Home / News / Corporate & Contract / How to Challenge an Unfair Restrictive Covenant in Your Contract 

How to Challenge an Unfair Restrictive Covenant in Your Contract 

09 Sep, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Restrictive covenants are clauses often found in contracts that aim to limit an individual’s or a business’s freedom to act, especially after the contract ends. They can feel unfair and have a significant impact on your career or business prospects. However, UK law provides a clear framework for challenging these clauses, which are not always enforceable. This guide outlines the legal process and explains how The Barristers Inc. (TBI) can provide expert legal assistance to help you determine if a covenant is unfair and, if so, how to challenge it effectively.

What is a Restrictive Covenant?

A restrictive covenant is a contractual term that prohibits or restricts a person from doing something. In the commercial world, they are most seen in employment contracts, partnership agreements, and contracts for the sale of a business. Their purpose is to protect the legitimate interests of the employer or business owner. For example, a restrictive covenant might prevent a departing employee from working for a competitor, or an individual selling their business from immediately setting up a rival company.

Common Types of Covenants

Restrictive covenants can take several forms, all designed to protect a business’s interests. The most common types include:

  • Non-compete clauses: These prevent an individual from working for a competing business or setting up a competing business of their own for a specified period within a defined geographical area.
  • Non-solicitation clauses: These prohibit an individual from approaching or soliciting clients, customers, or suppliers of their former employer or business after the contract ends.
  • Non-dealing clauses: A more restrictive form of a non-solicitation clause, these prevent an individual from having any dealings with former clients, even if the client makes the first contact.
  • Non-poaching clauses: These prevent an individual from attempting to recruit former colleagues to their new business.

The starting point in UK law is that any restrictive covenant is presumptively void as a “restraint of trade.” This is a fundamental principle of public policy. The law views these clauses as a hindrance to fair competition and an individual’s ability to earn a living. The burden of proof therefore lies entirely with the party seeking to enforce the covenant (e.g., the employer). They must demonstrate that the clause is both necessary to protect a legitimate business interest and that it is reasonable in its scope.

When is a Restrictive Covenant Unenforceable?

For a restrictive covenant to be legally enforceable in the UK, it must pass a rigorous two-part test. It must protect a legitimate business interest and be reasonable and proportionate in its application. If it fails either of these tests, a court will likely deem it unenforceable.

Legitimate Business Interest

A legitimate business interest is a specific, protectable asset that the covenant is designed to safeguard. The courts will not enforce a covenant that simply aims to prevent a former employee from competing. A legitimate interest must be a valuable asset, such as:

  • Trade secrets and confidential information (e.g., customer databases, pricing strategies, or unique business processes).
  • Customer and client connections (especially those with whom the employee had significant interaction).
  • Workforce stability (protecting a business from a key employee leaving and taking others with them). The party seeking to enforce the covenant must clearly identify and demonstrate a tangible interest that is in need of protection.

Reasonableness and Proportionality

Even if a legitimate business interest is identified, the covenant must be no wider than is reasonably necessary to protect that interest. A court will scrutinise the clause’s proportionality by considering a number of factors:

  • Geographical scope: Is the restricted area (e.g., a specific city, county, or country) wider than necessary to protect the legitimate interest? A restriction covering all of the UK, for instance, is unlikely to be reasonable if the business operates only in London.
  • Time period: Is the duration of the restriction (e.g., six months, one year, or two years) proportionate to the risk? Courts typically view longer periods with more scepticism.
  • Scope of restricted activity: Does the covenant prevent the individual from undertaking a wider range of activities than is required? A non-compete clause that prevents a person from taking any role in a competing company, when they only had a specific, limited role previously, may be deemed too broad. The court will consider the seniority of the employee and their access to confidential information when assessing this.

The Process for Challenging a Covenant

If you are faced with a restrictive covenant that you believe is unfair, there are a number of steps you can take to challenge it. The key is to act strategically and professionally from the outset.

Early Action and Communication

Your first and most important step should be to seek expert legal advice. A barrister can review your contract and provide a legal opinion on the enforceability of the covenant. A formal letter from a barrister or a firm like TBI, outlining the legal position and challenging the clause’s validity, can often be enough to prompt a resolution. This is often more effective than an individual’s personal communication and can avoid costly court proceedings.

Seeking a Declaration from the Court

If communication and negotiation fail, you may need to apply to the court for a declaration that the covenant is unenforceable. This formal process involves asking a judge to rule on the validity of the clause. In some cases, a court may not strike out the entire covenant but may instead “sever” the unfair parts. This “blue pencil” test allows a court to remove unreasonable wording while leaving the rest of the clause intact, provided that the remaining text still makes sense and does not change the overall meaning.

How The Barristers Inc. (TBI) Can Assist

At The Barristers Inc. (TBI), we provide expert, direct access legal services to individuals and businesses in England and Wales. Our barristers have extensive experience in contract law and civil litigation, offering a professional and authoritative approach to challenging unfair restrictive covenants. We are committed to protecting your rights and ensuring a fair outcome.

Our barristers can provide a detailed legal opinion on the enforceability of your restrictive covenant. We will review your contract, assess the specific circumstances of your case, and advise you on the likelihood of success if you were to challenge it. This professional assessment is a crucial first step in developing a robust legal strategy.

Dispute Resolution and Court Proceedings

Whether through negotiation, mediation, or formal court proceedings, TBI’s barristers will represent your interests with skill and professionalism. We are adept at resolving disputes out of court to save you time and money, but if litigation is necessary, we will provide robust court representation to argue for the invalidity of the covenant and secure your freedom to work.

Our Expertise in Contract Law

Our barristers at TBI specialise in all areas of civil litigation, with particular expertise in complex contract disputes. We have a proven track record of successfully challenging and resolving issues related to restrictive covenants. If you are concerned about a clause in your contract, contact The Barristers Inc. today for professional legal assistance that puts your interests first.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link