As a shareholder, your investment in a company comes with a set of legal rights and expectations. When those expectations are breached, and you are unfairly harmed by the actions of a majority shareholder or director, you can bring a legal claim for unfair prejudice. This is a powerful, statutory legal remedy designed to protect shareholders, particularly those in a minority position, who are being harmed by the way a company is being run. This article will provide a clear legal framework to help you understand your rights and the steps you can take to win a shareholder dispute based on an unfair prejudice claim.
An unfair prejudice claim is a legal tool available to shareholders who believe they have been unfairly treated by a company’s affairs. This claim provides a way for a shareholder to seek redress without having to resort to the more drastic step of winding up the company.
The legal authority for an unfair prejudice claim is found in Section 994 of the Companies Act 2006. This section allows a shareholder to petition the court for an order on the grounds that the company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner that is “unfairly prejudicial” to the interests of the members (or a part of the members, including the petitioner).
A shareholder’s “interests” go beyond just a financial stake. In small, private companies, a shareholder may have a legitimate expectation to be involved in the company’s management, to receive dividends, or to be consulted on key decisions. A breach of these legitimate expectations can form the basis of an unfair prejudice claim, even if the action taken was not a breach of the company’s articles.
To succeed with an unfair prejudice claim, you must prove two distinct elements: that you have suffered prejudice and that the conduct was unfair. Both of these elements must be present to win the case.
Prejudice refers to the harm or detriment caused to a shareholder’s interests. This harm is often financial, but it doesn’t have to be. It can be a reduction in the value of your shares, a failure to pay dividends, or the improper use of company funds.
Prejudice must be a real, tangible detriment. This can include:
The harmful conduct must also be unfair. This is not a subjective test based on your personal feelings but an objective test based on the specific circumstances. A court will ask, “Would a reasonable bystander consider the conduct to be unjust?”
The court will look at the entire context of the company, including the company’s articles of association and any shareholder agreements. Even if a director’s actions are technically legal, they can still be deemed “unfair” if they violate a legitimate expectation or a fundamental understanding between the shareholders.
Unfairly prejudicial conduct can take many forms, from financial misconduct to being excluded from the company’s affairs. The following are common examples of actions that can form the basis of a claim.
This is one of the most common grounds for a claim. It includes actions that improperly benefit a majority shareholder or director at the expense of other shareholders, such as:
In many small, private companies, shareholders have a legitimate expectation to be involved in the company’s management and decision-making. If a shareholder is excluded from meetings, denied access to company information, or stripped of their role as a director, this can be considered unfairly prejudicial.
A failure to comply with the company’s Articles of Association or a Shareholders’ Agreement is a strong basis for a claim. These documents set out the rules of the company, and a breach of these rules is often a clear example of unfair conduct.
A majority shareholder can take actions to dilute a minority shareholder’s stake, such as issuing new shares to themselves. This can be considered unfairly prejudicial if it is done for an improper purpose, like reducing the minority shareholder’s influence. Similarly, intentionally withholding company information or accounts can also be seen as unfairly prejudicial, as it prevents a shareholder from protecting their investment.
Bringing a claim for unfair prejudice is a formal legal process that must be approached with expert guidance.
Before filing a petition with the court, a shareholder must first attempt to resolve the dispute through negotiation or mediation. This is a mandatory pre-action step that aims to resolve the matter without the time and cost of litigation. A formal letter of claim should be sent to the company and the relevant shareholders, outlining the claim and the desired remedy.
The most frequent and effective remedy granted by the court is a share buy-out order. The court will order the majority shareholder to purchase the claimant’s shares at a fair value, often determined by an independent valuation. This provides a “clean break” for the unfairly prejudiced shareholder and is often the desired outcome when relationships have broken down.
While a share buy-out is the most common remedy, the court has a wide discretion to make any order it sees fit. This can include:
Unfair prejudice is a powerful legal tool that provides a vital safeguard for shareholders in England and Wales. By understanding the two-part test of prejudice and unfairness, and by identifying the common types of prejudicial conduct, you can determine if you have a valid claim. A successful petition can lead to a court-ordered share buy-out, allowing you to exit the company and be fairly compensated for your investment.
At TBI, our barristers are experts in corporate and civil litigation. We can provide clear, strategic advice to help you evaluate your case, gather the necessary evidence, and guide you through the process of filing a petition. Our barristers can represent you in negotiations and in court, fighting to protect your rights and secure a fair outcome. Contact us today for a consultation.