When a loved one passes away, finding that their will seems to contradict their true intentions can be both emotionally taxing and legally bewildering. Concerns often arise when the deceased had a medical condition like dementia. In England and Wales, a will’s validity can be directly impacted by the mental state of the person who made it. This guide will walk you through the legal standard for “testamentary capacity,” the significance of medical conditions, and the steps you can take to challenge a will, providing clarity and empowering you to act.
Testamentary capacity is a legal term for the mental ability required to make a valid will. It’s a specific legal test, not a medical one, meaning a diagnosis of dementia or another condition doesn’t automatically invalidate a will.
The legal test for capacity is based on the 1870 case of Banks v Goodfellow, which remains the cornerstone of this area of law. For a will to be valid, the person making it (the “testator”) must satisfy four key requirements:
While Banks v Goodfellow is the historical standard, the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) provides a modern statutory framework. In 2025, the relationship between these two is critical for anyone dealing with wills on all mental capacity matters.
| Feature | Banks v Goodfellow (Common Law) | Mental Capacity Act 2005 (Statutory) |
| Primary Use | Retrospective (deciding if a will was valid after death). | Prospective (deciding if someone can make a decision now). |
| Core Focus | Understanding assets and moral claims. | Ability to understand, retain, and weigh information. |
| Current Status | Remains the “Gold Standard” for will validity. | Used by the Court of Protection and as a “cross-check” by judges. |
The “Golden Rule” is a professional guideline for solicitors, especially when dealing with an elderly or seriously ill client. It advises that in situations where there’s any doubt about a person’s capacity, a medical professional should be present to witness the signing of the will and confirm the testator’s mental state. While not a legal requirement, following this rule provides a strong safeguard against future legal challenges.
The High Court case of Leonard v Leonard [2024] reaffirmed that while the Golden Rule is not a strict law, failure to follow it can lead the court to treat a will with significant suspicion, especially if the will-drafter’s notes are inadequate. Furthermore, the Wills Bill 2025 is currently moving toward aligning the Banks v Goodfellow test more closely with the MCA 2005 to reduce confusion.
A diagnosis of a medical condition like dementia is not in itself sufficient to invalidate a will. The focus is on the individual’s mental state at the time the will was made, and a person may have had a “lucid interval”, a period of mental clarity even with a progressive condition.
Dementia, Alzheimer’s, or other conditions that affect cognitive function can certainly raise concerns about a person’s capacity. However, a will can be valid if it can be shown that the testator had sufficient understanding at the moment it was signed. Proving this often requires a detailed review of medical records and a legal understanding of how these conditions manifest.
The law operates on a presumption of capacity, meaning a will is presumed to be valid unless proven otherwise.
Challenging a will is a serious legal process that must be handled with precision. The process begins with an investigation and can lead to formal legal action.
If you have concerns about a will, your first step is to place a caveat with the Probate Registry. This is a legal notice that prevents the grant of probate from being issued, putting a hold on the estate’s administration. During this time, you should gather all relevant evidence:
If your investigation suggests a strong case, you may proceed with formal legal action. This can involve sending a Letter of Claim to the executors, but you should also consider:
Will disputes are highly specialised and complex areas of civil litigation. Given the legal and evidentiary requirements, seeking expert legal counsel is not only wise but often essential for a successful outcome.
The legal test for testamentary capacity is nuanced, and the burden of proof is high. An expert barrister understands the relevant case law and can provide a strategic assessment of your case. They can help you identify the strongest legal arguments, navigate court procedures, and ensure that your evidence is presented in the most persuasive way possible.
TBI’s barristers provide invaluable services in a will dispute:
At TBI (The Barristers Inc), we understand the emotional and legal challenges that come with a will dispute. Our barristers provide clear, practical advice and a supportive approach. We have a wealth of experience in contentious probate and are committed to helping you achieve a just and fair outcome.
Our barristers have a deep understanding of the legal principles surrounding testamentary capacity. We are well-versed in the strategies required to successfully challenge a will, and our specialisation in this field allows us to offer you a level of insight and expertise that is second to none.
We take a client-focused approach, providing clear, strategic advice that is tailored to your specific situation. We are committed to making the legal process as transparent as possible, empowering you to make informed decisions at every stage.
If you are concerned about a will’s validity due to a lack of mental capacity, do not hesitate to seek professional legal advice. Contact TBI today for a confidential consultation. Our expert barristers are here to help you understand your options and provide the robust representation you need for wills on all mental capacity matters.
In the jurisdiction of England and Wales, legal testamentary capacity is the specific mental standard required for an individual to execute a valid and enforceable will. It is a unique legal concept that does not necessarily mirror a medical diagnosis; rather, it focuses on the testator’s cognitive ability to perform the specific task of disposing of their assets after death. If a person lacks this capacity at the material time of signing, the will is void ab initio, meaning it is treated as if it never existed, often leading to complex litigation between intended and legal heirs.
Despite being established over 150 years ago, the common law test in Banks v Goodfellow remains the primary authority for assessing testamentary capacity in England and Wales. Recent High Court rulings, such as Clitheroe v Bond [2021] and Leonard v Leonard [2024], have reaffirmed that this test has stood the test of time and was not superseded by modern legislation.
To be deemed Compos Mentis (of sound mind) for the purposes of making a will, a testator must satisfy four specific criteria:
While the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA 2005) provides a statutory framework for decisions made by living persons, the courts have clarified that the Banks v Goodfellow test is the “correct and only test” for retrospective assessments after a testator has died. However, the MCA 2005 serves as a useful cross-check for practitioners when assessing a living client’s ability to retain and weigh information.
Navigating capacity issues requires an understanding of the procedural protections designed to ensure a testator’s Animus Testandi (testamentary intention) is genuine.
In England and Wales, solicitors follow the Golden Rule. This is a best-practice guideline suggesting that if a testator is elderly or ill, the will should be approved by a medical practitioner who confirms capacity in writing.
If a will is later contested, a Larke v Nugent request is often issued. This is a formal demand for the drafting solicitor’s file notes and a statement regarding the circumstances of the will’s execution. These notes are critical evidence in determining whether the solicitor correctly identified any signs that the testator was Non Compos Mentis.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is a leading firm of expert barristers providing elite legal services across England and Wales. We specialise in protecting the legacies of our clients through rigorous advocacy and multidisciplinary expertise.
Our Civil Litigation team consists of specialist barristers who represent clients in high-stakes contentious probate. Whether you are seeking to prove a will as the Propounder or challenging its validity, TBI provides masterful representation in the High Court. We excel at analysing complex medical records and expert reports to determine if the Banks v Goodfellow criteria were truly met.
TBI provides a unique advantage by integrating Family Law and Criminal Litigation into our probate services. Our family law experts handle claims for “Reasonable Financial Provision” under the Inheritance Act 1975, while our criminal team investigates cases where a lack of capacity was exploited through fraud or elder abuse. This 360-degree approach ensures that our clients’ rights are protected regardless of the legal angle.
All services provided by TBI are in strict compliance with the Bar Standards Board (BSB) and the statutory frameworks of the UK. We offer direct access to barristers who provide clear, jargon-free guidance while maintaining the intellectual rigor required for complex litigation. By choosing TBI, you are choosing a partner dedicated to upholding the rule of law and the true intentions of the deceased.
Would you like TBI to review a Larke v Nugent response or provide a formal Counsel’s Opinion on a potential capacity challenge?
In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a diagnosis of dementia is not an automatic disqualification for making a will. Testamentary capacity is defined as the legal and mental ability of a person to execute a valid will. It is a task-specific legal standard rather than a purely medical one. This means that an individual may be medically diagnosed with a cognitive impairment but still possess the necessary clarity to understand the implications of their final wishes. A will created by someone with dementia is legally valid provided they meet the specific criteria established by common law at the moment the document is signed.
The determination of capacity is a nuanced process that balances the protection of vulnerable individuals with the fundamental principle of testamentary freedom. Under the laws of England and Wales, the courts look for specific cognitive markers rather than a general clean bill of health.
The primary test for capacity remains the common law standard set in Banks v Goodfellow. To create a valid will, the testator must:
Dementia is often fluctuating. In England and Wales, the law recognises the Lucid Interval—a period where a person who is otherwise Non Compos Mentis (not of sound mind) regains sufficient clarity to meet the legal test. If a will is executed during such a window of clarity, it is perfectly valid. Establishing this requires careful documentation to prove that the testator possessed the requisite Animus Testandi (testamentary intention) at the material time.
Because wills made by testators with dementia are highly susceptible to being contested, the legal profession utilises specific safeguards to protect the validity of the document.
The Golden Rule is a best-practice guideline for solicitors in England and Wales. It dictates that for elderly or ill clients, a medical practitioner should be involved to witness the will or provide a contemporaneous capacity report. If a will is challenged after death, the court will often demand a Larke v Nugent response. This is a formal statement from the drafting solicitor detailing their observations and the steps they took to ensure the testator was Compos Mentis, which serves as vital evidence in Contentious Probate.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is a specialised firm where our expert barristers provide elite advocacy and strategic counsel. We ensure that all legal actions taken are in strict compliance with the laws of England and Wales and the Bar Standards Board (BSB).
TBI excels in Civil Litigation, representing clients who wish to defend a will’s validity or those who believe a will was made without capacity. Our barristers are experts at cross-examining medical professionals and interpreting retrospective capacity assessments to ensure the court understands the reality of the testator’s mental state during execution.
Our firm uniquely bridges the gap between different legal sectors. In Family Law, we address how capacity issues affect the provision for dependents. In Criminal Litigation, we investigate cases where dementia has been exploited through fraud, coercion, or undue influence. This holistic approach ensures that our clients are protected from predatory behavior while their financial legacy is secured.
TBI provides a bespoke service for reviewing medical and legal evidence. By analysing GP records and solicitor attendance notes through a barrister’s lens, we provide an authoritative opinion on the strength of a will. This prevents unnecessary litigation and provides a clear roadmap for families navigating the complexities of estate management under UK law.
In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, the Banks v Goodfellow (1870) test is the seminal common law authority used to determine whether a person has the mental capacity to make a valid will. Unlike general mental capacity, which may be governed by modern statutes for living decisions, testamentary capacity is a specific legal standard. It ensures that a testator’s final wishes are born of a sound and disposing mind, protecting the estate from the effects of cognitive decline or mental illness. If this test is not satisfied at the material time of the will’s execution, the document may be declared void, potentially leading to a prior will being reinstated or the estate being distributed under the rules of intestacy.
The test established in 1870 remains the bedrock of probate law because of its functional approach. It does not look for a medical label but instead assesses whether the testator can perform four specific mental functions.
The testator must comprehend that they are engaged in the act of making a will. This involves understanding that the document they are signing will take effect only upon their death and will dictate the distribution of their assets. They must grasp the gravity and the legal consequences of this specific act.
A testator is not required to know the value of their estate to the nearest penny. However, they must have a sufficient understanding of the general extent of the property and assets they are disposing of. This ensures they are aware of the “bounty” they are distributing.
The individual must be able to comprehend and weigh the claims of people who might reasonably expect to inherit from them. This includes family members and dependents. Even if they choose to exclude someone, they must be capable of recognising the “moral claim” that person has and making a rational decision to bypass it.
The final limb requires that the testator’s mind is not clouded by a “disorder of the mind” or an “insane delusion.” A delusion, in this legal sense, is a fixed, false belief that cannot be corrected by reason. If such a delusion “poisons the affections” of the testator or perverts their sense of right, causing them to make a will they otherwise would not have made, the will lacks capacity.
While the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA 2005) is the statutory test for capacity in other legal areas, the High Court has repeatedly affirmed in cases like Walker v Badmin [2015] and Clitheroe v Bond [2021] that Banks v Goodfellow remains the sole test for retrospective probate disputes.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is a firm where elite barristers provide strategic advocacy and specialist counsel to ensure your legacy or your rightful inheritance is protected under the highest standards of UK law.
TBI’s Civil Litigation specialists are experts in the Chancery Division. We represent clients in high-stakes disputes where the Banks v Goodfellow test is at the heart of the claim. Our barristers are masters at cross-examining medical experts and analysing Larke v Nugent statements to prove or disprove capacity in the High Court.
Capacity disputes rarely exist in a vacuum. TBI integrates Family Law to manage claims for dependants under the Inheritance Act 1975 and Criminal Litigation to investigate “Undue Influence” or fraud. This 360-degree approach ensures that if a testator was Non Compos Mentis (not of sound mind), every legal avenue is explored to rectify the injustice.
Operating under the Bar Standards Board (BSB), TBI provides a level of specialised expertise that goes beyond standard legal services. We offer direct access to barristers who can provide a formal Counsel’s Opinion on the validity of a will, helping you navigate the “Golden Rule” of probate with confidence and technical precision.
In the jurisdiction of England and Wales, the Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA 2005) is a statutory framework designed to protect and empower individuals who may lack the mental capacity to make specific decisions for themselves. While the Act covers a broad spectrum of health and welfare decisions, its application in the realm of will disputes is nuanced.
Specifically, the MCA 2005 governs capacity assessments for individuals who are still alive, whereas the common law test in Banks v Goodfellow remains the primary authority for retrospective challenges after a person has passed away. Understanding the interplay between this statute and traditional probate law is essential for navigating modern estate litigation.
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 introduced a set of principles that shifted the legal landscape from a status-based assessment to a functional-based assessment. This means that capacity is no longer determined by a diagnosis, but by a person’s ability to make a specific decision at a specific time.
Section 1 of the Act establishes that every individual must be presumed to have capacity unless it is established otherwise. This impacts will disputes by placing a heavy burden on those who wish to prove that a living person is incapable of managing their affairs. The Act outlines a two-stage functional test:
When an individual lacks the capacity to execute a will themselves, the MCA 2005 empowers the Court of Protection to authorise a Statutory Will. This is a crucial procedural tool where the court, acting on behalf of P (the patient), approves a testamentary document that is deemed to be in P’s best interests. This prevents the estate from falling into intestacy or following an outdated will that no longer reflects P’s likely wishes.
A significant point of legal debate in England and Wales is whether the MCA 2005 has replaced the 1870 common law test. The High Court has clarified that the two tests coexist but serve different purposes.
For probate disputes involving a deceased testator, the Chancery Division still prioritises the Banks v Goodfellow test. Judges have noted that the MCA 2005 was intended to protect the living, while probate law must balance the dead’s testamentary freedom. However, practitioners often use the MCA 2005 as a persuasive framework to interpret a testator’s cognitive state, especially if a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) was in place.
When a will is challenged, the evidence often includes records from when the testator was under the protection of the MCA 2005.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is a leading firm of expert barristers who specialise in the intersection of statutory and common law within England and Wales. We provide high-level advocacy for clients facing the complexities of capacity-related disputes.
TBI barristers are experts in representing families and professional deputies in the Court of Protection. We handle the technicalities of applying for Statutory Wills, ensuring that the best interests of P are protected while adhering to the rigorous evidentiary standards required by the court.
Our Civil Litigation team excels in the Chancery Division, where we represent clients in contentious probate trials. We understand how to use MCA 2005 assessments to bolster or challenge a Banks v Goodfellow claim. Our barristers are trained to navigate the Onus Probandi (burden of proof) to ensure that the testator’s true intentions are upheld.
TBI offers a unique shield by combining expertise in Family Law and Criminal Litigation. We investigate whether an LPA was used to commit financial abuse (Criminal) or if a lack of capacity has unfairly disadvantaged a spouse or child (Family). This holistic approach, conducted in strict compliance with the Bar Standards Board (BSB), ensures our clients receive total legal protection.
In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, the Golden Rule is a venerable judicial guideline established to minimise the risk of disputes regarding a testator’s mental capacity. It is not a statutory law enshrined in an Act of Parliament, but rather a best-practice standard set by the courts in landmark cases such as Kenward v Adams (1975) and Re Simpson (1977). The rule dictates that when a solicitor prepares a will for a testator who is elderly or significantly ill, they should ensure the making of the will is witnessed or approved by a medical practitioner who satisfies themselves of the testator’s capacity and records their findings in writing.
The application of the Golden Rule serves as a preemptive strike against future contentious probate. It focuses on ensuring that the testator is Compos Mentis at the time of execution, thereby protecting the Animus Testandi, or the genuine intention to make a will.
There are specific circumstances where a legal practitioner in England and Wales must consider this rule to avoid negligence and protect the client’s interests. The rule is not applied to every will, but is triggered by specific “red flags” including:
Failure to adhere to this guideline does not automatically invalidate a will, but it makes the document significantly harder to defend in the Chancery Division.
| Action Taken | Golden Rule Compliant | Non-Compliant Approach |
| Medical Assessment | Professional medical capacity report obtained. | Solicitor relies solely on their own lay observation. |
| Witnessing | Medical practitioner acts as a witness or consultant. | Witnesses are often staff members without medical training. |
| Documentation | Detailed file notes and medical evidence archived. | Minimal notes, increasing the risk of a Larke v Nugent request. |
| Outcome Risk | High protection against capacity challenges. | High vulnerability to expensive Civil Litigation. |
To understand why the Golden Rule is so pivotal, one must grasp the technicalities of probate disputes. When a will is challenged, the court looks for contemporaneous evidence. If a solicitor fails to follow the Golden Rule, it creates a vacuum of evidence that challengers can exploit.
If the Golden Rule is ignored, the executors may face a Larke v Nugent request. This is a formal inquiry where the drafting solicitor is asked to provide a full statement regarding the circumstances of the will’s execution. Without a medical report, the Propounder of the will (the person proving its validity) faces a much higher hurdle in demonstrating that the testator had the requisite Testamentary Capacity.
By involving a medical professional, the solicitor also helps insulate the will from claims of undue influence. In the legal framework of England and Wales, proving that a testator acted of their own free will is easier when a doctor can verify that the testator was not under a fog of illness or coercion, ensuring the document is the true expression of their wishes.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is a leading firm of expert barristers dedicated to the highest standards of legal practice in England and Wales. Our multidisciplinary expertise ensures that every aspect of a client’s estate is secured against legal pitfalls.
TBI excels in Civil Litigation, representing clients in complex probate disputes where the Golden Rule has been flouted. Our barristers provide elite advocacy in the High Court, whether we are defending an executor or acting for a beneficiary who believes a will was made without proper capacity. We bridge the gap between medical evidence and legal argument to achieve favorable outcomes.
Our firm uniquely integrates Family Law and Criminal Litigation into our estate services. TBI’s family law experts handle inheritance claims for dependants, while our criminal specialists investigate potential fraud or financial abuse in the lead-up to a will’s creation. This 360-degree approach ensures that our clients are protected from every angle, complying fully with the Bar Standards Board regulations.
At TBI, we believe in preventative law. We advise solicitors and private clients on how to structure their testamentary acts to be robust. By ensuring strict adherence to the latest judicial precedents in England and Wales, we provide our clients with peace of mind, knowing that their legacy is defended by the most capable barristers in the industry.
In the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, a caveat is a formal legal notice lodged with the Probate Registry that prevents a Grant of Probate or a Grant of Letters of Administration from being issued. It serves as a temporary “freeze” on the estate, ensuring that assets are not distributed until a dispute regarding the validity of the will—or the entitlement of the proposed administrator—is resolved.
Placing a caveat is the fundamental first step in contentious probate, allowing a challenger the necessary time to investigate suspicious circumstances or gather evidence of a lack of testamentary capacity.
The process of placing a caveat is governed by the Non-Contentious Probate Rules 1987. It is a powerful tool, but it must be used with precision to avoid potential cost sanctions from the court.
To initiate the challenge, the Caveator (the person challenging the will) must submit Form PA8A to the HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS). This application can be made online or by post.
Once an executor or a person seeking to prove the will (the Propounder) becomes aware of the caveat, they may choose to “warn” it.
While the caveat is in place, the Caveator should issue a Larke v Nugent request to the solicitor who prepared the will. This request compels the disclosure of the solicitor’s file and attendance notes, which are essential for determining if the testator was Compos Mentis (of sound mind) or if there was a lack of Knowledge and Approval regarding the will’s contents.
The Barristers Inc (TBI) is an elite firm of expert barristers who provide specialised advocacy in the Chancery Division of the High Court. We assist clients in navigating the high-stakes environment of contentious probate with technical excellence.
TBI barristers are masters of the procedural “chess match” that occurs at the Probate Registry. We provide strategic advice on whether to enter an Appearance or whether it is safer to withdraw the caveat to avoid adverse cost sanctions. Our advocacy ensures that your legal standing is protected from the moment a Warning is issued, providing a robust defense against aggressive executors.
At TBI, we recognise that will disputes often involve complex family dynamics or criminal activity. Our Family Law team addresses the needs of dependants who may require reasonable financial provision under the Inheritance Act 1975. Simultaneously, our Criminal Litigation team investigates if a caveat was necessitated by fraud, elder abuse, or undue influence. This holistic approach ensures that your interests are protected across the entire legal spectrum of England and Wales.
Every instruction at TBI is handled in strict compliance with the Bar Standards Board (BSB). We provide a forensic review of the evidence gathered through Larke v Nugent requests and medical disclosures. By providing a clear Counsel’s Opinion, we help clients understand the merits of their challenge, ensuring that every step taken is legally sound and strategically optimised to secure the rightful distribution of the estate.