The legal obligation for landlords in England to check a tenant’s right to rent is a serious matter. It’s not a mere formality; it’s a critical part of your legal responsibilities. Failure to conduct these checks correctly can result in significant legal penalties, including large fines and, in serious cases, a prison sentence. This post provides a clear, lawful framework for conducting these checks, outlining your obligations, the penalties for non-compliance, and a step-by-step guide to doing it right. At The Barristers Inc (TBI), we understand that these rules can be complex, and our expert barristers are on hand to provide the legal assistance you need to ensure full compliance and protect your investment.
The “Right to Rent” scheme places the responsibility for immigration checks squarely on landlords. It is a legal obligation that carries serious consequences for non-compliance.
The Immigration Act 2014 created the legal requirement for all landlords in England to check the immigration status of all adult tenants before a tenancy begins. The purpose of the scheme is to make it more difficult for illegal immigrants to rent private accommodation. The checks apply to all adults (aged 18 and over) who will be living at the property, regardless of whether they are named on the tenancy agreement. This is a crucial point; if an adult family member or a lodger moves in, they must also be checked.
Landlords who fail to conduct these checks correctly or who knowingly rent to a person who is not legally allowed to be in the UK face severe civil and criminal penalties. These penalties were significantly increased in February 2024 to deter illegal renting.
A landlord who fails to conduct a correct “Right to Rent” check can be issued a civil penalty. For a first offence, the fine can be up to £10,000 per tenant. For repeat offences within a specified period, the fine can be increased to up to £20,000 per tenant. These fines can be substantial, especially for landlords with multiple properties. For lodgers, the fines are up to £5,000 for a first offence and £10,000 for a repeat offence.
In serious cases, a landlord could face criminal penalties. The Immigration Act 2016 introduced a criminal offence for landlords who knowingly or have reasonable cause to believe they are renting to a person without the right to rent. A conviction for this offence can lead to a prison sentence of up to five years and an unlimited fine.
To avoid these serious penalties, you must follow a clear, lawful, and methodical process. A correct check provides you with a “statutory excuse,” which is a legal defence against a civil penalty.
A lawful “Right to Rent” check consists of three key steps:
The documents you can accept for verification depend on the tenant’s nationality. The Home Office provides clear guidance on which documents are acceptable.
British and Irish citizens have an unlimited right to rent. They can prove their status by providing one of the following:
For non-British and non-Irish citizens, the process is slightly different and requires you to use the Home Office’s online service. The prospective tenant must provide you with a “share code” and their date of birth. You can then use the Home Office’s online service to view their digital immigration status and confirm their right to rent. This service provides a clear yes/no answer and is the most secure way to verify a person’s right to rent. You must not accept share codes that begin with a ‘W’ or ‘S’, as these are for other purposes.
The timing of your check is crucial. The check must be conducted on all adult tenants before the tenancy begins. For tenants with a time-limited right to rent, such as a visa, you must also conduct a follow-up check either before their visa expires or within 28 days of their visa expiring. If the follow-up check shows they no longer have the right to rent, you must make a report to the Home Office.
Beyond the initial check, landlords have a legal duty to maintain proper records and to apply the checks consistently to all prospective tenants.
To maintain your statutory excuse, you must keep clear, dated copies of the documents you have checked. This can be a hard copy or a digital scan. You must keep these records for the duration of the tenancy and for at least one year after the tenancy ends. This ensures you have a clear record to show the Home Office in the event of an investigation.
You must conduct a “Right to Rent” check on all adult tenants, regardless of their perceived nationality or race. Failure to do so can lead to a claim of discrimination under the Equality Act 2010. A landlord who only checks tenants who they believe “look foreign” is discriminating and could face a civil claim for damages from a prospective tenant. The most effective way to avoid this is to apply a consistent, non-discriminatory process to every single adult tenant.
The “Right to Rent” scheme is a serious legal obligation. A landlord who ignores these rules or makes a simple mistake is at significant financial and legal risk.
At TBI, our barristers possess specialised knowledge in civil litigation and landlord-tenant law. We can provide direct advice on how to conduct these checks correctly and lawfully. We can help you create a robust vetting process that is fully compliant with all legal requirements and is non-discriminatory, giving you peace of mind that your business is protected.
If you are facing a civil or criminal penalty for non-compliance, TBI can provide legal representation and support. We can help you mount a legal defence, challenge a fine, and, in some cases, help you avoid a criminal conviction. Our expertise can help you handle the legal system and ensure your case is presented effectively, helping to mitigate the penalties you face.