions.

The Test in Banks v Goodfellow

  • The legal test for testamentary capacity comes from the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow (1870). The testator must have:
  • Understood the nature of making a will and its effects.
  • Known the extent of their property of which they are disposing.
  • Been able to comprehend and appreciate the moral claims they ought to consider, such as those of family members.
  • Not been suffering from any disorder of the mind which may have influenced their will.
  • This ground is particularly relevant in cases involving elderly testators or those suffering from dementia, Alzheimer’s, or other mental health conditions. Medical evidence is often critical to proving this claim.

Undue Influence

This ground alleges that a person was coerced or pressured into making a will against their true wishes. The influence must be so strong that it overbears the free will of the testator. Proving this is notoriously difficult as it requires evidence of a high degree of coercion. The law distinguishes between mere persuasion or family pressure, which is acceptable, and influence that amounts to coercion, which is not.

Proving Undue Influence

Proving undue influence often relies on a compelling body of circumstantial evidence that suggests the only reasonable explanation for the will’s terms is coercion. The evidence might include the testator being isolated from family and friends or a sudden and unexplained change in the will’s terms that heavily benefits the person exerting the influence.

Q&A: How do I prove a person was coerced into changing their will?

You must prove that the testator’s free will was completely overcome by another person’s actions. It’s not enough to show that the testator was influenced; you must show that they were coerced. This requires a high standard of evidence that the testator acted against their free will. Since it’s often hard to get direct evidence, building a strong case relies on a combination of witness statements, financial records, and other circumstantial evidence that creates an undeniable picture of coercion.

Lack of Due Execution

This ground is a technical challenge to the will’s validity, arguing that it was not signed and witnessed correctly as required by the Wills Act 1837. The formal requirements for a valid will are strict.

Formal Requirements for a Valid Will

According to the Wills Act 1837, a will must be:

  • In writing.
  • Signed by the testator, or by another person in their presence and under their direction.
  • Signed in the presence of two or more witnesses present at the same time.
  • Each witness must also sign in the presence of the testator, but not necessarily in the presence of the other witness.
  • If any of these formal requirements are not met, the will can be deemed invalid. This can be a straightforward technical challenge, for example, if one of the witnesses was also a beneficiary, which would make the gift to them void.

Fraudulent Calumny or Forgery

These grounds involve active dishonesty or deception.

Fraudulent Calumny

Fraudulent calumny occurs when a person poisons the mind of the testator against a potential beneficiary by making false statements about them. The statements must be made with the intention of influencing the testator to disinherit the individual. It is a subtle form of undue influence where the testator’s mind is manipulated by malicious falsehoods.

Forgery

If the will itself is a forgery, it is an outright criminal act and renders the will invalid. Evidence of forgery would likely involve a forensic analysis of the handwriting and signatures on the will.

Lack of Knowledge and Approval

This ground asserts that the testator did not know about or approve of the contents of their will. While they may have had the mental capacity to make the will, they may not have been fully aware of its specific provisions. This often arises where a will is complex or where a vulnerable testator was not fully aware of what they were signing.

Claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975

This is a different type of claim that does not challenge the validity of the will itself but instead argues that the will (or the rules of intestacy) do not make reasonable financial provision for the claimant.

Who Can Make a Claim?

Eligible claimants include the deceased’s spouse, a former spouse who has not remarried, a child of the deceased, or any person who was financially dependent on the deceased. The court has a wide discretion to make orders to ensure that reasonable financial provision is made.

Q&A: What if the will seems unfair but there’s no obvious legal ground to contest it?

If the will is legally valid but seems unfair, you may still be able to make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. This is a separate legal process where you argue that the will did not make reasonable financial provision for you as a dependant. It is not about challenging the will’s validity but about seeking a fairer share of the estate.

How Our Firm Can Assist in Will Disputes

Dealing with a will dispute is a complex and highly technical process. The legal burden of proof is significant, and mistakes in gathering evidence can be costly. At TBI – The Barristers Inc., our expert barristers and solicitors have extensive experience in will and probate litigation. We can assist by:

  • Assessing the Merits of Your Claim: We provide confidential consultations to assess the specific grounds for your challenge and advise on the likelihood of success.
  • Structured Evidence Gathering: We guide you through the process of obtaining all necessary documents, including medical records and witness statements, to build a robust legal case.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: We are skilled in dispute resolution and can represent you in negotiations or mediation to seek an amicable settlement, avoiding costly and time-consuming court proceedings.
  • Litigation and Court Representation: If litigation is necessary, our barristers will provide expert representation, presenting your evidence and legal arguments with the highest degree of professionalism.
  • Our firm’s expertise also extends to civil litigation, dispute resolution, corporate and contract, and property and boundary disputes, ensuring we can provide a comprehensive and strategic approach to all aspects of your case.

Latest FAQs

Search Icon
Toggle Icon
Can a Will be Rectified If it Contains a Mistake?  
Yes, a will can be rectified if it contains a mistake, but only under very specific and limited circumstances. Rectification of a will is the process by which the High...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Represent Myself in a Will Dispute?
A will dispute can be an emotionally charged and legally complex matter. It’s understandable to consider representing yourself to save on legal fees, particularly when the value of the estate...Read More
Toggle Icon
Can I Settle a Will Dispute Out of Court?
A dispute over a will can be one of the most emotionally charged and legally complex situations a family can face. The grief of losing a loved one, coupled with...Read More
Toggle Icon
How do I Find a Good will Dispute Barrister in London?
A will dispute can be a deeply personal and emotionally taxing ordeal. Unlike other legal matters, it often involves family members, and the outcome can have a profound impact on...Read More
Toggle Icon
How Long Does a Will Dispute Case Take?
The duration of a will dispute case in England and Wales is not a fixed period. It is a highly variable process, influenced by a multitude of factors, from the...Read More

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link