For many leaseholders, feeling disconnected from the management of their building can be a source of constant frustration. Issues with service charges, a lack of transparency, or poor maintenance can lead to a sense of powerlessness. Fortunately, in England and Wales, you have a powerful legal tool at your disposal: the Right to Manage (RTM).
This blog post will provide a clear breakdown of the entire RTM process, from the initial eligibility checks to the final transfer of responsibilities. We will simplify the legal complexities and provide you with a practical checklist to follow. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), we specialise in guiding leaseholders through this intricate process. Our expert barristers help you avoid common pitfalls and ensure that your claim is legally robust and ultimately successful. Our aim is to empower you to take back control of your home and protect your investment.
The Right to Manage is a legal right for leaseholders to take over the management of their building from the freeholder or landlord, without having to prove any fault on their part. It’s an important piece of legislation designed to give leaseholders greater control and influence over their living environment.
The Right to Manage was established by the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002. Its purpose is to give leaseholders the power to manage their own building’s affairs, including maintenance, repairs, and service charges. A key feature of the RTM is that it is a “no-fault” right, meaning you do not need to prove that the current landlord or managing agent has been negligent. You simply need to satisfy the legal eligibility criteria.
To successfully claim the RTM, both the building and the leaseholders must meet specific legal requirements. These criteria are strict and are the most common reason for a claim to fail if not checked correctly.
The building must be a self-contained block or have a self-contained part that can be managed independently. It must also contain at least two flats. A significant condition is that at least two-thirds of the flats in the building must be held by qualifying tenants (leaseholders with a long lease of over 21 years).
A sufficient number of qualifying leaseholders must participate in the RTM claim. The minimum number required is at least 50% of the total number of flats in the building. For example, if your building has 20 flats, at least 10 leaseholders must agree to participate in the RTM.
The RTM process follows a strict legal procedure with a series of steps that must be completed accurately and on time. Any deviation can be grounds for a landlord to challenge the claim.
The first legal requirement is to set up a special company to manage the claim. This is a private company, limited by guarantee, specifically for the purpose of exercising the RTM. All participating leaseholders must be members of this company. This entity acts as the legal vehicle for the RTM claim and, if successful, will be responsible for the building’s future management.
Once the RTM company is formed, the next step is to serve a formal Claim Notice on the landlord. This is a crucial document that must be served correctly to all relevant parties and must contain specific information, including:
After being served with the Claim Notice, the landlord has a set period to respond with a Counter-Notice. The landlord can either:
If the landlord does not dispute the claim or if their challenge is dismissed, the RTM company formally acquires the right. There will be a period of transition where the landlord provides relevant information and transfers funds. The RTM company then takes over all management responsibilities for the building, including arranging maintenance, collecting service charges, and managing budgets.
The RTM process is not always straightforward. Landlords may challenge the claim, and even among leaseholders, disagreements can occur. Anticipating these issues is key to a successful outcome.
Landlords will often challenge the RTM claim on technical grounds. The most common challenges relate to the eligibility criteria, such as a dispute over the number of qualifying tenants or whether the building meets the legal definition. If a landlord disputes the claim, the matter is referred to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber), which acts as a specialist court to resolve the dispute.
Disagreements can also arise between leaseholders, particularly concerning budgets, preferred contractors, or the level of service charges. This is why it’s essential for the RTM company to have a clear constitution and strong rules to govern its operations, as well as a defined process for making decisions democratically.
Disputes with the landlord or among leaseholders are best resolved through negotiation or mediation. However, if these fail, the First-tier Tribunal provides a formal legal process for resolving issues. TBI’s barristers are experts at representing clients in these tribunals, ensuring your case is presented clearly and persuasively.
While the RTM process is a valuable right, its legal and procedural requirements are highly technical. A single error can lead to a failed claim and wasted costs. Expert legal assistance is not just an advantage; it is often essential for success.
A barrister provides a level of specialised knowledge that is invaluable in RTM cases. They can ensure that all procedural steps are followed correctly, from the initial notice to dealing with a landlord’s counter-notice. Their expertise helps you avoid common mistakes, such as errors in the Claim Notice, which are often the grounds for a landlord’s challenge. This proactive approach saves you time and money in the long run.
At TBI, our barristers are experts in property law and contentious leasehold matters. We offer clear, strategic advice at every stage of the RTM process. We can help you: