When a loved one passes away and their will is read, it can be an emotionally charged time. But what if you suspect the will doesn’t reflect their true wishes? One of the most common and powerful grounds for challenging a will is a lack of testamentary capacity. This legal term refers to a person’s mental ability to make a valid will. If you believe the deceased lacked this capacity—perhaps due to a mental illness or a degenerative condition like dementia, the will may be invalid. This guide will provide a clear, detailed breakdown of the legal test for testamentary capacity and the steps you can take to challenge a will in England and Wales.
For a will to be considered a valid legal document, it must meet several requirements. It must be in writing, signed by the person making the will (the testator), and witnessed by two people. However, one of the most fundamental requirements is that the testator must have the mental capacity to make the will at the time they create it.
A will is a powerful legal document that determines how a person’s assets will be distributed after their death. Because of its significant impact, the law requires that the person making it is of “sound mind, memory, and understanding.” This means they must be mentally capable of making a reasoned and informed decision about their estate.
A person’s mental state directly affects their intentions. If a person is suffering from a mental illness or a delusion, their will may not accurately reflect what they would have done if they were of sound mind. This is why a lack of mental capacity is a key area for disputes, as it goes to the heart of whether the will truly represents the deceased person’s wishes.
The legal test for testamentary capacity is not based on a medical diagnosis alone; it is a legal test that assesses a person’s ability to understand their actions at the time they make a will. The test is a long-established common law principle.
The legal test for testamentary capacity is derived from the landmark case of Banks v Goodfellow from 1870. The case established a four-part test that a person must satisfy to have the capacity to make a will. A person challenging a will on this ground must provide sufficient evidence to raise a “real doubt” as to the testator’s capacity. If they do, the burden of proof shifts to those seeking to uphold the will to prove capacity.
The person making the will must understand that they are creating a legal document that will take effect after their death and that it will determine how their property is distributed. They must grasp the significance of the act.
The person must have a reasonable idea of the assets they own and the value of their estate. They don’t need to know the exact value of every item, but they must have a broad understanding of what they are disposing of.
The person must be able to comprehend and appreciate the claims of those who would normally be expected to benefit from their estate. This includes close family members, such as a spouse and children. They must consider these individuals and make a conscious decision to either include or exclude them.
The person must not be suffering from any mental illness or delusion that perverts their sense of right or influences their decisions about the will. The disorder does not have to be a severe illness, but it must be shown to have had a direct impact on the provisions of the will.
The law presumes that a person has testamentary capacity unless there is evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the person challenging the will is responsible for providing sufficient evidence to raise a “real doubt” about the deceased’s capacity. This is often the most difficult part of the process and requires a strong, well-supported case.
Building a successful case to challenge a will on the grounds of a lack of capacity requires more than just suspicion. You need to gather specific types of evidence to prove your claim.
Medical evidence is often the most powerful and important evidence in these cases. Medical records, doctor’s notes, and psychiatric evaluations can provide a clear picture of the deceased person’s mental state around the time the will was made. A diagnosis of a condition like dementia or Alzheimer’s can be a key piece of evidence, but it must be linked to the person’s mental state at the exact time the will was created.
Statements from people who knew the deceased person well can also be crucial. Friends, family, caregivers, and neighbours can provide a personal account of the deceased’s behavior, memory, and cognitive abilities around the time the will was made. This can provide important context and support the medical evidence.
The ‘Golden Rule’ is a best practice for legal professionals. It states that if a solicitor or will writer has any doubt about a person’s mental capacity—perhaps due to their age or a known illness—they should arrange for a medical professional to assess the person’s capacity before the will is signed. While it is not a legal requirement, a failure to follow the Golden Rule can raise a red flag in court and make a will easier to challenge.
Challenging a will is a complex legal process that must be approached with caution and expert guidance.
Before you take any action, you should consult with a legal professional. A barrister specialising in inheritance and estate disputes can assess the merits of your case, review the evidence, and advise you on the best course of action. They can determine if you have a strong enough case to proceed with a challenge.
Before issuing a claim in court, legal professionals must follow a pre-action protocol. This involves sending a formal letter to the executors of the will, outlining the grounds for the challenge and requesting a copy of the deceased’s medical records and other relevant documents. This step is a chance to resolve the matter out of court and avoid a costly legal battle.
If the pre-action protocol fails to resolve the dispute, you can issue a formal claim with the court. The case will then proceed to litigation, where evidence will be presented and the court will make a final decision on the validity of the will. If the court finds the will to be invalid, it will either revert to a previous will or the deceased’s estate will be distributed according to the rules of intestacy.
Contesting a will on the grounds of testamentary capacity is a serious and complex legal matter. However, if you have genuine concerns that a deceased person was not of sound mind when they made their will, the law provides a clear pathway for you to seek justice. By understanding the legal test, gathering strong evidence, and following the correct legal process, you can ensure that the deceased’s final wishes are honoured.
Testamentary capacity is a legal, not just a medical, test.
The test has four parts, as defined by Banks v Goodfellow.
Medical evidence is crucial for a successful claim.
The burden of proof is on the person challenging the will.
At TBI, our barristers are experts in inheritance and estate disputes. We can provide clear, strategic advice to help you evaluate your case, gather the necessary evidence, and guide you through the process of challenging a will. Our barristers can represent you in negotiations and in court, ensuring your case is presented with the highest level of expertise. Contact us today for a consultation to discuss how we can help you contest a will and secure a just outcome.