Challenging a will is a complex legal process that requires a strong evidential basis. In England and Wales, a person who wishes to contest a will carries the burden of proof, meaning they must provide sufficient evidence to convince the court that the will is invalid. The type of evidence required depends on the specific legal ground for the challenge, such as a lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, or a failure of due execution. Simply believing a will is unfair is not enough; the claim must be rooted in specific legal principles.
The law presumes a will is valid if it appears to have been properly signed and witnessed. This initial presumption means the person challenging the will has a significant hurdle to overcome. The evidence must be compelling and, in some cases, must demonstrate a high degree of probability that the will is not a true reflection of the testator’s wishes.
The court will not set aside a will lightly. The evidence presented must be inconsistent with the will’s validity. This often requires gathering a wide range of documents and witness statements, which can be a lengthy process. The first step is to issue a caveat with the Probate Registry, which prevents the executor from obtaining probate and distributing the estate while investigations are carried out.
This ground for a will dispute hinges on the testator’s mental state at the time the will was made. It requires evidence that they did not have the mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of their actions.
This is the most crucial type of evidence for this claim. It can include:
Notes from the deceased’s GP, hospital records, and reports from specialists, such as psychiatrists or neurologists, are essential. These documents can show a diagnosis of conditions like dementia, Alzheimer’s, or other cognitive impairments that may have affected the testator’s mind.
A legal team will often instruct an independent medical expert to provide an opinion on the deceased’s capacity at the time the will was signed, based on their medical records and other evidence.
Statements from individuals who were in close contact with the deceased are also vital. These witnesses can include family members, carers, friends, or the solicitor who drafted the will. They can provide personal testimony on the deceased’s behaviour, memory, and general mental state around the time the will was made.
This is one of the most difficult claims to prove because it alleges that a person coerced the testator into making or changing their will. Such pressure often occurs behind closed doors, making direct evidence scarce.
Proving undue influence often relies on a compelling body of circumstantial evidence that suggests the only reasonable explanation for the will’s terms is coercion.
Evidence that the will contains provisions that are dramatically different from the testator’s previous stated intentions or from a previous will.
Documentation or testimony showing that the beneficiary allegedly exerting influence isolated the testator from family and friends.
Bank statements or other financial documents that show a sudden transfer of assets or a pattern of financial dependency on the influencer.
You need to prove that the testator’s will was overborne by the actions of another person. It’s not enough to show that the testator was influenced; you must show that they were coerced. This requires a high standard of evidence that the testator acted against their free will. As it’s hard to get direct evidence, building a strong case often relies on a combination of witness statements, financial records, and other circumstantial evidence that creates an undeniable picture of coercion.
This ground is a technical challenge to the will’s validity, arguing that it was not signed and witnessed correctly as required by the Wills Act 1837.
The primary piece of evidence is the will document itself. A close examination can reveal:
Are all the required signatures present? Does the testator’s signature appear genuine?
Were the witnesses’ signatures present, and were they present at the same time as the testator when the will was signed?
Statements from the witnesses who were present at the signing are critical. Their testimony can confirm or deny whether the formal legal requirements were met. The solicitor’s file, if one was involved, can also provide valuable information and a professional record of the will’s execution.
Navigating a will dispute is a complex and highly technical process. The legal burden of proof is significant, and mistakes in gathering evidence can be costly. At TBI – The Barristers Inc., our expert barristers and solicitors have extensive experience in will and probate litigation. We can assist with: