Discovering you’ve been unfairly excluded from a loved one’s will can be a deeply painful and confusing experience. It’s a moment that raises not just financial concerns but also feelings of betrayal and injustice. You may wonder if the will can even be challenged, especially if it appears to be legally valid.
This guide is designed to provide you with a clear path forward. It will explain the legal framework that allows you to challenge a will for “reasonable financial provision,” even when it seems final. We will walk you through the process, from understanding who can make a claim to what a court will consider. At TBI (The Barristers Inc.), our barristers specialise in this complex area of law and are ready to provide the authoritative guidance you need to seek a just outcome.
An Inheritance Act claim is a legal action brought against a deceased person’s estate by an individual who believes the will (or the rules of intestacy, if there is no will) has not made a reasonable financial provision for them.
The legal foundation for these claims is the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. This Act was created to protect certain people who are left in financial hardship after a person’s death. It allows the court to override the provisions of a will and order that a portion of the estate be paid to the claimant, even if the will itself is entirely valid. The central question for the court is not whether the will is valid, but whether it makes a “reasonable financial provision.”
Only specific categories of people are legally permitted to make a claim under the Act. These categories include:
The core of an Inheritance Act claim rests on the concept of “reasonable financial provision.” This is a legal standard that the court must apply and a claimant must prove. The definition of what is “reasonable” differs depending on who is making the claim.
For a surviving spouse or civil partner, “reasonable provision” is not limited to what they need for maintenance. The court can consider a much broader range of factors, aiming to provide a fair settlement that reflects their contributions to the marriage, similar to what might be awarded in a divorce settlement. For all other claimants, “reasonable provision” is limited to what would be required for their maintenance. This means a claimant must prove a financial need that requires ongoing support.
When deciding a claim, the court will conduct a detailed “balancing exercise” by considering several factors, as outlined in Section 3 of the Act. The court will look at all the circumstances of the case, and no single factor is more important than another.
The court will scrutinise the financial needs and resources of the claimant, any other claimants, and all beneficiaries. This includes their current and foreseeable future income, assets, and liabilities. This is a key area of a claim.
The court will consider any obligations or responsibilities the deceased had towards the claimant or any beneficiary. This could include a moral obligation, such as a promise to leave a property to a child who had cared for the deceased in their later years.
The total size and nature of the estate will also be a major factor. A larger estate may be better able to provide for a claimant’s needs without causing hardship to other beneficiaries.
While the legal grounds may seem straightforward, the process of making a claim is governed by strict rules and deadlines.
This is the most critical aspect of an Inheritance Act claim. You have a strict six-month deadline to issue a claim from the date the Grant of Probate is issued. While a court has discretion to allow a claim to proceed after this deadline, it is not guaranteed. Missing this deadline significantly reduces your chances of success, so acting quickly is essential.
The vast majority of Inheritance Act claims are resolved without a full court trial. Mediation is a voluntary process where a neutral third party helps the disputing parties negotiate a settlement. It is an extremely effective way to reach a compromise, save significant legal costs, and avoid the stress and public nature of a court hearing.
If a settlement cannot be reached, the case will proceed to a court hearing. The judge will hear arguments from both sides and, based on the evidence presented, will make a final order. The court has the power to order a lump sum payment, periodic payments, or the transfer of a specific asset from the estate to the claimant.
Given the strict deadlines and complex legal standards, attempting to make an Inheritance Act claim without professional legal assistance is a significant risk.
A barrister is a specialist legal advocate who can provide you with direct, expert advice on your claim. They can assess the strength of your case, advise you on the factors a court will consider, and represent you in negotiations, mediation, or at a court hearing. Their strategic insight is invaluable for navigating these complex disputes.
At TBI, our barristers are experts in contentious probate and Inheritance Act claims. We provide clear advice to help you understand your rights and the best path forward. We can assist you with every step of the process, from assessing your claim’s viability to securing a settlement. Don’t let an unfair will leave you in financial hardship. Contact TBI today for a consultation to protect your interests and seek the provision you are entitled to.