Home / News / Property & Boundary Disputes / When Siblings Can’t Agree: How to Resolve Inherited Property Disputes 

When Siblings Can’t Agree: How to Resolve Inherited Property Disputes 

19 Nov, 2025 | The Barristers Inc
Table of Contents
Do you have more questions?

Do you have more questions?

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Get In Touch

Inheriting a property can be a gift, but when siblings cannot agree on what to do with it, it can quickly become a source of immense stress, emotional turmoil, and financial strain. Disputes over inherited property can fracture family relationships beyond repair, often because the disagreements are rooted not just in money, but in years of personal history, unequal perceived contributions, and a deep emotional connection to the family home. At TBI, we understand the sensitive nature of these disputes. We have a wealth of experience in guiding families through these difficult times, providing a clear roadmap for resolution that prioritises a fair outcome and, wherever possible, the preservation of family relationships. This guide will take you through the common causes of these disputes and outline a structured approach to finding a resolution, from initial communication to formal legal action.

Common Causes of Sibling Disputes

  • Inherited property disputes are rarely about the property itself. Instead, the property becomes the focal point for deeper, unresolved issues. The root causes of these disagreements can be varied and complex, often stemming from different expectations and life circumstances. By understanding these underlying issues, it may be possible to find a path to resolution before the situation escalates.
  • One of the most frequent causes is divergent goals for the property. One sibling may want to sell the house immediately to access their inheritance for a down payment on a home, to pay off debts, or to invest. Another sibling may have a strong sentimental attachment and want to keep the house in the family, perhaps even living in it themselves. A third may see the property as a long-term rental investment and wish to rent it out. These differing aspirations are often irreconcilable without a structured legal process to find a fair solution. The law recognises these diverse interests and provides a framework for the court to consider each sibling’s position.
  • Another significant cause is unequal contributions to the deceased’s care. It is very common for one sibling to have taken on the primary role of caring for a parent in their later years, whether by living with them, managing their finances, or providing daily support. This sibling may feel that their significant sacrifices and contributions should be reflected in a greater share of the inheritance, particularly the family home. While this argument has a strong moral basis, without a legally executed will that explicitly states this, the law of England and Wales does not automatically grant this person a larger share. This can lead to deep-seated feelings of injustice and resentment.
  • Finally, the absence of a will, or intestacy, can be a major catalyst for disputes. In our previous guide on intestacy, we explained that when there is no will, the law dictates a rigid formula for distributing the estate. While this provides a legal solution, it may not align with the deceased’s unstated wishes or the family’s expectations. For example, if a parent told one child they could live in the house after they passed away, but the Intestacy Rules state that the property must be sold and the proceeds divided, a dispute is almost guaranteed.

The Role of Property Valuation

Before any meaningful negotiation or legal action can take place, it is essential to establish a factual and unbiased starting point. This is where an independent property valuation plays a critical role. A disagreement over a property’s value can derail any attempt at an informal resolution, as one sibling may believe the house is worth more than another is willing to accept.

To avoid this, it is highly advisable to instruct a qualified, independent valuer, such as a RICS (Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors) chartered surveyor, to provide an official valuation. This provides an objective, professional assessment of the property’s market value, based on comparable sales and other market factors. Having a single, jointly-agreed upon valuation eliminates the potential for disputes over price and provides a solid foundation for all future discussions. Whether the ultimate decision is to sell the property on the open market, or for one sibling to buy out the other’s share, the valuation provides a fair and accurate benchmark for all financial transactions. The court will almost always require such a valuation if the dispute escalates to legal proceedings.

First Steps for Resolution (Without a Lawsuit)

Engaging in legal action should always be considered a last resort. The process is not only expensive and time-consuming but can also cause permanent and irreparable damage to family relationships. Once a formal lawsuit is filed, it is very difficult to de-escalate the situation and return to amicable terms. The financial costs, including legal fees and court costs, can quickly erode a significant portion of the inheritance, leaving less for everyone involved. For these reasons, it is crucial to exhaust all possibilities for informal resolution before escalating to the courts. This includes an open dialogue and, if necessary, the intervention of a neutral third party.

Communication and Mediation

The first and most important step in resolving any dispute is to open a channel of communication. It is critical to try and understand each sibling’s position, their underlying motivations, and their desired outcome. This should be approached with empathy and a willingness to listen. Rather than starting with an aggressive position, try to begin the conversation with a focus on shared goals and an acknowledgment of the emotional significance of the property. For some, a simple conversation can be enough to uncover a creative solution, such as one sibling buying out the other’s share, or a decision to rent the property out and split the income.

When direct communication proves difficult or unproductive, mediation offers an excellent alternative. Mediation is a structured, voluntary process in which a neutral and impartial third party—the mediator—helps to facilitate a discussion between the disputing siblings. The mediator does not make a decision or take sides; instead, they help the parties communicate effectively, explore their interests, and work towards a mutually acceptable solution. Mediation is confidential, flexible, and significantly less expensive than going to court. It allows for creative, out-of-the-box solutions that a court may not be able to order. For example, a court may only be able to order a sale of the property, whereas a mediator might help the parties agree on a plan for one sibling to live there and pay a fair rent to the others. A settlement reached through mediation is legally binding and offers a final, amicable resolution.

When all attempts at informal resolution have failed, and the dispute remains unresolved, it may become necessary to seek formal legal remedies. The law of England and Wales provides specific mechanisms for resolving such disputes in court. These legal options are powerful tools designed to provide a definitive and legally binding resolution when co-owners of a property cannot agree on its future. It is crucial to have expert legal advice from the outset to understand your legal standing and to pursue the most appropriate course of action.

Claims Under TOLATA (Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996)

  • The primary legal tool for resolving property disputes between co-owners in England and Wales is the Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act 1996, commonly known as TOLATA. The Act gives the court extensive powers to make orders relating to property that is held in a trust of land, which an inherited property almost always is. Even if the will states that the property is to be given to the siblings equally, the law implies a trust of land. The siblings become both the beneficiaries and the trustees of the property, with a duty to act in each other’s best interests.
  • A TOLATA claim asks the court to resolve the dispute and can result in several different types of orders, depending on the circumstances of the case:
  • An order for the sale of the property: This is the most common outcome of a TOLATA claim. The court can order that the property be sold on the open market, and the proceeds divided according to the beneficial interests of the parties. This is a definitive solution that provides each sibling with their share of the cash.
  • An order requiring one party to buy out the other’s share: If one sibling wants to keep the property, the court can order that they must buy the other siblings’ shares at a professionally valued price. This allows the property to remain in the family while providing the other siblings with their rightful financial entitlement.
  • A declaration of beneficial interests: The court can make a formal declaration as to the extent of each sibling’s beneficial interest in the property. This is particularly useful in cases where there is a disagreement over the proportion of ownership.
  • An order for one person to occupy the property and pay rent: In cases where one sibling is living in the inherited property and is preventing its sale, the court can order them to pay occupational rent to the other beneficiaries to compensate them for being excluded from the property. This provides a fair financial remedy while the dispute is being resolved.
  • When making an order, the court will consider a wide range of factors, including the purpose for which the land was held, the intentions of the person who created the trust (the deceased), and the financial circumstances and needs of the beneficiaries.

Challenging the Will

While a TOLATA claim focuses on how to manage the inherited property, a separate legal process involves challenging the validity of the will itself. This is a powerful, but difficult, legal action that aims to have the entire will declared invalid. If successful, it would result in the deceased’s estate being distributed according to the Intestacy Rules. A will can be challenged on a number of specific grounds, all of which require significant evidence to prove:

  • Lack of Testamentary Capacity: This is one of the most common grounds for a challenge. It argues that the deceased lacked the mental capacity to understand and approve the contents of their will at the time it was made. The legal test for this, known as the Banks v Goodfellow test, requires that the person understood the nature of their act, the extent of their property, the claims of those who might expect to benefit, and was not suffering from any mental disorder that would affect their decision.
  • Undue Influence: This alleges that the deceased was coerced or manipulated into making the will in a way they would not have otherwise. This is a difficult ground to prove, as it requires evidence of coercion that overbore the deceased’s free will.
  • Improper Execution: A will must be executed in accordance with the strict requirements of the Wills Act 1837. This means it must be in writing, signed by the deceased, and witnessed by two people who are present at the same time and attest the signature in the deceased’s presence. A failure to follow these rules can render the will invalid.
  • Fraud or Forgery: This alleges that the will was a forgery or that the deceased was fraudulently misled into signing it.
  • Challenging a will is a complex and emotionally charged process that requires a strong legal strategy. It is separate from a TOLATA claim and should only be pursued if there are clear grounds for believing the will is legally invalid.

How TBI Can Assist You

Handling an inherited property dispute, whether with a sibling or another relative, is a difficult and delicate process. The combination of financial pressure and emotional baggage can make a fair resolution seem impossible. At TBI, our expert barristers specialise in civil litigation and have extensive experience in handling complex inheritance and property disputes. We provide clear, straightforward legal advice to help you understand your legal options and to provide a pathway toward a fair and definitive resolution.

Our team offers a wide range of services tailored to your specific needs:

  • Initial Case Assessment: We will conduct a thorough review of your case, providing a realistic assessment of your legal position and outlining the most effective strategy.
  • Negotiation and Mediation: We are skilled negotiators and advocates who can represent you in mediation, ensuring your interests are protected and working towards a settlement that works for all parties.
  • Formal Legal Representation: If informal resolution fails, we are ready to represent you in court. We will prepare and file all necessary legal documents, including applications under TOLATA, and provide powerful courtroom advocacy to ensure a just outcome.
  • Challenging a Will: Our barristers are adept at handling challenges to a will, gathering evidence and building a strong legal case to support your claim.
  • At TBI, we understand the emotional weight of these disputes. We are committed to providing not only exceptional legal expertise but also a compassionate and supportive approach. We are here to guide you through this challenging time, providing the clarity and confidence you need to resolve your dispute and secure your future.

Get Started Today

Cant find the answer youre looking for? Please chat to our friendly team.

Search

Find articles, FAQs, lawyers, and more

Press Enter to search or ESC to close

Secret Link